3 ms·
Seeing that Ashton Kutcher is a co-founder brought to mind his feud with the Village Voice a few years ago over the VV's escort ads, which Kutcher alleged were
by danso 10y ago
Seeing that Ashton Kutcher is a co-founder brought to mind his feud with the Village Voice a few years ago over the VV's escort ads, which Kutcher alleged were facilitating child prostitution and sex slavery. The VV then published a long investigative piece arguing that Kutcher's statistical claims -- e.g. that 100,000 to 300,000 U.S. children are sold into sex slavery each year -- was off by several orders of magnitude: http://www.villagevoice.com/news/real-men-get-their-facts-straight-6431644 http://www.villagevoice.com/news/real-men-get-their-facts-st...
And of course it should be said, VV, which was and is undergoing huge financial stress, has every incentive to believe its hands are clean, as it was desperate for the revenue from escort ads.
Hard to tell if Kutcher has revised his numbers. The Thorn site is vague about its numbers. It talks about hundreds of thousands of kids at risk, and on the about page, fuzzes the claim with "100,000 escort ad posted in the United States every day, and within these, there are ads that represent children."...the unsaid implication being that the number of escort ads per day may not have any real bearing on the actual number of children at risk.
It might seem pedantic to care about stats when children are at risk, but the purported goal of this Thorn initiative is to "use tech to fight child sexual exploitation", and its pages make as much mention about data science as the average tech startup press release. But worthwhile data science requires good data, not platitudes. It's not as if the fight against child abuse is as simple as throwing tech and computational resources at it, nor is that even necessarily the most efficient way to fight the problem.
- hogrammer 10y agoAnd I'm sure "children" refers to all those under 18, even though age of consent can be as low as 16 in some states. Certainly, people forced into prostitution is wrong, but I'd doubt the numbers of actual "children" (of the ages of the schoolchildren pictured on their webpage) who are abducted and forced into sex-slavery in the United States are even a fraction of what they claim. The logistics of running such a business in any organized manner and keeping it a secret would be difficult.
- WhitneyLand 10y agoAgreed. And it's not pedantic. First, taking care with stats and claims lends lots of credibility with the people they want help from. Also, having solid numbers helps people start to quantify the problems and think about solutions that will meaningfully impact those numbers.
- M_Grey 10y agoI don't see scrutinizing apparently fictional "statistics" as an exercised in pedantry in the slightest. People who can't be bothered to as you say, find or generate good data and are content with bad data are not people you should trust with money, or important tasks. From a random celebrity like Kutcher, it's understandable and expected at least; if someone expects him to be rigorous they might be new to the planet. News outlets and other users of that stat by contrast, have much more to answer for.
- ottumm 10y agoI’m a software engineer at Thorn. I don’t work directly on the research or data science side of things, but I work closely with those who do and they take it very seriously. Here’s some more detail from our website: https://www.wearethorn.org/child-sexual-exploitation-and-technology/ https://www.wearethorn.org/child-sexual-exploitation-and-tec...