3 ms·
It seems that baity titles become less so when the content is as highly predictable as nybooks.com. If a reader is comfortable sitting down to what they can rea
by sctb 10y ago
It seems that baity titles become less so when the content is as highly predictable as nybooks.com. If a reader is comfortable sitting down to what they can reasonably expect is a book review, they might not feel so cheated when it's about prejudice instead of, say, economics.
The principle behind letting a title like this one stand where not everything is spelled out is that it encourages a quiet, reflective approach. This is a highly desirable quality for Hacker News in that it supports the gratification of intellectual curiosity, which is why we're here.
- dredmorbius 10y agoIf a set-up question can be simply answered, it's clickbait. I don't care who the hell's written it. I hear the same complaints from an 84 year old friend with greatly diminished eyesight who gripes about this all the time in newspaper headlines. Teasing titles which reveal nothing and force the reader into the story. He's among the few subscribers the paper has left, and is about all out of fricks to give for their shoot. This is clickbait. The fundamental problem with clickbait, and the reason it draws so much rightful ire, is that it is deliberately contemptuous of its reader. HN should fix the title or flag the post. Fixing the title wins my vote. Particularly as you've already troubled to write an excuse not to.
- raldi 10y agoI support you and Dan having absolute authority to decide which direction you want to take HN in, and which policies to set in order to achieve that goal, but for what it's worth, I respectfully disagree with this decision. I'd explain why, but TeMPOraL already did so perfectly in the insightful second paragraph of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12746980 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12746980, every word of which I agree with.