5 ms·
Overpopulation is kind of a myth. Population growth rates are plummeting globally and below replacement in some places. Global population is expected to peak th
by ch4s3 10y ago
Overpopulation is kind of a myth. Population growth rates are plummeting globally and below replacement in some places. Global population is expected to peak then decline well before hitting the Earth's carrying capacity.
- reflexive 10y ago> below replacement in some places And in other places, the total fertility rate is over 8x. > Global population is expected to peak then decline ORLY, "expected" by whom? Is it the same people who expected mosquitoes to be extinct by the end of the 20th century because people don't ride horses anymore?
- gertef 10y agoWhat's this about horses? Google isn't finding relevant links (except that mosquitos and horses are correlated)
- reflexive 10y agoAs I recall, the argument was that the main breeding grounds for mosquitoes were horse stables and swamps. The horses would be replaced by cars, and the swamps would be drained to make room for highways and factories, thus leading to the mosquito's extinction.
- clock_tower 10y agoExpected by the UN, as the demographic transition spreads. See the following as a starting point: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographic_transition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographic_transition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sub-replacement_fertility https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sub-replacement_fertility https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birth_dearth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birth_dearth
- reflexive 10y agoYou're a little out of date. "new analysis suggests that the world’s population will keep rising through 2100, and not flatten around 2050 as has been widely assumed". https://www.technologyreview.com/s/530866/un-predicts-new-global-population-boom/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/530866/un-predicts-new-gl... There's a lot of problems in your old analysis, including the fact that sub-replacement fertility trends that affected Europe and East Asia aren't catching on in other parts of the world.
- antisthenes 10y agoEarth's carrying capacity was hit a long time ago. > Global population is expected to peak then decline On what timescale? That's the most important question here that you conveniently glossed over. You're grossly misinformed.
- underbluewaters 10y agoCarrying Capacity refers to an ecosystem's capacity to support a certain population size. It can hardly be said that their earth's ecosystems are sustainably supporting the current human population. We've had to essentially destroy and replace working ecosystems with a regime that now relies on petroleum-based technology (fertilizer, herbicide, mechanization, transport) to raise productivity. We are on borrowed time and now have to rely on new technology to save us before we either run out of fossil fuels or cook the planet.
- noobiemcfoob 10y agoWe've been relying on technology for our salvation since the advent of agriculture, every day trying to fight back our inevitable doom at the hands of one out of a million causes. We may have remodeled our ecosystem(s), but it is still an ecosystem. The term Carrying Capacity wholly applies.
- underbluewaters 10y agoI guess I glossed over the most important bit, which is that it implies a sustainable system. Ingenuity may keep disaster at bay or it may not. Natural resources that took millions of years to develop like fossil fuels, aquifers, and healthy soils are being strained or drawn down by human population growth.