5 ms·
Diversity of thought is not itself a good thing. That is, a group with more opinions among its members is not necessarily any better / more moral / more effecti
by snowwrestler 10y ago
Diversity of thought is not itself a good thing. That is, a group with more opinions among its members is not necessarily any better / more moral / more effective than a group with fewer opinions.
Facebook is not "stronger" than the Democratic National Committee or the ACLU or Heritage Foundation because it has a broader array of political opinions among its staff and leadership than those groups do. The organizations simply have different reasons for existing.
What we should concern ourselves with as a society is freedom of thought, freedom of expression, freedom of association. This is different from diversity. In fact these freedoms eventually reduce diversity of thought, as we influence each other.
For example, the belief that slavery should be legal is no longer widely held in the U.S. That is a reduction in "thought diversity" from 160 years ago. And I highly doubt that Mark Zuckerberg would keep a board member who advocated for the return of slavery, in the name of "diversity of thought."
The freedoms listed above include the freedoms to disagree, to dissociate. It would not be unpatriotic or somehow wrong for Facebook to break ties with Thiel based on political disagreement. After all Zuckerberg has already done the opposite: he has sunk millions into efforts to convince the country to pass immigration reform. This despite knowing that a huge number of Facebook customers (and perhaps staff) don't want immigration reform.
If it's ok to create organizational relationships based on shared political beliefs, I don't see how it's wrong to break relationships based on political beliefs.
So: I find the appeal to "diversity of thought" to be not very compelling. The reality is that Zuckerberg probably thinks that cutting off Thiel would cause himself and his company more harm than good.
- ThomPete 10y agoDiversity is the very reason you and I even exist. So whether you like it or not it's one of the best things if you care about progress of any sorts.
- snowwrestler 10y agoLet's say Facebook added David Duke to their board. That would significantly increase the diversity of thought: Duke would bring many ideas and beliefs to the board that the current board members don't hold. Would that be better or worse for social progress? See, social progress is not just a spreading-out of more and more and more social ideas. It is a definite direction. Less slavery, not more. More tolerance, not less. Less sexual assault, not more. Social progress requires decisions and commitments. It requires people to change their minds, which means discarding one idea for another. Not trying to hold more and more contradictory ideas in their heads at the same time. Zuckerberg has every right to decide to keep Thiel on the FB board. But he also has the right to ask Thiel to leave, and doing so would not be any less principled than keeping him. Both decisions rest on the same principle, which is that Zuckerberg is free to make his own decisions about who he associates with.
- ThomPete 10y agoYou are taking a point made in about diversity in general and applying it to a single case. I hope you understand what's wrong about that.
- snowwrestler 10y agoI'm making the point that one cannot talk about diversity in general. The word means very different things in different contexts. Political beliefs are not the same thing as race or gender.
- ThomPete 10y agoOf course you can talk about diversity in general. It doesn't actually mean different things in different context but it has different consequences IMO.
- snowwrestler 10y agoWith respect, I don't think you've thought about this very carefully. If you feel you have, I'd be interested in your response to any of my detailed points above. edit: softened the tone
- ThomPete 10y agoThe difference we are having is not with the details but with the fundamental principle you approach this from vs. how I approach it. Diversity is by default at good thing by exception a bad thing. Thats my base point and I thought about that quite a lot.