7 ms·
If elected, Clinton would support an “Encryption Commission” to help feds
- MichaelBurge 10y agoI don't know that Trump cares much about encryption by itself, except perhaps indirectly by bolstering the NSA to protect against foreign attacks. Though, Hillary blowing a few million(or tens of millions) on some cryptography research wouldn't be the worst thing a president could do. After Wikileaks, Trump might be more sympathetic to whistleblowers like Snowden. He seems to be making corruption a central point in his more recent rallies. And I can't imagine Clinton would have much sympathy for whistleblowers, probably associating them with Assange.
- daxorid 10y agoThis is no surprise. She has long wanted to create a "Manhattan Project" to backdoor crypto Why the infosec community overwhelmingly supports her is an ongoing point of confusion for me.
- GordonS 10y agoMaybe because the alternative is Trump. Which is the lesser evil?
- hprotagonist 10y agoAlso because what she wants is a technical impossibility, as she (and feinstein and burr) will learn in time. It's the natural approach of centrists to try to take a compromise, middle-of-the-road position. Usually that's wise; sometimes the world is quantized in a way that means you cannot split the difference.
- jwtadvice 10y agoI think it's probably this. The primary strategy by the Democratic Party and by establishment circles has been to make Trump seem as unpalatable as possible, hoping to make him so much less desirable than the historically untrusted establishment candidate that she may pull off a win at the ballot box. Since the first-past-the-post electoral system functions to magnify strategic voting and minimize voting for values, the impression that Trump is a more dangerous and despicable candidate (traded by campaign dollars and personal connections to create information bubbles over the electorate), this strategy is not only effective but also smart. In the end we've got two candidates we really don't want, a complete lack of examination of policy, and a 'default' to an establishment candidate seeking further erosion of civil liberties, checks and balances and civilian participation in government.
- matt4077 10y agoTrump is simply unacceptable, there's no establishment conspiracy required. In fact I thought the major media outlets waited far too long to give up the pretense of normalcy. It's only the last few weeks that journalists get to write the by-now established fact that he's a lunatic. But I share the concern about HC, considering she's just far too conservative on major issues especially with regards to encryption/"national security" etc. She's not corrupt, or evil or crooked or lying or smelling as sulfur, she's just (imho) wrong. Let's hope there will be people around her who can have a positive impact on her thinking.
- wernercd 10y ago> She's not corrupt, or evil or crooked or lying or smelling as sulfur, she's just (imho) wrong. If she's not... why did she delete thousands of emails that were illegally on a private server? Why did she lie about the source of protests and then leave American's to die? For someone who isn't corrupt/evil/crooked... she sure does do a lot of corrupt/evil/crooked shit.
- jwtadvice 10y ago> If she's not... why did she delete thousands of emails that were illegally on a private server? Because she was covering up criminal behavior. You don't have to be evil to cover up criminal behavior. It's a very rational thing to do. > Why did she lie about the source of protests and then leave American's to die? She didn't want Americans to understand that their intelligence and military communities had supported extremist forces in Libya to oust a geopolitical opponent, and that these extremist forces themselves aren't particularly welcoming to America or its values. She didn't want comparisons to 9/11 and the Saudi support for those attacks on our home country. She left Americans to die because she and the administration could not muster the support to mobilize, against international law, troop movements across borders as the activity in Libya had until that point been special operations and irregular warfare. It would have been difficult to breach international law to engage an enemy in the CIA annex to the State Department buildings - bases that on the record didn't exist. All of this is very rational. Al Capone, similarly, was a very rational person, and not "evil" whatsoever. A rational person looks after themselves, their interests and the activities and events they stewart.
- toomuchtodo 10y ago> Maybe because the alternative is Trump. Which is the lesser evil? This is what we're reduced to? Voting for the "lesser evil"? Who in a first world country should tolerate this? I'm not voting, but I hope Trump wins. Hopefully the resulting 4 years are so terrible that voters never tolerate a candidate like Trump or Clinton again. EDIT: I'm against Clinton's encryption policies, her pro-fracking stance, her war hawk attitude, her backroom political dealings, and her stance on privatizing social security, just to start (almost forgot! The ACA is "good enough" and we won't ever see single payer). I don't care if she's the "lesser evil", that she's a woman, whatever. She's not just a terrible candidate, but also a terrible person.
- gjolund 10y agoSame. I am so tired of the "Trump is worse" rationalization.
- eridius 10y agoRationalization? It's not a rationalization, it's true. By all appearances Trump would be a national disaster.
