3 ms·
> The decision to hive off the U.S. life insurance operations—into a new company called Brighthouse Financial—happened because of strategic and regulatory reaso
by snowwrestler 10y ago
> The decision to hive off the U.S. life insurance operations—into a new company called Brighthouse Financial—happened because of strategic and regulatory reasons. Company officials have said the new company will be small enough to avoid federal designation as “systemically important” and thus should be able to sidestep potentially stiff capital rules.
This is a key paragraph and it should be understood that this is an intended effect of the regulations.
The "Dodd-Frank" bill that was passed in the wake of the financial crisis gave the Federal Reserve new responsibility and authority to regulate "systemically important" financial institutions of any industry. These are the companies that would come to mind when you think "too big too fail." Prior to this bill, the Fed only had authority over commercial banks.
If a company gets designated as "systemically important," it has to meet higher capital ratio requirements and other extra regulatory hurdles. This is to (try to) make it less likely that the company will fail. But it will obviously have an impact on financial performance.
Some companies--like GE and now MetLife--instead choose to downsize their financial operations to get them under the "too big to fail" line.
This has the same effect as if the federal government "broke them up"--but it was accomplished via incentive instead of direct action.
The potential downside is that large companies do have some financial advantages, and foreign companies don't have the same regulatory requirement. (Their U.S. subsidiaries do, but not their business overseas.) Thus, over time we might see capital flow out of the U.S.
- tvanantwerp 10y agoReminds me of when I lived in Copenhagen. There were laws against businesses being opened on Sunday. But if your store was small enough, you were exempt. And so I regularly saw two or three tiny and separate H&M stores side-by-side with each other.
- jbpetersen 10y agoI was not expecting HN to make me think about the potential for unwavering capitalism to be adorable.
- matt4077 10y agoIt's a bit different because they're actually selling (parts of) that business unit – a holding is evaluated as single entity. Oh, and H&M frequently does small shops in locations without such laws as well. They often have separate stores for men/women/children or along segments of style (i. e. stores with only formal menswear). It could be marketing, availability of retails space or an attempt to remain flexible. It's also not too hard to make such laws airtight, or to leave some details to the executive branch which can react much faster.
- jomamaxx 10y agoThe Fed is technically a privately owned entity, which is really a caba of banks (banks in the US 'own shares' in the Fed and basically run the show). It's at arms length form congress - as it should be - for monetary operations. But for regulatory issues? The US let's a group of banks 'self regulate' - moreover regulate other industries? The seems kind of crazy to me. I see the need for 'smart regulation' esp. by bodies that are as 'independent' as possible, but in this case 'independent' could mean 'conflict of interest' which is kind of the opposite of what we would want, no?
- snowwrestler 10y agoBy "the Fed," I meant to refer to the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve, which is not privately owned; it is an independent agency of the U.S. federal government. It was created by an act of Congress, the governors are appointed by the President and confirmed by the Senate, it makes monetary decisions, it has regulatory powers, heck it even has its own federal police force and a .gov domain name. Some private banks do have representatives on the boards of the regional Federal Reserve banks. This is to balance the fact that they are essentially forced to keep some of their capital in those banks.