5 ms·
Summary: Google Cloud Storage is now (significantly) cheaper, faster and more available than Amazon S3. Also, it supports multi-region whereas S3 does not. Lo
by user5994461 10y ago
Summary: Google Cloud Storage is now (significantly) cheaper, faster and more available than Amazon S3.
Also, it supports multi-region whereas S3 does not.
Love the direction Google Cloud is taking <3
- Touche 10y agoThe best thing about Google Cloud is the Console. I haven't seen a comparable console for managed services. Think about the UX nightmare that is the AWS Management Console and take that complexity and separate it out neatly and make everything available in a fast search box and you have Google Cloud Console. It's the primary reason I've switched over to Datastore and App Engine.
- RhodesianHunter 10y agoHmm. I actually really like the AWS management console. I find that everything is logically organized and easy to manipulate. That could just be because I've been using it for a long time.
- rstupek 10y agoI agree with you. Google's console is neigh unusable
- tehbeard 10y agoWhat about ~~reliability~~ durability of storage (bitrot, not the uptime)? I didn't see any information comparing this, is it practically the same across both? edit: durability, not reliability.
- shshhdhs 10y agoI think that you mean durability
- klodolph 10y agoAt this point, durability is hard to compare because the published numbers are total fantasies. S3's published durability is 11 9s, which I've complained about in the past because the chance that the human race will be wiped out next year by an asteroid impact is probably not too far from one in a hundred million, which puts a hard cap on durability at around eight nines. Then ask yourself, "is the chance that someone made a mistake in designing the system which causes catastrophic data loss higher or lower than one in a billion?" Yes, the number is total fantasy. The only actual meaning of the durability SLA is that if the durability SLA is violated, your cloud provider will give you some service credits. If the data is worth more than some service credits, this is small consolation. In practice, if you absolutely must compare durability, what you are trying to do is compare the frequency of black swan events, but actually estimating the frequency of those events requires access to proprietary data which you don't have. Both providers are undoubtedly storing the data in multiple locations on multiple types of storage systems with multiple layers of error coding. After thinking about this issue earlier, the most likely data loss scenario in my opinion was "I get injured, the company hires someone incompetent who doesn't pay the bill for a year while I'm in the hospital."
- ghshephard 10y agoI've always seen durability from the perspective of Amazon telling me, "Look, we're going to lose your data - here's how quickly you should expect it to rot." Basically, take the number of objects you have, and multiply by: 1xe-7 each year. So, if I have 400 Billion objects, (4e11) - Amazon is going to lose approx 40,000 of them/year, and I should be prepared for that. With regards to your Asteroid Strike (And other disasters such as Riot, Insurrection, War, Hurricane, Earthquake, etc...) - these are all disclaimed in the agreement you sign with Amazon under a clause known as Force Majeure - which essential means, "Acts of God". The durability clause comes into effect under the normal course of business, not exceptional events. For those types of scenarios, you'll want to have a business continuity plan in place, not a durability formula on your storage service.
- klodolph 10y agoYour numbers are off... according to Amazon's durability notes, if you have 400 billion objects then Amazon would expect to lose less than 40 per year, not 40,000. And for that level of storage, you're paying Amazon something like a quarter million dollars per year to do storage for you. My point is that there is no point in taking that kind of durability guarantee into account, because there are much bigger threats to data storage. It's kind of like saying that driving by car is very safe if you don't get into an accident--while technically true, it's not a very useful fact.
- billhathaway 10y agoFrom https://cloud.google.com/storage/docs/storage-classes https://cloud.google.com/storage/docs/storage-classes [paraphrased] All storage classes are designed for 99.999999999% durability As the previous replies to your comment mention, at that order of magnitude there are many other causes of data loss to worry about. Disclaimer: work for an Alphabet company but not doing anything related to this.
- sashaafm 10y agoCould you please provide a more detailed comparison? :)
- user5994461 10y agoHere's an old article with lots of numbers and performance graphs: http://blog.zachbjornson.com/2015/12/29/cloud-storage-performance.html http://blog.zachbjornson.com/2015/12/29/cloud-storage-perfor...
- theDoug 10y agoWe're all working hard to be everyone's favorite. Thank you!