3 ms·
Unfortunately this is really common on HN nowadays. What I find really interesting about Tesla (and SpaceX and HyperLoop) criticism is that people think it wil
by grecy 10y ago
Unfortunately this is really common on HN nowadays.
What I find really interesting about Tesla (and SpaceX and HyperLoop) criticism is that people think it will fail for what it doesn't do, instead of focusing on what it does do. What they don't realize is that all products in history that got hugely successful didn't do a ton of stuff initially. They just did some things really well.
Early washing machines were noisy as hell and got unbalanced all the time. But who cares? they washed clothes and everyone wanted one.
Early TVs were massive things with fussy screens and only in B&W.
The first iPhone was extremely slow and only had EDGE.
But rather than focus on what all of those things don't do, you only need to realize they do something really well, and that's why they are a huge success.
Even if the Tesla can't drive itself too well in heavy snow, or if the range is crap in really, really cold weather - WHO CARES? There are still tens of millions of people on earth that will lap them up because of the list of things they do so well.
Products don't fail or succeed because of what they don't do. They fail or succeed because of what they do do.
- planteen 10y agoI agree this attitude is common on HN. But is it really a recent development? Engineers are skeptical by nature. I feel like engineers are especially skeptical of marketing and "idea" people.
- mturmon 10y agoIt is not a recent development. Sometimes an early attitude correction can divert the still-growing thread into more constructive comments.
- forgetsusername 10y ago>Unfortunately this is really common on HN nowadays. I see things differently. Anyone who criticized Theranos was met with the same reaction, "Everyone on HN is so negative!" But the questions were valid. Look what happened. The same thing is occurring with Tesla. Yes, there is fantastic work being done, but many people here can't separate marketing from the real world. It's shocking, frankly.
- tcoppi 10y agoAre you suggesting that Tesla is defrauding investors and regulators, as Theranos did?
- planteen 10y agoWhen I looked into the Solar City after the announcement of the Tesla buying them, these "Solar Bonds" did make me a bit uneasy. Their interest rate implies junk... https://solarbonds.solarcity.com/ https://solarbonds.solarcity.com/
- FireBeyond 10y agoNo, he's suggesting, in exactly his own words, "many people can't separate marketing from the real world".
- tcoppi 10y agoIf the "marketing" Tesla is putting out is not part of the real world, that would be fraud, which was the situation with Theranos.
- forgetsusername 10y ago>Are you suggesting that Tesla is defrauding investors and regulators, as Theranos did? I'm suggesting that there's a lack of critical analysis applied to what are, essentially, Tesla press releases. Like when it was implied that people were sexist for questioning the genius of Elizabeth Holmes, because she was changing the world and all that, according to the press releases. Again, I have no problem with being a Tesla fan. I probably come off as a "hater" here because I like to play Devil's Advocate and it's a pretty one-sided discussion on HackerNews (expectedly). I think what they're doing is fantastic. But give some credit to other companies who are also doing good things for this space, people's safety and the planet.
- bosdev 10y agoTo be fair, being enthusiastic and positive about the future isn't that useful of a comment. There is only one way to say 'Elon's vision is right and it will happen,' but there are countless, interesting, ways to point out how it might fail. So after the first few excited comments come in, often the only novel thing to contribute is a counter point. This doesn't mean that the majority of people aren't optimistic about the future, just that their opinion has already been expressed.
- komali2 10y agoThat's a bit pessimistic. "I wonder if Elon will go down path A...." "Interesting that the battery is now x, this is probably a result of Y technology they developed last year." Etc. I don't find it hard to discuss a topic in a positive light at all.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoIt's interesting to think about the ways your opponent might capture your pieces, but it's just as interesting and just as important to think about the ways you might capture theirs. Time we spend bickering about whether electric cars are ready is time not spent talking about the new grid, the new architecture, the new social organization that will form around these (to me obviously) imminent technologies. I don't think "how it could succeed" is less interesting than "how it could fail". And if I expect something to succeed, frankly the failure speculation starts to get a bit boring. It's a bit personal for me because I am pursuing a high-setback business model in my startup and so people always want to talk about the looming dangers they see. It starts to get boring, because I expect a certain number of failures, and I intend to work through them. What's interesting to mr is whether the first principles analysis is right, and how the plan looks from a Zen perspective... Not is everything right, but am I applying pressure in the right place today given the conditions.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoIt's interesting to think about the ways your opponent might capture your pieces, but it's just as interesting and just ad important to think about the ways you might capture theirs. Time we spent bickering about whether electric cars are ready is time not spent talking about the new grid, the new architecture, the new social organization that will form around these (to me obviously) imminent technologies. I don't think "how it could succeed" is less interesting than "how it could fail". And if I expect something to succeed, frankly the failure speculation starts to get a bit boring.