4 ms·
I've done quite a lot of homework on a Pi3 I got for free from someone who didn't want it. They're actually a functional desktop.
by swiley 10y ago
I've done quite a lot of homework on a Pi3 I got for free from someone who didn't want it. They're actually a functional desktop.
- paulmd 10y agoThey work as a desktop but you're better off using something designed around the task. SD cards are not really designed for heavy random writes on a long-term basis and can be sensitive to corruption during brownouts that don't necessarily trigger a full system dropout. The GPU was primitive even for its day and has not gotten better with age. There's no SATA or USB 3.0, no GigE, and everything runs across a single USB 2.0 bus. For desktop or server use, the Pi is in the same price range as systems built on laptop chipsets (Kabini, Baytrail/Cherrytrail/Goldmont, etc). These can easily be had for sub-$150 normally and sub-$100 if you shop around. That's about the same price as the Pi once you factor in all the other things you have to purchase to get your "$35 computer" to boot. They are are lot faster and a lot more fully-featured. You can easily get SATA, GigE, USB 3.0, and you can even get ECC RAM on the AM1 platform. Also check out the Liva series from ECS and the ZBOX series from Zotac. Of course if you have the cash you can also look at a NUC or BRIX or other mini-PC but those are aimed a little higher in the market. Also it's kinda sad to hold up an Intel product as a positive example of open source, but it's much better than the Raspberry Pi. You are still reliant on binary blobs to boot the hardware to this day. The graphics stack is open source, the ThreadX-based VideoCore OS RTOS the GPU uses is not, and the documentation/drivers are restricted to usage only on official Raspberry Pi hardware.
- khedoros1 10y agoA lot of people seem to want something like a more-powerful Arduino that they can interface to a few I2C or SPI sensors, run some relays or servos, and embed into a project. Use your old cell phone charger, buy a microSD for $5, borrow a keyboard and some time on an HDMI TV to configure wifi, then just access it through VNC. Before the Pi3 with it's built-in wifi, it was also common to connect the Pi to a laptop with an ethernet cable and access it that way. For some people, one of those cheap X86 systems would make more sense, because they're trying to use it as a desktop or to do something that benefits from a higher-power CPU (real-time object recognition comes to mind). For a lot of others, a little ARM board hits a few important points: it's small, doesn't use much power, is easy to re-flash if it gets corrupted, is actually available in their country, is generally easy to adapt Arduino code to work on, and has a huge community around it focused on learning, experimentation, and building things. There's a nice little niche that it and similar boards fill.
- paulmd 10y agoYeah, it's nice for some embedded use-cases too but don't forget there's also BeagleBone Black and some other tools that fit that use-case as well. Or just a Bus Pirate in some situations. Depends on what you want to do. It's nice for some video things that really whale on the GPIOs. The "it's easy to reflash" thing really grinds me because it's just as easy to image any other type of disk too. Yeah, the BIOS is on the disk too, but that actually increases the chance of an accident since you can nuke it out with a disk operation. It's legitimately hard to nuke a conventional BIOS unless you're trying, and in theory UEFI should block writes of invalid firmware images (one of the rare happy side effects of the cryptographic signing). "using your old cellphone charger" is one of those things that sounds great in theory but you should actually never do in practice. The Pi takes a lot of power and needs much more voltage stability than a charging circuit. Using a random charger is asking for corruption issues because the SD card will silently fail writes. For object recognition, check out the Jetson TK1 and TX1 boards. They're more expensive than a Pi but CUDA GPU acceleration buys you a LOT more performance and you still fit into a tight power budget.
- khedoros1 10y ago> Yeah, it's nice for some embedded use-cases too but don't forget there's also BeagleBone Black Agreed, along with dozens of other {Fruit} Pis, Udoos, Odroids, etc. I like the BBB because it has those separate processors that can be used for tasks with real-time priority. > it's just as easy to image any other type of disk too. In theory, yes, but there's something nice about popping out a microSD, putting it in the adapter it came with, and sliding it into my laptop to re-image (or a USB SD card reader, to image a disk from a Pi host directly). SDs are small, easy to move between machines, and SBCs tend to have their OSes distributed as image files. In contrast, to take a backup image of the computer that I just bought, I needed to download + flash an OS on a USB key, boot, and copy/compress a 256GB disk onto a USB hard drive. It's a lot more steps, a lot more hardware, and there's not a place that I could just download the bare OS image, if I happened to lose the backup. It's just all around a less convenient process. > [...] sounds great in theory but you should actually never do in practice. ...but that almost everyone does in practice. I haven't personally had an issue with it over 4 years of use. > For object recognition, check out the Jetson TK1 and TX1 boards. They're more expensive than a Pi but CUDA GPU acceleration buys you a LOT more performance and you still fit into a tight power budget. A lot of the people especially interested in this are working through a university or technical school class, where the coursework assumes use of a Raspberry Pi, specifically (there seem to be lots of courses like that in India and the Middle East). When it seems like the use-case fits, I try to point people to other hardware. A lot of people that I talk to about the Pi are from poorer countries though, where a lot of the time "cheap computer" takes precedence over "capable computer". I hear what you're saying though, and I agree: There are a LOT of SBC options out there (and none of the Rasperry Pi computers are necessarily the best technically-suited for most things) and some very nice hardware a couple of price brackets up.
- pjmlp 10y agoThey are still more powerful than if I could combine my old 386SX, Pentium 75 and Pentium 166 into some form of single computer.
- krylon 10y agoI have an Asus EeeBox at home (Atom N270, 1GB RAM), and besides the hard disk vs. MicroSD card, I think my Pi3 is faster than that. (If one includes the GPU in the calculation, it definitely is - with omxplayer, the Pi3 can play 1080p smoothly, while the EeeBox only gets about 5fps on 720p...) The hybrid old-school machine you propose sounds interesting, though. ;-)
- cheiVia0 10y agoRPi boot blobs are going away: https://github.com/christinaa/rpi-open-firmware https://github.com/christinaa/rpi-open-firmware
- cheiVia0 10y agoanholt is getting paid by broadcom to write proper open VC4 GPU drivers: http://anholt.livejournal.com/ http://anholt.livejournal.com/
- nullr0ute 10y agoWhich is the drivers that Fedora is using in their support.