- dragonwriter 10y agoEveryone in a democracy should work to get the best possible options in an election, but then choose intelligently the best (which is the same as the least bad) option in terms of expected result of voting when the election arrives. A failure to secure the options you'd like to have in the head up to an election may prompt reflection and longer-term changes in approach to try to get better results in the future, but doesn't change that you ought to make the best (which may merely be least bad) available choice at the election.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y ago> Hopefully the resulting 4 years are so terrible that voters never tolerate a candidate like Trump or Clinton again. Accelerationism is irresponsible, and the human harm it will cause is irreparable.
- daodedickinson 10y agoI'm voting Trump because I feel Hillary is unimpeachable in the bad sense of the term. I hope they both get their many days in court and are prosecuted for any wrongdoing. If Trump is president, the media will do it's job, Twitter, Google, Facebook, the networks and papers will work diligently against him, and Trump has many enemies in the GOP. I hope for bipartisan opposition to Trump to reign in and deter in the future the imperial powers the presidency has accrued.
- StanislavPetrov 10y agoThere are plenty of alternatives. One is Jill Stein (who I support). The fact that 99% of voters will vote for a completely worthless, amoral candidate is an indictment on our population - it has nothing to do with lack of decent options.
- zzzcpan 10y ago> Why the infosec community overwhelmingly supports her They do? I thought infosec community doesn't play this game. States are their natural enemies.
- amalcon 10y agoFirst, because not everyone in the infosec community is a single issue voter. Second, because to all appearances so far, her opponent would be at least as bad on this issue. Remember, Trump briefly advocated a boycott of Apple if they wouldn't decrypt a phone for the FBI.
- Shivetya 10y agothere is one real reason to vote for her opponent, regardless how odd he may be at times. Congress and the Press will give her a pass to do as she wants whereas they will hound Trump day in and day out. We need an active press, not one that thinks itself part of the government. One that doesn't take orders from the Administration and one that isn't afraid to ask the questions that need to be asked.
- eanzenberg 10y ago>>Congress and the Press will give her a pass to do as she wants whereas they will hound Trump day in and day out. Wat. You mean like congress gives Obama a pass to do what he wants? Are you thick?
- StanislavPetrov 10y ago>You mean like congress gives Obama a pass to do what he wants? Yea, I can't believe all the scrutiny he is getting for bombing Yemen and launching a new war in Iraq. The criticism from the press has been astounding!
- jordanb 10y agoI've always been a huge Obama supporter (slightly disillusioned in recent years) but Obama, honestly, has been given an ENORMOUS pass on his drone assassinations and on his war against whistleblowers.
- eanzenberg 10y agoSure lets stop assassinating islamic terrorists and give them the due process they deserv...owait looks like theyre beheading civilians again lul..
- whybroke 10y agoBecause he leaves his supporters to assume his agenda is theirs by never explicitly stating it: Against backdoor crypto? so is Trump. For a backdoor crypto, so is Trump.
- dragonwriter 10y agoProbably because while she is persistently (at least publicly) ignorant in advocating mutually incompatible positions involving getting around encryption while protecting legitimate privacy and security rights of everyone who isnt a terrorist, and in suggesting that these mutually incompatible goals could be met with sufficient application of technical expertise, her opponents only statements on the issue have been on the side of unconditional surrender of access to the security apparatus without acknowledging that there are legitimate privacy and security concerns. Hillary's position, if pursued as she has laid it out, would involve a bunch of money being spent, much of it going to infosec experts, with the result that the impossible thing she says she seeks would be shown to be impossible.
- davesque 10y agoWhile there are certain issues on which I don't agree with Clinton, here's why I'm still voting for her: she believes in man-made climate change and, in my opinion (I know a lot of people don't agree with me on this), a vote for one of the third-party candidates is largely wasted.
- adam12 10y agoThat is her public view. edit: How concerned about climate change could she be? She was for the TPP and she hasn't said anything about DAPL. > a vote for one of the third-party candidates is largely wasted. No. They will learn from this. Maybe Ranked Choice Voting will catch on.
- jwtadvice 10y agoHer private view is that fracking should be expanded quite liberally - as was disclosed in hacked emails - and that diversification of energy sources is useful for thwarting the economic influence that oil-and-gas-producing nations (such as Russia) can muster. I mean, it's smart. But it is in no way honest.
- programminggeek 10y agoWhy can't women make climate change too?
- liquidise 10y agoWhat possible relevance does this statement have to the topic of an encryption commission?
