3 ms·
There are no federal ID's other than a passport in the US. Unless they pass a new federal identification law what they are doing is unlawful. This is what peo
by dogma1138 10y ago
There are no federal ID's other than a passport in the US.
Unless they pass a new federal identification law what they are doing is unlawful.
This is what people often seem to miss, and it also is going on in the EU sadly too much.
The Federal government was granted certain powers by law, it can't just decide that it would grab more power or interfere in things it was intentionally prohibited from interfering.
This isn't because everything the fed's do are malicious but because the separation of power between the state and local governments is a key element of how the US government and political system is structured.
The federal government can't crouch over state rights any more than a state can decide to reinstitute slavery or ban women from attending school, once you start messing with that things can get murky really fast.
- Analemma_ 10y ago> Unless they pass a new federal identification law what they are doing is unlawful. How so? The Federal government can set ID standards in areas that it has jurisdiction over, and reject IDs that don't meet these standards in its jurisdiction, which is all that's happening here. Like other federal levers over state behavior (No highway funding if your drinking age is under 21!), this is grating, but it's not illegal. This has been going on in one form or another for decades and has been consistently ruled legal, as long as its not an unfunded mandate on the states.
- dragonwriter 10y agoThere are, in fact, federal IDs other than passports. They include resident alien IDs, military IDs, and numerous others.