3 ms·
Spoken like someone who hasn't taught a CS class. You really want to teach some useful skills and not actually disrupt your CS class too much? Here's the star
by bsder 10y ago
Spoken like someone who hasn't taught a CS class.
You really want to teach some useful skills and not actually disrupt your CS class too much? Here's the start.
Lecture 1: How to drive a basic IDE (I used to choose Eclipse, but I might rethink that nowadays depending on language used. One of the IntelliJ projects might be easier.).
Most students are stunned at the difference between what they use as an editor vs what an IDE can do. Once somebody shows them what is possible, they start swimming really well.
Lecture 2: Source control and automated testing.
For most students, they view this as a homework dropbox that checks and runs their work. That's good enough to start. Some of them progress beyond this.
NOW, I can actually start to talk about the substance of my class as well as how to put that in programs.
Guess what? I have to give these lectures to every single class I teach. It doesn't matter if the class is 101 or 499, every single class.
- gravypod 10y agoI've been pushing the head of the class I help TA for to make it mandatory that students use PyCharm. He's still afraid that PyCharm will intimidate the users but I think it's well worth it. We have 2nd and 3rd year students at my college who still haven't opened Eclipse, IntellJ/PyCharm/Whaterver else, or even Visual Studios. They have also never used a debugger. They have no idea what formatting standards, or naming standards are. It's crazy.
- bsder 10y ago> I've been pushing the head of the class I help TA for to make it mandatory that students use PyCharm. He's still afraid that PyCharm will intimidate the users but I think it's well worth it. Dropping an IDE and automated testing into your class is not without cost. 10% of the questions the rest of the semester will be how to do something in the IDE. And, occasionally, you're not going to know the answer. Saying "I don't know" can be intimidating to someone who doesn't have 20+ years of experience. As for source control and automated testing--congratulations, you are now Mr. IT-guy for 30 people for the next 14 weeks. And students can be really creative in wedging their repositories. To this day, I still have no idea how one student managed to create a recursive repository in Subversion. You really have to be committed to accept the cost of the things I recommended.
- sotojuan 10y agoHeh, way more than 10% of my CS classes' questions were how to do stuff in Emacs (what my professor said we should use). I used to just use Sublime and `scp` the files back to the school server.
- bsder 10y agoThat's unsurprising. I would never use vi or emacs for beginners. However, I also didn't care what my students used. I taught Eclipse. One of my students said: "Is using Netbeans okay?" "Okay? That fact that you have a conception about IDE's makes me ecstatic. Absolutely, you can feel free to use whatever you choose. Just know that I can't answer questions about your IDE, so you are on your own for that." For my very senior class, I set things up so that they could actually use any of the JVM languages rather than just straight Java (Using Groovy, Jython, JRuby, etc. would have made their programs SOOOOOOO much smaller and easier). Disappointingly, nobody took advantage of it.
- vorg 10y ago> Using Groovy, Jython, JRuby, etc Hope you included Scala, Clojure, and Kotlin in that list, all of which are more suitable than any of those three. Jython's been around since 1997-ish but isn't used much, nor is JRuby. As for Groovy, I recently looked into its apparent popularity at #17 on the TIOBE ranking and found Baidu was giving a result 12 times too high and Yahoo a result 20 times too high, both of which would skew the ranking. Groovy's real ranking is somewhere below that of #50 ranked Clojure.
- bsder 10y agoI would have taken ANY JVM language at the time. ANy language with hash tables and tuples that wasn't so verbose would have been a vast improvement. Groovy gets a boost because of Gradle which is now the default build system for Android Studio. That's going to artificially inflate its position.
- gravypod 10y ago
- yodsanklai 10y agoUsually, students don't really need IDEs or source control in order to learn the basics. They write short programs that require more thinking than typing/editing. It's only for bigger projects that they start to be useful, and when students reach that stage, they don't have any problem to use them. Actually, IDEs can be problematic for beginners as they may hide things you'd like the students to learn (e.g. compiling from the command line).
- bsder 10y ago> Usually, students don't really need IDEs or source control in order to learn the basics. They write short programs that require more thinking than typing/editing. Only at the very beginning where answers are less than 10 lines. After that, it's surprisingly useful. > It's only for bigger projects that they start to be useful, and when students reach that stage, they don't have any problem to use them. Oh, your naivety is touching. In my senior level class, I expected that the program would end up being about 2000 lines of code by the end. I still needed to give the IDE lecture as people were struggling with editing (foolishly, I didn't give it immediately because I thought like you did). > Actually, IDEs can be problematic for beginners as they may hide things you'd like the students to learn (e.g. compiling from the command line). So wrong. The command line is the LAST place I want a beginner. I don't even want most intermediate students at the command line. The "UNIX lectures" were one of the most hated things in the CS department. In fact, quite a few of the students never compiled anything themselves. They submitted it to my automated tester via source control which would compile and test it immediately. Would I have liked them to compile and test themselves? Absolutely. However, I'm not there to teach infrastructure so I'll take whatever works and lets me get on with teaching the actual information from class.