5 ms·
Why would Sam not go for a third party who was less problematic? There are third party candidates available. Is it because they are unlikely to be elected? I
by mc32 10y ago
Why would Sam not go for a third party who was less problematic? There are third party candidates available. Is it because they are unlikely to be elected? If so, this thinking keeps on trapping us into voting for the least bad of the bad.
- bpicolo 10y ago> Donald Trump represents an unprecedented threat to America, and voting for Hillary is the best way to defend our country against it
- sama 10y agoYes--honestly, for me this is much more about not electing Trump than electing Clinton.
- gragas 10y agoIf you switch Trump and Clinton in that sentence, you'll get something that millions of Americans agree with as well.
- the_watcher 10y agoTo be fair, this pretty much describes why the two party system remains dominant despite increasingly fractured and contentious primaries. Take a look at how aggressively Hillary campaigned against Obama in the 2008 primaries, for example.
- lotso 10y agoIf you really care about improving the viability of third parties in this country, please do that in local and state elections where it is actually possible to elect third parties. Voting for 3rd parties in Presidential elections is fine, but really doesn't do much really and if you actually dig deep into 3rd party Presidential candidates, they're usually not great either.
- dnautics 10y agoThis is an incredibly concern trolling argument. There is no right or wrong way to vote for third parties.
- mc32 10y agoI initially was upset at mr Nader, when Gore lost. I got over it and, in retrospect, the blame is fully on Gore. He simply didn't convince enough people with his message. It wasn't Nader's (or anyone else's) responsibility to make Gore more electable, it was Gore's responsibility.
- the_watcher 10y agoExtremely well said. The point of multiple candidates is to offer voters a choice, and it's the job of a candidate to convince voters to choose him or her. Just because a candidate won a primary in a major party does not entitle the candidate to votes from people who find another candidate more appealing. If you want to vote strategically, fine. You have that option. If you like one candidate best, but the major party candidate is close enough that you're willing to vote for them in the interest of protecting against another outcome, that's also fine. But to the people arguing that voting third party is throwing your vote away: this is the argument that is used to convince otherwise reasonable Republicans to vote for Trump.
- lotso 10y ago>There is no right or wrong way to vote for third parties. Sure, I agree with you. However, if your goal is to make third parties viable long-term in Presidential elections and not dependent on having very unfavorable candidates from the major 2 parties, I would argue that strong local and state 3rd parties are important.
- ones_and_zeros 10y agoIn most social and business circles, especially wealthy ones, supporting a 3rd party presidential candidate puts you in the "out out group", a severe career limiting move (TM).
- meritt 10y agoBecause Sam is an intelligent and rational individual.
- mc32 10y agoIf Trump were to win, Dems would for sure do a reshuffle and look introspectively. If Hillary were to win, there will be little introspection. If Clinton wins, the Repubs will go into a tailspin and introspect, if Trump were to win, Repubs and Dems will have to both look inwardly to figure out how their machinery failed so miserably in the face of a hack -a blowhard with no political experience who will say anything to win and who likely, if elected would make Taft look like a good executive.
- meritt 10y agoMy view is Trump is an existential threat to our way of life and society. His authoritarian trigger-finger views and sheer lack of understanding of anything related to governing a nation will yield a world war and erase many decades, if not centuries, of progress. Democrats and Republicans are already, and will continue, to investigate the failure of their machine. That much is true regardless. It's whether or not we're still here to do that introspection that I'd prefer to save.
- the_watcher 10y agoI honestly don't know a ton about Taft's presidency, but what made him such a bad executive? I really should invest in some books about him, since on the surface, he's pretty interesting: only dual President/Supreme Court justice (which, even if it's inarguable that he was great there, seems completely at odds with the ostensible non-partisanship of the Supreme Court), Teddy Roosevelt's Bull Moose Presidential run was a somewhat direct outcome of his tenure, all on top of the many apocryphal stories about his girth. If you've got any recommendations for learning about his weakness as a President, I'd appreciate them.
- gjolund 10y agoYou just summed up what I have been trying to explain for months. Sometimes things need to get worse before they can get better.
- munificent 10y ago> Is ot because they are unlikely to be elected? It's more than unlikely. There is effectively zero chance of a third party candidate getting elected president in 2016. Voting for one is throwing away your vote. Worse than that, it's throwing away an opportunity to indicate your second choice preference. The US's first-past-the-post electoral system is not great, but voting for a third-party candidate does not at all address that problem. Instead, it plays exactly into the agenda of the two dominant parties by effectively disenfranchising yourself. If you don't like the US's voting system, great, work to change it. Probably start by pushing for more small scale and local elections to switch to smarter voting systems. That way, citizens can used to them there and the venues are easier to change. Maybe eventually that will percolate all the way up and we can change the Constitution and change how the president is elected. In the meantime, vote strategically for which of the two options to choose from that is most closely aligned to your interests.
- the_watcher 10y ago> Voting for one is throwing away your vote. No. It is not. The reason the two party system continues to exist is because so many people insist on there not being other options, despite there literally being other candidates on the ballot. There's a reason why Democrats have continued to spend money on turning Texas blue for years, despite the argument that they are "throwing money away." Momentum matters. Please don't listen to this. It's the absolute worst outcome of the two-party system: they've effectively convinced people that they're stuck with them, and it's why there are regular Republicans voting for Trump. Someone told them that not voting for him was throwing their vote away, and they listened.
- munificent 10y ago> The reason the two party system continues to exist is because so many people insist on there not being other options, despite there literally being other candidates on the ballot. No, it's because the mechanics of the voting rules themselves lead to a stable two party system. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duverger%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duverger%27s_law
- sanjeetsuhag 10y agoI'm assuming because he has taken a good look at the 3rd party candidates of this year ? Case in point : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k3O01EfM5fU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k3O01EfM5fU