4 ms·
To some extent, this is a choice many Americans intentionally make. There are many jobs that offer European-like benefits, working hours, and employment stabili
by jandrewrogers 10y ago
To some extent, this is a choice many Americans intentionally make. There are many jobs that offer European-like benefits, working hours, and employment stability in the US (e.g. Federal government jobs and some companies) but these are frequently viewed as undesirable -- it is not a first choice for many people if circumstances offer something better. The tradeoffs tend to be similar to Europe if you take one of these jobs. Lower pay, less opportunity for advancement (these kinds of environments tend to have promotions that are more seniority based), and you have to work with more people that put in the minimum effort required.
The concept of "quality of life" goes beyond the hours you work to also include having the opportunity to go after your ambition, if you have one. Culturally, I think one of the ways the US and Europe differ is that Europe imposes an environment designed to limit expressible ambition to the lowest common denominator, whereas US culture allows much greater variance in ambition. Or to put it another way, if it is your nature, it is easier to be ambitious in the US and easier to be non-ambitious in Europe. But all other things being equal, I prefer having the opportunity to be ambitious. Americans are not required to be ambitious, but many Americans take the opportunity nonetheless.
- RandomName2020 10y ago> (e.g. Federal government jobs and some companies) but these are frequently viewed as undesirable Federal and government (city, state etc.) jobs (perhaps excluding IT) are some of the most desirable jobs in US, with long waiting lines. Got try get a city job in NYC....
- TDL 10y agoAre you going to back up any of your claims?
- RandomName2020 10y agoBack up claims? It is common knowledge - bus drivers for example, working for Santa Clara county transit make $35/h, bus drivers for (contracted) Google and such make less than $20.
- TDL 10y agoThat's not common knowledge to me, especially since I don't live in California. You have asserted certain claims and offer no evidence. "Common knowledge" isn't evidence.
- RandomName2020 10y agoI do not know how to even reply to that. Bus drivers, post delivery people, municipal construction workers etc. - all have better salaries and benefits than similar private workers. I am not sure how any adult living anywhere in US could manage to not know that.
- thedufer 10y agoYou're talking past one another, I think. You are correct for most blue collar jobs; GP's description is accurate for most white collar workers. Your downvotes are probably for your unnecessarily inflammatory final sentence.
- antisthenes 10y ago> "Common knowledge" isn't evidence. But it is. The data for public salaries generally has very good availability in the Information age. If you're trying to participate in a discussion in an informed way, you should at least conduct the minimum due diligence to do so.
- cloverich 10y agoCommon knowledge is by definition not evidence. > The data for public salaries generally has very good availability in the Information age. The salaries don't seem particularly high, and in some cases (construction workers and bus drivers, top quarter) seem particularly low. Of course a lot more goes into job satisfaction than Salary but I agree, this is not common knowledge. http://money.usnews.com/careers/best-jobs/construction-worker/salary http://money.usnews.com/careers/best-jobs/construction-worke... http://money.usnews.com/careers/best-jobs/bus-driver/salary http://money.usnews.com/careers/best-jobs/bus-driver/salary
- jandrewrogers 10y agoYes, they are highly desirable to people that are non-ambitious and strongly risk averse, which includes a non-trivial percentage of the population. For a certain kind of person, those jobs are perfect; the pay and opportunity isn't great but the risk and level of effort is also low. I've worked in these organizations before; the people that take these jobs don't want much out of life, just looking to coast. But most Americans find government jobs to be unfulfilling and stifling for exactly the same reason -- it is a dead-end. I know it is different in other countries but "government job" has mixed connotations in the US.
- untog 10y ago> the people that take these jobs don't want much out of life I disagree - those people don't want much out of work, they still want plenty out of life. Most I've met have tremendously fulfilling family lives, or similar. Not to be discounted.
- RandomName2020 10y agoNASA and Fermilab are also government jobs.
- antisthenes 10y agoNo offense, but everything you wrote makes you sound like a condescending asshole that bases their views on people on a short stint at some gov. agency. How do you know what those people were doing in their lives? Were their performing their job adequately? If yes, I don't really see the issue. Many of the federal jobs are just as demanding and rewarding as those in the private sector and they are so highly desired, that the hiring process has to be very selective, so it leads to at least some quality in the candidates. > But most Americans find government jobs to be unfulfilling and stifling for exactly the same reason -- it is a dead-end. Perhaps you should stop extrapolating your preconceived (and incorrect) notions to most Americans and instead consider the alternative.
- uola 10y agoI actually think it's easier to be ambitious in Europe. Both in absolute terms, since it's easier to access good education education and working environment, and in relative terms, since there's more room to work harder than everyone else.
- embiggen 10y ago> To some extent, this is a choice many Americans > intentionally make. Uhm, to what extent do they have a choice? Be super poor or work hard. Hmm..yes those are delightful "options" to get to "select". But seriously, I don't see a realistic choice for most people. To have any decent level of security and stability in our lives, most of us have to work our asses off!