- davesque 10y agoWhy is the context of this article not relevant? Sure, the fact that she thinks encryption should be back-doored is foolish. But what's more foolish? Not believing in man-made climate change (her main opponent's position) or not believing in strong encryption? That's not even considering the question of which candidate would be more willing to change their views in response to logical arguments. In my opinion, the answer to that question should be obvious.
- gjolund 10y agoTypical apologist bullshit.
- sctb 10y agoWe detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12748319 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12748319 and marked it off-topic.
- jwtadvice 10y agoThe article itself is actually very generous to Clinton, as it primarily questions Trump's policies, features a ridiculing picture of him, and praises Clinton's policy documents (focusing, actually, on the number of pages rather than their clarity, consistency or purposes). They also snub Trump for questioning whether the hacks of the DNC were supported by the government of Russia. In doing so this article falls prey to much of what plagues the media during the election cycle. Broadly aligned against particular candidates and willing to take widely biased and selective approaches toward writing and editing about them, they fail to say much of anything substantive at all. For instance this article can't come up with what a good policy might look like, any particular appraisal of either candidate's policies (it merely cites pages and makes an issue of known Clinton's backdoor policies). The article mentions that both candidates consider Snowden a traitor, with Trump explicitly using the word and Clinton calling for Snowden to be extradited to the United States under investigation for violating the Espionage Act. Reading between the lines the article emphasizes that Silicon Valley doesn't understand or trust the policies from either candidate, but appears to have a stronger majority support for Clinton due to issues not related to either campaign promises or policy directions. EDIT: People below in the thread take issue with the term "libelous" so I replaced it with "ridiculing".
- dogma1138 10y ago>The article mentions that both candidates consider Snowden a traitor, with Trump explicitly using the word and Clinton calling for Snowden to be extradited to the United States under investigation for violating the Espionage Act. Only 15% of American believe that Snowden is a hero, 30% call him a traitor outright and only 25% of them believe that he should be offered any type of deal/pardon. http://www.newsmax.com/Newsfront/edward-snowden-rasmussen-poll-hero-russia/2016/09/23/id/749866/ http://www.newsmax.com/Newsfront/edward-snowden-rasmussen-po... So both candidates either appeal too or represent to the vox populi.
- jwtadvice 10y agoI think that's a fair point. Our republic, much like many historical republics including (crossing immediately the Godwin line) the Weimar Republic, are fervently nationalistic and willing - through fear, state disinformation, and through prejudice - to support cases against liberty in support of centralized autonomous power. While the youth population of America either broadly support Snowden or are deadlocked (depending on the poll), the more religious and jingoistic elements of the American public and those whose generations participated in World and Cold wars have been easy to convince that civil liberty is something cheap to trade for consolidated power.
- StanislavPetrov 10y agoIts simply astounding that in the 21st century the overwhelming favorite to become the ruler of the "free world" literally doesn't know how to use a computer. She doesn't even know how to read and send email on a computer. Absolutely frightening. http://thehill.com/policy/national-security/267727-clinton-didnt-know-how-to-access-email-by-computer-state-dept http://thehill.com/policy/national-security/267727-clinton-d...
- jordanb 10y agoI'm becoming very worried about what an increasingly likely Clinton presidency means for privacy. The FBI carried a ton of water for Clinton with the email investigation. We already know what the FBI's top legislative priority is. And now she owes thim a big one. Then you have all the Wikileaks hacking. I think it's probable that Clinton will see this as further demonstration of the "lawlessness" of the Internet and the need to assert federal authority over the net. Finally you have the fact that Clinton was already a Dianne Feinstein on this issue. There was a leak where a staffer contemplated getting Clinton to say something good about Snowden or whistle-blowers while she was fighting off Bernie but admitted that it was against her nature to take that position. I really think that Clinton is going to be a cornucopia of goodies for the police state and the panopticon. (Disclosure: I'm a Bernie supporter and I've early voted for Stein).
- nv-vn 10y agoWho in the intelligence community believes that it was undeniably Russia who hacked the DNC? And why is this article advocating for Clinton when her policy is pretty much just as bad: she wants Snowden extradited and she wants backdoors in encryption. Worst of all is her claim that Snowden could have done the same legally; I'm surprised her fact checkers didn't notice this one [1]. Other than the more explicit language and the part about executing Snowden, they basically said the same thing. A piece like this should have instead highlighted the people who are actually on our side: Bernie Sanders, Rand Paul, Jill Stein, and Gary Johnson (2/4 of which have sadly been knocked out of the election, with the remaining 2 having no chance of winning). [1] http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2015/oct/14/hillary-clinton/clinton-says-nsa-leaker-snowden-failed-use-whistle/ http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2015/oct/...