5 ms·
> it's something used by Erlang Syntax only. Well... and English syntax. In English, you can specify a list of things by separating each thing with a semicolon
by kqr 10y ago
> it's something used by Erlang Syntax only.
Well... and English syntax. In English, you can specify a list of things by separating each thing with a semicolon and then a sentence is terminated by a period. Example:
> Today I would like you to buy coffee; talk to Sarah about the party if you can, otherwise send her a text; drop off the kids; meet me at soccer practise.
You see how the sentence is terminated with a period, each individual item in the list is separated by a semicolon, and the comma is free to use inside each item to indicate related clauses. I've changed nothing about the structure of that list, except replaced the items with function definitions.
> Today I would like you to define f(m, n, r, 1) as f(m, n, remainder of m divided by n, 2); f(m, n, r, 2) as n if r is 0, otherwise as f (m, n, r, 3); f(m, n, p, 3) as f(n, p, p, 1).
It's the same thing, only we've replaced the mundane everyday tasks with function definitions. Now reformat the thing and we get
Today I would like you to define
f(m, n, r, 1) = f(m, n, remainder of m divided by n, 2);
f(m, n, r, 2) = n if r is 0,
f (m, n, r, 3) otherwise;
f(m, n, p, 3) = f(n, p, p, 1).
Sure, Erlang syntax happens to coincide with the syntax of English, and I'm not sure whether this was intentional or not, but it certainly has nothing to do with Knuth.
- old_sound 10y agoReally you can use semi-colons on a sentence and then end the sentence with a period? And I thought I had learned something during all my years studying linguistics and grammar. BTW, newsflash: many languages use semi-colons inside sentences. Spanish for example, which could be argued to be older than English. So did Erlang copy Knuth, or Erlang actually copied El Cid Campeador? I think Erlang comes from El Cantar del Cid.
- kqr 10y agoI just find it more likely that Knuth continued to use English for those definitions, and not that he switched to Spanish, or for that matter Erlang.
- old_sound 10y agoFor me it's pretty clear he was trying to write the algorithms in Spanish, therefore the semicolons.
- dllthomas 10y agoSemicolon has two uses in English. First, to separate two related sentences in a way weaker than a period. Second, in place of commas separating items in a list where at least one list item contains commas.
- jameshart 10y agoIt's a poor mind that can only conceive of two uses for a punctuation mark. Sure, those are the two conventional uses for semicolons, but it's far from all the ways a semicolon can be used. Try combining it with reported speech; consider deploying it in lists which don't contain commas (like this one); use it to jam together sentence fragments in poetry; use it to notate interruption in a screenplay; use it to make your smileys wink ;)...
- dllthomas 10y agoConventional uses was all I was speaking to. Clarification of that fact omitted for brevity.