4 ms·
> a lack of options can be a luxury Definitely. I worked for a couple of years on a startup that aimed to help people make better shopping decisions. In user i
by wpietri 10y ago
> a lack of options can be a luxury
Definitely. I worked for a couple of years on a startup that aimed to help people make better shopping decisions. In user interviews and tests, we really saw the pain. The technical term for this is "tyranny of choice". [1]
One important distinction here is that shopping behavior tends to fall into one of two modes, optimizer and satisficer. [2] Satisficers just want to pick something adequate; optimizers want to pick the best thing. Everybody does both, but people tend toward one side or another.
People here surely skew toward optimizer, so the problem is especially painful for us. Amazon's reviews have become so reliable that my first stop will often be something like Consumer Reports, Wirecutter, or SweetHome. Knowing that some other optimizer has already done the research lets makes me more comfortable making a satisficer-style choice.
[1] http://www.economist.com/node/17723028 http://www.economist.com/node/17723028
[2] http://abundancemeasures.blogspot.com/2012/01/choice-part-ii-satisficers-vs.html http://abundancemeasures.blogspot.com/2012/01/choice-part-ii...
- endemic 10y agoI'll confirm your anecdote RE: using other websites for curated reviews. I recently needed a new router; instead of wading through the innumerable search results on Amazon, I simply chose Wirecutter's recommendation.
- spencerflem 10y ago100% agree. The Wirecutter rocks.
- pimlottc 10y agoI've been doing that too. My experiences have generally been good, but I do feel a bit of unease at basically giving them somewhat blind trust.
- mjevans 10y agoI usually look through a few brands that haven't irked me yet on OpenWRT's HCL since I'll stick that on anything I'm likely to buy anyway.
- dom0 10y agoIn Europe (mostly the German and English speaking parts) there's a search engine for "stuff", formerly only computer-related things, that is often used for this: http://geizhals.de/ http://geizhals.de/ Their unique features are curated filters (boatloads of them, extremely handy to narrow choices down) and accurate, non-fake reviews and ratings. This removed 95 % of the annoyingness in buying hardware for me: 1.) Define requirements 2.) Apply filters on gh 3.) Check reviews for the few resulting choices 4.) Buy.
- thesmok 10y agoThe same thing for Ukraine is hotline.ua I'm surprised there's no service like that in US.
- chrisdotcode 10y ago> Amazon's reviews have become so reliable Did you mean unreliable here?
- notyourwork 10y agoDo you have any numbers or reports on population distribution that fall into each type, optimizer and satisficer? I have never heard this before and find this topic very interesting.
- wpietri 10y agoI don't have that handy, but I'd start with the book "The Paradox of Choice" and the author's academic work. The phenomenon also goes by the name "maximizer vs satisficer", and you might check the psychological literature for that.
- gambiting 10y agoAlso, how do you tell a crap restaurant from a great one? A crap one has 400 items on the menu, while a great one has 5.