3 ms·
You mean why are we giving a hard time to all those people who join the KKK just because they look good in white? But seriously, I don't think the demand to "s
by pron 10y ago
You mean why are we giving a hard time to all those people who join the KKK just because they look good in white?
But seriously, I don't think the demand to "sever ties" with Thiel is the right (it does have the slight scent of a purge), or the smart one to make (it plays too much into the hands of those who are glad to jump on the "silencing opposing views" bandwagon). In fact, it pretty much ensures that the debate be diverted to that, especially when many in the crowd are, for one reason or another, fixated on their ideas of free speech. It isn't a hypothesis, either, but precisely what happened time and again in the relevant "community". But YC is influential in SV, where various racist and misogynistic ideas, for one reason or another, take hold on some from time to time, and yet YC has often stayed silent (or faint) on such issues, even when they claim to disagree with them, while being quite vocal about political issues like SOPA and visas that affect the powerful SV players.
- Chris2048 10y ago> it plays too much into the hands of those who are glad to jump on the "silencing opposing views" bandwagon Why frame it like this? It is "silencing opposing views", whether a bandwagon exists or not, so is bad in itself. You seem to imply the only problem is that people care about the issue - that's a good thing! > in SV, where various racist and misogynistic ideas SV is a liberal and leftist hotspot, so those ideas also take hold. Are you pondering why any none-liberal ideas sometimes take hold there? Maybe there a degree of subjectivity in it? > yet YC has often stayed silent (or faint) on such issues Possibly for good reason. There is a lot of animosity towards the tech crowd there, and beating them up about diversity in tech is a common pastime. Remember the PG misquoting? He should have just refused to talk about the subject.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pron 10y ago> It is "silencing opposing views" Well, I'm not 100% sure that telling your billionaire buddy that since he's become a politician in a movement that you view as dangerous to your country and its people perhaps you shouldn't do business together for a while, qualifies as silencing his views. Still, I don't think it was right to demand this of YC. > Are you pondering why any non-liberal ideas sometimes take hold there? I'm not wondering why supremacist views sometimes takes hold anywhere, I'm just saying that perhaps people of influence who oppose those views may want to speak up a bit more vocally. Maybe it's even their duty. > Possibly for good reason. There is a lot of animosity towards the tech crowd there So Marie Antoinette's mistake wasn't not working in the interest of her people but in reminding them that they're hungry?
- Chris2048 10y agoHe hasn't "become a politician", it isn't proposed "for a while". > I'm not wondering why supremacist views sometimes takes hold We were talking about "various racist and misogynistic ideas", not "supremacist views". Are you talking about any view you see as subjectively racist/misogynist, or only specific ones? > Marie Antoinette's mistake wasn't not working in the interest of her people Antoinette's famous comment was glib and not intended to help, versus PGs sincere willingness to discuss sex issues; Also, she was a monarch is a brutal reign, if you want to compare than to the SV tech industry, go ahead.
- pron 10y ago> We were talking about "various racist and misogynistic ideas", not "supremacist views". Are you talking about any view you see as subjectively racist/misogynist, or only specific ones? There is not much room for subjectivity when extreme views are concerned, certainly no more than in any other moral question. Either you think an equal power distribution among the races and the sexes is a desirable, high-priority goal or you don't. There's room for subjectivity in the means of achieving that goal and in its exact priority, but not in recognizing it as one. In any event, Trump's movement is certainly much more supremacist than any other mainstream and establishment conservative movement in recent history, and leaders at YC have said they regard it as abhorrent. > Also, she was a monarch Here we come to the question of whether government is the only external power affecting people's lives, or that there are a multitude of powers. It has been firmly established that the latter view is the correct one. The moral responsibility of an unelected and unconstitutional government to its subjects stems from the fact it has power over them (as it is not formally obligated to do a specific job); every other power has similar responsibility, from the same moral argument, to a degree commensurate with its influence.
- Chris2048 10y ago> There is not much room for subjectivity when extreme views are concerned, certainly no more than in any other moral question I'm not sure what you mean by "moral question". I mean the difficulty in deriving someones intent. for example, som people would see "voting for Trump" as "extreme view" and "racism". > Either you think an equal power distribution among the races and the sexes is a desirable, high-priority goal or you don't There so much about that that isn't binary. 'Priority' is one, continuous dimension. Implementation is another. > Trump's movement is certainly much more supremacist More supremacist? You don't think that's binary? > Here we come to the question No we don't, here we come to the conclusion that your comparison of the SV tech crowd to a 17th century French monarch is a poor one; You spun this out to another issue yourself. > It has been firmly established Again with the weasel terms. Who, when, how?!? Even 1 + 1 = 2 needs a basis http://tinyurl.com/1and1is2 http://tinyurl.com/1and1is2