4 ms·
In a former life, I worked Tier 1 for one of America's largest credit card company. We had a lot more latitude than you seem to realize or care to know. I once
by throwanem 10y ago
In a former life, I worked Tier 1 for one of America's largest credit card company. We had a lot more latitude than you seem to realize or care to know.
I once, over ninety minutes and three credit department reps, convinced the organization to extend additional credit to a woman dying of terminal cancer, so that she'd be able to afford pain medication a while longer. This was of course a bad credit risk, in the sense that she had no realistic prospect of ever repaying her debts, or indeed of living long enough to do so; I don't know whether you are familiar at all with terminal illness, and I hope for your sake you are not, but there is often a point at which acceptance and exhaustion become perceptible in a person's voice, and she had passed it. You would of course argue that it's of no significance to the company whether such a person dies peacefully or otherwise, and to a certain extent this is of course true. What you overlook is that companies, even very large ones, are made of people, and that those people have agency and will surprisingly often go very far out of their way in order to help a customer, even if doing so might carry a personal cost for them. (In the case I describe, it cost me about $400. I knew it would. Some things matter.)
I also dealt with people who operated under the idea that being unpleasant to me would benefit them somehow. At least, I assume some of them thought that way; others no doubt were just nasty people in general. The thing about serving as the human interface to a company is that we don't stop being human when we put our headsets on and log in to the PBX, and the thing about latitude is that it goes both ways.
Recognize our shared humanity despite your entirely reasonable frustration and behave toward me on that basis, and I'll go to great effort to help you, even if it costs me something.
Treat me as a disposable vessel for your anger at some imaginary cipher you cherish of the company for which I work, and you're going to have a damn hard time getting so much as a late fee waived.
(Oh, and by the way - you're not going to make me think about quitting my job, and it is a comedy of arrogance that you imagine otherwise. You are 1/150 of my average daily workload. Do you really think you have power over me? You have the power to ruin your reputation among my colleagues - we can't say things like "what an asshole" in account notes, for reasons of professionalism and liability, but we can convey the same meaning in other words, and we do. And you have the power to influence my analysis of whether it is worth my limited time to come to your assistance with whatever problem has prompted your call. But to imagine you have the power in a three-minute phone call to materially affect the course of my life and the decisions I make therein? What astonishing hubris!)
You inveigh against "companies that think it's OK to treat their customers like garbage", and in that, and that alone, you're not wrong. But you fail to realize, or perhaps to care, that, when you interact with customer service, you aren't talking to companies, but to people. You seem to think that treating those people with cruelty has value. It does not. Such behavior is both counterproductive and beneath you. It also, in my professional experience, is much less common than I think you suspect - you really are an outlier here, and whatever mass movement of which you imagine yourself to be a part really does not exist. I have to say I feel
for you - it must be awfully lonely to be where you are. But the extent of my sympathy is strictly circumscribed by the fact that you bring it on yourself.
- dTal 10y ago>I once, over ninety minutes and three credit department reps, convinced the organization to extend additional credit to a woman dying of terminal cancer, so that she'd be able to afford pain medication a while longer. >In the case I describe, it cost me about $400 This sounds like an interesting incentive structure. Could you elaborate?
- throwanem 10y agoSure. We were incentivized to maximize a range of metrics, primary among which was average call length, over successive two-week periods. The value of the incentive was tied to the degree to which a given operator exceeded the global average for the call center, and there were some disqualifying conditions such as an error rate exceeding some set minimum I no longer recall. We had access to our own metrics on a daily basis, and the value calculation was published, so tracking incentive value was pretty trivial - this was well before smartphones existed, so I wrote up the formula as a TI-BASIC program that took metric values and gave back how much of a bonus I stood to receive in my next pay packet. Customer commendations, one of which I received for the call I described, weren't figured into the incentive metric. (Or, unlike customer complaints, into much of anything else; it wasn't a job with a career path, although we did get nice little laminated plaques, the twenty or so of which I received I probably still have somewhere.) So I knew that exceeding the center average by a factor of thirty was going to unrecoverably hose my incentive metrics for the period, and I knew exactly how much doing so would cost me. But, as I said, some things matter.