2 ms·
Ban all this crap, eliminate parent income calculations, and put a flat price on things. Let students get their financial aid externally. It's a conflict of int
by koolba 10y ago
Ban all this crap, eliminate parent income calculations, and put a flat price on things. Let students get their financial aid externally. It's a conflict of interest on the part of the school to pick and choose who they're giving it to. While you're at it, get rid of student loan subsidies (i.e. Government guarantees) and allow student loans to be be washed away by bankruptcy.
After the initial shock of the bubble bursting when he band-aid is ripped off, you'll have a sustainable education cost structure with the added benefit that the altruism is externalized and insulated from the institutions.
- Meegul 10y agoAnd just say 'too bad' to the kids who can't afford it or get a loan because they have no co-signer with good enough credit?
- koolba 10y agoNo they can get free money from charities or loans from non profits. I'm saying it's not the governments job to do it. Nor is it a good idea for the schools to do it either. If they want to have a fund that provides money for a specific school, have it external to school and provide it to the students that attend that school. Otherwise you're hiding the costs.
- erroneousfunk 10y agoI would argue that schools don't do this because it's in their best interest to admit a certain percentage of kids who can't afford it, and bend over backwards to make sure the kids attend. If the schools fill up with ONLY rich kids with excellent academics, they're going to miss out on the poor (or middle class) kids who will clearly go on to do great things. The output will get bland, and they're leaving a huge market gap open for another educational institution to come in and sweep up these poor geniuses and build a reputation on that. You need to strike a delicate balance between the Malia Obamas, the Rothschilds, and the Ramanujans out there in order to build and maintain the reputation of the institution. Even if they're losing money, and dealing with a paperwork nightmare in the short term, it's a long term gain for them. So the schools don't want to eliminate these loans and subsidy programs, the consumers certainly don't want to eliminate them, and because of this, the government doesn't want to eliminate them -- adding more subsidies, scholarships, and increasing access to loans is an extremely popular political move. I would also argue that these subsidies provide a net economic benefit to society, by allocating educational resources to those who will get the most out of it, but that's a little more controversial.