7 ms·
Wikileaks: Multiple US sources tell us John Kerry asked Ecuador to stop Assange from publishing Clinton docs during FARC peace negotiations. https://twitter.co
by hammock 10y ago
Wikileaks: Multiple US sources tell us John Kerry asked Ecuador to stop Assange from publishing Clinton docs during FARC peace negotiations.
https://twitter.com/wikileaks/status/788369924175441920 https://twitter.com/wikileaks/status/788369924175441920
- mc32 10y agoWhelp, he was being used. And I'm sure he knows that, but now that EC has other things on their minds more important than being a thorn to American politics, it's back to Realpolitik and Assange releasing info which may further embarrass their horse in the American political race would counter their political cause, so it becomes a casualty.
- dntrkv 10y agoMultiple US sources say Assange is pulling a PR stunt. Multiple US sources say Trump is the anti christ. Multiple US sources say Assange is a false flag placed by the Reptilians. Wow, this is easy!
- thingexplainer 10y agoThis isn't a very interesting criticism. If WikiLeaks says an anonymous source told them something that is a.) completely believable and b.) isn't what a onymous source would be able to say, I see no reason to doubt them. I don't have an extraordinarily high confidence in a claim based on an anonymous witness alone, but journalists (lets squint hard enough to still call Assange a journalist for a moment) do this all the time. Do you have other evidence to bring to the table? Do you have reason to doubt a.) or b.)?
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoIrrelevant to your point, but I hadn't heard “onymous” as the antonym of “anonymous” before, thank you for that.
- thingexplainer 10y agoIt isn't a real word I'm afraid, but an FBI invention. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Onymous https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Onymous
- Etzos 10y agoIt is a real word though. http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?allowed_in_frame=0&search=onymous&searchmode=none http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?allowed_in_frame=0&searc...
- thingexplainer 10y agoThanks, learned something new.
- zem 10y agointeresting, I've always used "nonymous" for that, but "onymous" is etymologically sounder
- jcranmer 10y agoYeah, I was going to say "nonymous" was etymologically superior, but then I looked up the etymology for anonymous before hitting send. Given that the English (/Germanic) is "name" and the French is "nom", I would have expected the PIE for name to be some sort of "nVm"-ish thing, whence I expected the Greek to render it is some sort of "non"-ish thing. The actual Greek is ónoma, with the PIE being something like *hnómn. (So my PIE guess was right-ish, but the transition to Hellenic was wrong).
- antman 10y agoThis is Ancient Greek and the antonym is "eponymous". Unfortunately it has a double meaning, used more often as "named after". So we got 'onymous' which has no meaning as an old root.
- Berobero 10y agoI don't know that there's a reason to specifically doubt a or b, but in contrast to their other major (and known valid) leaks, this one is much more tied to their organizational interests, so there's that much more reason to be healthily skeptical of it.
- revelation 10y agoAscribing government propaganda to anonymous sources is basically 70% of the New York Times "reporting".
- thingexplainer 10y agoBut what seems to be in question here is if WikiLeaks said "US officials speaking on condition of anonymity said that enhanced interrogation was vital to finding Osama Bin Laden," did WikiLeaks actually talk to those officials and did they really say that? Or are they promoting their brand as a marginalized alternative news source that the government is trying to fight?
- untog 10y agoIf the quote is about Wikileaks then I certainly see reason to doubt them. They have obvious motivations.
- dntrkv 10y agoOn the one hand we have a reputable media company reporting quotes from reputable sources, and on the other we have WikiLeaks (with a very well documented agenda) claiming the exact opposite from an anonymous source. The New York Times and The State Department are both putting their reputation (however much that means to you) on the line with their quotes, whereas WikiLeaks and its anonymous source, aren't putting anything on the line since a large part of their business model depends on making claims that can only be proven in their favor, but never in reverse. Example, this claim about who is responsible for cutting Assange's internet access. Let's say the US did not cut his internet. There is absolutely nothing The State Department can say to make WikiLeaks supporters believe them. Whereas, anything WikiLeaks says about the US government will be eaten up by their supporters since the only people that can provide evidence to the contrary, WikiLeaks supporters don't trust. It's the same approach taken by Alex Jones (They want to take your guns, they want to put you in fema camps, etc...), Trump (A lot of people are saying...) Oh and btw, I'm not saying you should just blindly believe what the government tells you, but until any actual evidence is provided to support another explanation, there is no reason to assume it is true. Bonus hypocritical Trump tweet: https://twitter.com/realdonaldtrump/status/781838706030313472 https://twitter.com/realdonaldtrump/status/78183870603031347...
