5 ms·
there's no reason to think that bacteria couldn't evolve resistance to these things, too.
by dnautics 10y ago
there's no reason to think that bacteria couldn't evolve resistance to these things, too.
- M_Grey 10y agoVacuoles would probably be a good solution, or some means of transport back out of the cell, and both would probably be minor modifications of existing systems in bacteria. I wonder if either would increase the stress on the host as well.
- mellavora 10y agotrue, but the article suggests that they were not seeing evidence of emergent resistance. Also, the mechanism of action is one which bacteria would have a very hard time learning resistance to.
- dnautics 10y agoI'll believe it when they make a megaplate with that stuff. megaplate: https://player.vimeo.com/video/180908160 https://player.vimeo.com/video/180908160
- AnimalMuppet 10y ago> true, but the article suggests that they were not seeing evidence of emergent resistance. It's a bit early for that, isn't it? Give it a decade or two of widespread use, and then we'll see. > Also, the mechanism of action is one which bacteria would have a very hard time learning resistance to. That is hopeful. But how hard is "a very hard time"? It takes decades? Centuries? Or never?
- Fomite 10y agoIt's pretty trivial to generate resistance phenotypes in a lab at much shorter time scales to detect if it's possible.
- danielmorozoff 10y agoIt would seem very hard as the main mechanism of action for these nano particles is electrostatic pore formations- confirmed by their mechanistic studies. This would require evolution of the outer membrane (OM), quite a big change for a bacteria to evolve. That said it's very surprising there are so few off target effects.
- jaggederest 10y agoTo some degree there are things that are "resistance proof", in that forming resistance to them would defacto leave organisms unable to survive in the human body. A good example is highly acid/basic environments, thermal stress, or alcohols and solvents. Anything that can reproduce in a 50 degree C alcohol bath, for example, is going to have a tough time adapting to humans well enough to be pathogenic. These polymers might be a similar phenomenon, but that would also imply that they're inimical to humanity too, though perhaps at a higher concentration.
- todd8 10y agoDon't forget prions. They survive temperatures above 120C and also alcohol and remain infectious. (Hydrogen peroxide and alkalis seem too work, but see [1] because I really know nothing of the science of sterilization.) [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/21271212/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/21271212/
- Senji 10y agoPrions aren't alive, by the same measure asbestos is also resistant.
- todd8 10y agoPrions, like viruses, reproduce when inside a host. Parasites, bacteria, fungi, viruses and prions are all types of pathogens. Sterilization protocols need to be followed to ensure that one patients prions don't infect another surgery patient. It turns out that relatively recent concerns over transmissible spongiform encephalopathy, caused by prions, has required changes to the sterilization procedures used in hospitals.
- dnautics 10y agothe fact that the polymers don't kill the mammalian cells means that whatever mammalian cells do to avoid destruction can be adapted by bacterial cells for their survival.