3 ms·
But the OP asked "What is the state of C++ vs. Rust?" and I answered "C is still significantly faster than Rust which follows that C++ is too" That is still tru
by bjourne 10y ago
But the OP asked "What is the state of C++ vs. Rust?" and I answered "C is still significantly faster than Rust which follows that C++ is too" That is still true because we are discussing the current state of the languages and what you wrote does not affect that.
Btw, the last time this topic was discussed we measured the performance using a microbenchmark. Here is the C version: https://gist.github.com/bjourne/4599a387d24c80906475b26b8ac9e5b7 https://gist.github.com/bjourne/4599a387d24c80906475b26b8ac9... None of the Rust aficionados were able to produce a Rust program (using the nightly build of Rust even) that came close.
- steveklabnik 10y agoYes, but you then also went on to say that no language will ever do it. Rust _has_ consistently beaten C on many of these benchmarks in the past, and continues to remain very close in the ones that it's not. I actually don't think microbenchmarks are a good way to think about performance anyway. There's two reasons: First, Rust's safety guarantees let you get away with more dangerous things. Consider scoped threads, or non-atomic reference counting.[1] You _could_ write this in C, and you'd do so for a microbenchmark, but not for a real codebase, as it's far too dangerous. Or, you might do it, but end up with bugs that you don't detect, that aren't there in the Rust version. 1: http://blog.faraday.io/saved-by-the-compiler-parallelizing-a-loop-with-rust-and-rayon/ http://blog.faraday.io/saved-by-the-compiler-parallelizing-a... Secondly, microbenchmarks are often "can the best person at language X write something faster than the best person at language Y"? I don't think that's nearly as interesting as "When an average programmer of languages X and Y write a program, which is faster?" Rust's default patterns and style is already extremely fast. It's not a guarantee, mind you, but for real-world usage, it's the average case that matters more.
- bjourne 10y agoNo, I didn't say that no language will ever beat C. I can't predict the future. Rust has not beaten any highly optimized microbenchmarks that I know of. Like it beats C on the mandelbrot benchmark, but is then beaten by Swift, suggesting that the C implementation isn't very good (http://benchmarksgame.alioth.debian.org/u64q/performance.php?test=mandelbrot http://benchmarksgame.alioth.debian.org/u64q/performance.php...). The reason we have micro benchmarks is because it is so hard to reason about the average case. Yes, code written in Rust could on average be faster than C due to its safety features. But so could Python, Java or Haskell so we're back were we started and can't say anything about relative language performance. It's a small niche, yes, but some people absolutely need to squeeze out every gram of performance, and they should continue to prefer C over Rust.
- igouy 10y ago(The C Mandelbrot program is considerably less extreme.)