5 ms·
Time to move my (paid) account to gitlab or somewhere similar then. I want github to host my projects, not to be the PC police.
by flukus 10y ago
Time to move my (paid) account to gitlab or somewhere similar then. I want github to host my projects, not to be the PC police.
- eli 10y agoDo you anticipate your use of github being affected by these guidelines? Or just the idea of them offends you?
- white-flame 10y agoFirst they came for those I deemed offensive, and I did not speak out— Because I did not deem myself offensive. Then they came for me— and there was no one left to speak for me.
- heartbreak 10y agoYou seem to have missed that eli was suggesting that you find Guthub's new policies...offensive.
- white-flame 10y agoThe whole slicing of society into those deemed "offensive" and "acceptable" is a problem in and of itself. These policies are not a solution to them, it's catering to the problem. Niemoller's poem is an example of a divisive society being its own divide-and-conquer downfall. Illegal behavior is illegal behavior, and if someone's behavior reaches that level, it should be taken up with the police against the perpetrator.
- geofft 10y agoThat seems like a good recipe for big government. If society can't trust that private institutions can avoid undesirable behavior, the only recourse is to make everything offensive illegal. So, conversely, if we don't want to live in that world, it is appropriate and beneficial for private institutions to have some standards of acceptable behavior beyond mere legality.
- Turing_Machine 10y ago"the only recourse is to make everything offensive illegal." Alternatively, you could recognize that there is no right to not be offended. There are ~7 billion other people out there, a solid majority of whom likely hold one or more views that you would find offensive (and who find one or more of your views offensive in turn).
- geofft 10y agoSure. I have no right to not be offended, I acknowledge that. I do have freedom of association, though, and I absolutely have the right not to associate with those that offend me, patronize businesses that welcome people who offend me, etc. In turn, people who find my views offensive are, of course, free not to associate with me, not to patronize businesses that welcome me, etc., and I steadfastly support their rights to do so!
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- white-flame 10y agoHow do you reconcile that with your upstream comment "If society can't trust that private institutions can avoid undesirable behavior, the only recourse is to make everything offensive illegal"? That statement seems to imply that there is a mandate for 3rd parties to provide systems free of "undesirable behavior" from particular perspectives. Freedom of association means no, there isn't. Demanding private institutions provide freedom from offensiveness implies a perceived right not to be offended.
- Turing_Machine 10y agoOr you (and they) could just suck it up and stop demanding that everyone else behave in the way that you, personally, have decided is the "correct" way. If it doesn't actively "pick your pocket or break your leg", why not let it go?
- eli 10y ago
- qb45 10y ago> eli was suggesting that you find Guthub's new policies...offensive. eli's right, somebody should suggest adding "community guidelines" to this "offensive" blacklist and see how they resolve the paradox ;)
- flukus 10y agoI anticipate someone making a big deal over nothing (like what triggered the whole code of conduct thing in the first place) will trigger one of the clauses and I or the project may be removed. I anticipate that my account could be removed because of the actions of another contributor on a project, even if I had no involvement. And a simply don't like the idea of it. They are selling a product, I want to buy the product, I don't want to be forced into their political philosophy for it.
- eli 10y agoDoesn't HN also have community guidelines and sometimes bans accounts that violate them? What's the difference?
- flukus 10y agoHN is a forum and doesn't host anything I would care about losing, github is (was) a service I paid for. We discuss some contentious subjects on HN but github will be preventing contributions from people with wrongthink, which I don't care about.
- eli 10y agoYou seem to be making some big assumptions about how these guidelines will be enforced. I got a very different sense from reading them. I see no evidence they will delete your paid accounts because you think or express ideas that are merely contentious or unpopular.
- flukus 10y agoBecause I've seen it used in practice to vilify people with different beliefs, even when those beliefs are irrelevant to the work on the project. Github and some recent hires they've made have a history of this.
- AvenueIngres 10y ago>You seem to be making some big assumptions about how these guidelines will be enforced. Oh please. We all know what kind of rancid and toxic people are spearheading these kinds of seemingly innocuous initiatives. >I see no evidence they will delete your paid accounts because you think or express ideas that are merely contentious or unpopular. Yeah. Because I am going to take the risk and potentially disrupt the workflow of three high-volume OSS projects I maintain. The time I assumed benevolence from Github is long over. Time to move my shit to a reliable service like Gitlab.
- thescribe 10y agoI too worry that this is opposed to the virtues I expect from the open source software community.
- matt4077 10y agoHere's the list of behavior they're targeting. Which one of these do you believe github should have to tolerate against their will? - Threats of violence - Hate speech and discrimination - Bullying and harassment - Impersonation - Doxxing and invasion of privacy - Sexually explicit content - Active malware or exploits
- miend 10y agoJudging by his comment, it doesn't seem he's advocating for forcing a private entity (or at least this particular one) to do anything "against their will". Instead, he's moving his business elsewhere because of a policy he disagrees with -- a non-aggressive response of voting with one's wallet. Do you believe this equates to forcing Github to take actions against their will?
- aaron-lebo 10y agoThe problem is several of those are completely arbitrary. You define rules which seem nice at first and then get abused for political reasons.
- jlappi 10y ago> - Bullying and harassment It's not the majority of the time, but I've see policies against 'bullying and harassment' used to silence anything but. That might be what is worrying OP.
- oridecon 10y agoI wouldn't want to be the person deciding where issues like this fits: https://github.com/opal/opal/issues/941 https://github.com/opal/opal/issues/941
- tzs 10y agoThe person who opened that issue to remove an Opal core developer because she didn't like his personal tweets was subsequently hired by Github.
- 10y ago
- Waterluvian 10y agoI would like to better understand your point of view. What in particular about the guidelines inclines you to move? Why do you think GitHub shouldn't be doing it?
- adamnemecek 10y agoI doubt that these were issues, more likely they put these in place to declare some sort of allegiance to certain groups. These groups seem to be more about policing people because the position of moral authority gives them some sort of high than solving actual issues (but that might require expending energy, time and resources so they stick to policing people online).
- flukus 10y agoThe fact that there are guidelines. I want my ISP to be a dumb pipe and not a content provider, filterer, etc, In the same way I want github to be a dumb service host.