3 ms·

> Reddit works You know what I really hate about reddit? The inconsistency of the links. If the link is a self.subreddit link, it goes to the discussion thread

by mhurron 10y ago

> Reddit works You know what I really hate about reddit? The inconsistency of the links. If the link is a self.subreddit link, it goes to the discussion thread, if it was a submitted link to a location outside of reddit, the link goes to that page and to see the discussion thread you have to click on the small 'comment' link. I wouldn't say reddit works any more than a 'designed to death' site, just that it hasn't been 'designed to death.' It is full of it's own problems.

swiley 10y ago
Where else would a self.reddit link go? Also, the comments link always goes to the same place.
- mhurron 10y ago
  But the link does not always go the the same place. I personally am always clicking on external links when I meant to go to the discussion page. I would have the main link always go to the discussion page, if there is an associated external link, have it listed under the main link. Lets see if I can get this to show what I mean (grabbed from the front page) What is the most 2000s thing you can think of? submitted 5 hours ago by enormous-radio to /r/AskReddit 4741 comments share Police vehicle rams protesters at anti-U.S. rally in the Philippines Link: somewhere.latimes.com submitted 7 hours ago by wilson_rawls to /r/news 561 comments share The main target is consistent, there is a clear external link if it exists. Probably could drop the Link: part.
  - Deimorz 10y ago
    The way I think of it is that clicking on the title is taking you to the content. For a self-post, the content is posted on reddit itself, so the content location is the same as the comments page. That being said, they've made a few steps toward something closer to your suggestion in some places. For example, if you do a search, the search results behave this way, where clicking the title always takes you to the comments and there's a separate link (with a chain-link icon) to go to the linked content.
    - CamelCaseName 10y ago
      What do you mean 'they'? Commenting from the wrong account? ;)
      - Deimorz 10y ago
        Last Friday was my last day at reddit, so "they" is appropriate now.
  - the_duke 10y ago
    I agree. The same thing annoys me here on HN.
gabemart 10y ago
> If the link is a self.subreddit link, it goes to the discussion thread, if it was a submitted link to a location outside of reddit The link goes to the content, wherever that is. Reddit was designed to share content. In the early days they didn't even have comments.

by mhurron 10y ago

swiley 10y ago

Where else would a self.reddit link go? Also, the comments link always goes to the same place.

mhurron 10y ago
But the link does not always go the the same place. I personally am always clicking on external links when I meant to go to the discussion page. I would have the main link always go to the discussion page, if there is an associated external link, have it listed under the main link. Lets see if I can get this to show what I mean (grabbed from the front page) What is the most 2000s thing you can think of? submitted 5 hours ago by enormous-radio to /r/AskReddit 4741 comments share Police vehicle rams protesters at anti-U.S. rally in the Philippines Link: somewhere.latimes.com submitted 7 hours ago by wilson_rawls to /r/news 561 comments share The main target is consistent, there is a clear external link if it exists. Probably could drop the Link: part.
- Deimorz 10y ago
  The way I think of it is that clicking on the title is taking you to the content. For a self-post, the content is posted on reddit itself, so the content location is the same as the comments page. That being said, they've made a few steps toward something closer to your suggestion in some places. For example, if you do a search, the search results behave this way, where clicking the title always takes you to the comments and there's a separate link (with a chain-link icon) to go to the linked content.
  - CamelCaseName 10y ago
    What do you mean 'they'? Commenting from the wrong account? ;)
    - Deimorz 10y ago
      Last Friday was my last day at reddit, so "they" is appropriate now.
- the_duke 10y ago
  I agree. The same thing annoys me here on HN.

gabemart 10y ago

> If the link is a self.subreddit link, it goes to the discussion thread, if it was a submitted link to a location outside of reddit The link goes to the content, wherever that is. Reddit was designed to share content. In the early days they didn't even have comments.