- drzaiusapelord 10y ago>anything WikiLeaks says about the US government will be eaten up by their supporters It used to be a saying that geeks can't do politics. And now after what I've seen of years of slashdot, digg, Reddit, and HN I think its fair to say that saying is true. The problem I see is that people who think they're smart think they must automatically be immune to propaganda, bias, etc because, well, they're so smart. I find the techie personality to be unusually vulnerable to propaganda and conspiracy theories. I think this type of thinking gives simple answers and black and white thinking that are intellectually satisfying and dismiss the incredible complexity of human interactions. Its very easy to just eat up anti-US college identity politics and make the US be the devil in all things. Its simple and is emotionally satisfying. The problem is that its also incorrect, especially when your "good guys" are Russia, China, and Iran.
- 10y ago
- unprepare 10y ago> that is a.) completely believable How so? If ecuador was going to give in to US demands, why wouldnt they just let the US extradite Asssange? Clearly the US doesnt have the type of pull with Ecuador to force their hand, why would you think this is any different? you believe that john kerry alone was able to convince them to cut the internet, but the fact that 3 separate countries want him arrested is meaningless to them? Doesnt sound believable to me at all. so yes, i have reason to doubt a)
- thingexplainer 10y agoBecause they're willing to do one thing but not the other?
- gjolund 10y agoSo do you think he just forgot to pay his bill?
- dogma1138 10y agoAnd why is that a bad thing? you can't leak stuff during negotiations it blows everything up. The FARC deal is now dead as it seems since the referendum has failed but if there was anything in those emails that could have jeopardized the deal it should not have been released.
- cmdrfred 10y agoIf the truth blows up your negotiations, you are a cheat.
- tocotun1 10y agoWho believes the Colombian government has ever had the upper hand in the FARC negotiations? For fuck's sake, they are having to negotiate with a terrorist organisation. It's obvious the gov is handcuffed.
- dogma1138 10y agoYou don't know how negotiations work do you? Everyone comes to the table with points that would make the other side walk away, and everyone has their initial redlines. These change during the negotiations, premature release of information backs one or both parties into a corner in which further negotiations are no longer possible. This is the real world, not some fairy tale.
- toomuchtodo 10y ago> This is the real world, not some fairy tale. Indeed. And in this world now, information asymmetry is greatly reduced. Politicians can live with it. The fairy tale is you can hide your dirty laundry until you've fleeced your negotiating opponent.
- dogma1138 10y agoIt's not dirty laundry its negotiations the deal would become public. Look at how many deals with Iran and N. Korea blew up early own because one side leaked (usually intentionally to tank the negotiations) some information that meant no further negotiations would be possible.
- untog 10y agoYou know the wikileaks Twitter account is Assange, right? I'm going to wait for a reliable third party report on this one.
- arkitaip 10y agoIs Assange the only one using the wikileaks twitter account? Because it's batshit crazy at times https://heatst.com/politics/wikileaks-posts-and-deletes-anti-semitic-tweet-as-it-does-putins-bidding-for-trump/ https://heatst.com/politics/wikileaks-posts-and-deletes-anti...
- snovv_crash 10y agoIf anything, that website you linked is batshit crazy. At least Wikileaks had the sense to delete the tweets.
- neves 10y agoThe guy is locked with Ecuadorian TV and English food. It is completely plausible that he goes batshit crazy at times. :-)
- thingexplainer 10y agoWhile I agree that Assange has been under an incomprehensible amount of stress for such a long time, he is getting increasingly radical and less journalistic, such as his (edit: alleged) vendetta against Clinton.
- imron 10y agoHe has repeatedly stated that he would happily release information on Trump and the Republicans if someone would leak it to him.
- thingexplainer 10y agoI'm sure he would, that doesn't make it appropriate to use leaked information to carry out a vendetta. edit: getting source
- JohnStrange 10y agoIf that was true, how would Clinton docs affect FARC negotiations? Is Clinton habitually buying cocaine from Colombia or what would be the reason? I would understand if Kerry asked Ecuador to stop Assange from publishing Clinton docs until she has been elected or until after the next presidential debate. That would make a lot of sense. But this FARC <--> Clinton doc connection doesn't.
- Sebguer 10y agoYou're misunderstanding, the claim is that it was 'during', not 'because'. Kerry was there as part of the negotiations, and supposedly had a private meeting where he made the request. Not that I particularly believe this, just clarifying for you!
- empath75 10y agoThe state department probably asks ecuador to turn over assange every single time they talk to someone in ecuador.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoHowever, we only have one source for the claim of multiple sources. When Wikileaks dumps a bunch of documents, I trust that those are real documents. But I'm not sure that I trust Wikileaks when they release publicity for themselves.
- ww520 10y agoThat sounds like state sponsored censorship.