4 ms·
> I'm not a fan of people getting paid for copyrighted works decades after the work was created Can you explain why exactly? John August (screenwriter/blogger
by paulcole 10y ago
> I'm not a fan of people getting paid for copyrighted works decades after the work was created
Can you explain why exactly?
John August (screenwriter/blogger) wrote about this extensively and his argument (when it comes to the film industry) is very simple: Most writers (and by extension actors, etc.) aren't stars or even semi-famous. They get very few new projects produced and rely on residuals to provide income in between new projects. Without residuals, screenwriting would only be accessible to those who are already wealthy.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoI'm part of the "strip back protections" to a more reasonable frame of reference. His argument, to wit, is bullshit (if I'm reading correctly). Reasonable Copyright Reform is basically "Life of Artist + X years" where X is the variable. A single digit extension, say like 5 years, so family members can enjoy a last bit of revenue stream / protection of works, and then it goes back to the public benefit. Nobody other than Copyright Abolitionists assert that Copyright should expire while the creator is still alive - I mean, I guess somebody could assert it but it's so far out as a non-sequitur it's laughable. If I misread his argument or your summary then I still think there are significant problems with that line of reasoning in a serious Copyright Reform discussion.
- smhenderson 10y agoBullshit? OK, thanks for explaining why you think my argument is bullshit, even if I think that language is unnecessary. But I do disagree. If I write a hit song and die before the copyright ends than sure, let my family have a cut. But even five years after the term of it ending is too long in my mind. And, no, I also don't think it's fair that someone reap the benefits of a work for their entire life (assuming they live a long life). People have to work for a living. If you only come up with one hit song in your life that makes any money I believe you'll need to suck it up and find something else to do for a living. And to be clear, I love music, I play music and I have spent many, many thousands of dollars on music in my life. I have no problem with people getting paid, just not riding it out forever. Especially when the industry is set up to give most of the benefits of long term copyright to the industry, not the artists.
- paulcole 10y ago> I also don't think it's fair that someone reap the benefits of a work for their entire life I'm assuming you're against startup equity for a similar reason? After all, why should someone benefit from one period of professional work for the rest of their lives?
- smhenderson 10y agoNot really, that's an investment that continues to generate benefits as an investment. To use your analogy, how about an artist take the fruits of their work and start their own publishing company thereby reaping further reward and providing a benefit to society. In fact the more successful of them do.
- paulcole 10y ago> investment that continues to generate benefits as an investment Isn't a creative work the result of an investment in time spent practicing and learning? And aren't the generated benefits continued sales of that work?
- paulcole 10y ago> Especially when the industry is set up to give most of the benefits of long term copyright to the industry, not the artists Also, how do you rationalize this with the fact that you're advocating stripping away one of those few remaining benefits?
- imron 10y ago> They get very few new projects produced and rely on residuals to provide income in between new projects Let's take 'decades' at its minimum value - 20 years. That's plenty of time to get another project and if it's not, then it's more likely lack of talent than lack of wealth that's keeping that person out of the industry. I agree with the GP. You shouldn't be able to rest on your laurels for decades from a single piece of work.
- smhenderson 10y agoThanks, as I've mentioned elsewhere me saying "decades" was probably a bit vague, and yes, you're literal interpretation is in line with what I was thinking.
- paulcole 10y ago> You shouldn't be able to rest on your laurels for decades from a single piece of work. Why not? If people still like the work and are willing to pay for it? People retire after cashing out stock from a startup. Are you against this as well?
- imron 10y agoIn the context of copyright, which my reply was about, it's about striking a balance between rewarding creators and progressing the arts. In my opinion, extended copyrights like what we have now tilt the balance too far in favour of rewarding the creator, at the expense of progressing the arts. 20-30 years is a perfectly reasonable amount of time to profit exclusively from the distribution of a work. Which is not to say you can no longer profit from it afterwards, just that opening it up to the public greatly increases the potential of progressing the arts. Not to mention, it adds incentive for creators to keep creating even after making successful art.