5 ms·
> [...] this guy confessed. Yes, he did, but after: > All I asked for in return was a subpoena or immunity. They said no. I wonder realistically how long can
by viraptor 10y ago
> [...] this guy confessed.
Yes, he did, but after:
> All I asked for in return was a subpoena or immunity. They said no.
I wonder realistically how long can you drag this out as a whistleblower? How many times can you say "I'll give you these people if you don't charge me", especially when your document stash is well hidden.
- tptacek 10y agoIt sort of looks like this bank exec traded 3 years in minimum security prison for more money than any of us could ever use in a lifetime. I'm pretty OK with that precedent!
- viraptor 10y agoI'm not. It was not an exchange. He neither knew about the money, nor expected it at the start. I think it would be more precise to say: "Bank exec blew a whistle his company and got 3 years in minimum security prison. By coincidence he also got a lot of money afterwards." Basically unless the whole story the whistleblower reported was fabricated, I don't think there's any situation where I'd be ok with the whistleblower being the only one jailed. As part of a larger group - sure, maybe. Otherwise what's the point of whistleblowing? It would only work if you hate the company more than you like your current life. Or if you knew how to do it anonymously.
- tptacek 10y agoWhat do you mean he didn't know about it? He's a banking exec whistleblowing on tax evasion. The IRS bounty on recoveries is not exactly a secret. Even in the unlikely event that he himself wasn't aware of his prospects when he went in, you'd assume literally the very first thing any competent lawyer would have told him was "you stand to make a hundred million dollars if you go through with it". The thing I like about the precedent? That banking executives need to be on their toes because all of their colleagues have an immense incentive to rat them out.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- frank_jaeger 10y ago> (It is, however, extremely important to me that I make clear that I had no idea there was a law like this for a reward when I resigned from UBS in October 2005, as the law passed in December 2006.)
- tptacek 10y agoHuh. Fair point. I stand corrected.
- wnoise 10y agoImmunity plus the bonus would be a better incentive to rat them out.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoNo, I still sort of agree with you. The law did pass after he started to whistleblow. However, he wasn't whistleblowing because they were a sneaky bank doing things like set up tax evasion schemes. He was whistleblowing because they set him up to take the blame for the damages. His next plan was to get immunity for all his crimes while screwing them and keeping his money. Had that document not formed or he seen it, he would've kept helping companies in their crimes (or shady stuff) in exchange for large paycheck at the bank. So, he's still a piece of shit that doesn't give a damn about tax evasion doing it solely for himself. He got a great reward in the process anyway despite it backfiring a bit. Like you said above, I think it's probably a good trade so long as it didn't screw up his head in there. :)
- rhizome 10y agoYou're undervaluing time spent locked up.
- tptacek 10y agoI would do 3 years for $100MM. I would do the next three years for $100MM, and they're pretty important years in my family! Someone offer me $100MM to be imprisoned for the next three years; I will put my money where my mouth is on this.
- djdjjd 10y agoWe all knew you were a prostitute for the state, but now we know your upper bound. I suspect your lower bound ia significantly lower. Lap dog.
- roel_v 10y agoI'll do it for $90MM though, pick me! Pick me!
- tedunangst 10y agoThis would make for an interesting loser pays auction.
- grecy 10y agoI smell a reality TV show...
- pyvpx 10y agoif you assume a 4-5% return on the money, only want to live off the returns (not the principal) and "six figures" (say, $250,000) is enough as yearly, net income...the lowest a person would go is about USD$6.7MM (after tax, of course)
- oblio 10y agoIn the US ;)
- st3v3r 10y agoI'm not. Most people won't be in the position to get that kind of deal.
- Lazare 10y agoI'm not. As near as I can tell from objective sources, Birkenfeld: 1) Deserved the money 2) Did not deserve prison. You can't equate those.
- tptacek 10y agoUnless I'm misreading, he's a bank executive who smuggled diamonds internationally to held a Russian oligarch avoid US taxes. Why exactly are you immunizing him?
- Lazare 10y agoTo clarify: I don't feel that he deserved prison for what he was accused of and eventually pled guilty to in a plea bargain, given the totality of the circumstances. Which was not, unless I'm misreading, anything to do with diamond smuggling. Mind you, it's possible he plead guilty to what seems (to me) as vaguely absurd charges to avoid a much harsher penalty for the diamond smuggling and such.
- random314 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Igor_Olenicoff#Tax_evasion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Igor_Olenicoff#Tax_evasion Prosecutors were extremely reluctant to prosecute the oligarch and didn't want him in jail. However they were pretty vigorous with his banker!
- nickpsecurity 10y agoHe aided tax evasion for U.S. and other companies. IRS threatened to come after me for about $1.20 once. No kidding. This guy helping them disguise tens of millions to billions... who knows amount... in taxes they owed? "Did not deserve prison." Oh no, I think the scumbag did. His bosses deserved a longer sentence, too. Although, they're doing what their country makes a lot of money on. So maybe heroes of private industry over there. ;)