3 ms·
An interesting, if somewhat disingenuous perspective. Japan has one person in space, no manned launch capability, Russia has one person in space, with manned la
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
An interesting, if somewhat disingenuous perspective. Japan has one person in space, no manned launch capability, Russia has one person in space, with manned launch capability.
I think of the Soyuz system as the "B-52 of space capsules", conceived in the 50's, first flown in the 60's, and kept flying by incremental avionics updates to the present day. Which makes for a well understood system.
In many ways the Chinese system is an offspring the Soyuz system, while great efforts are made to stress it is a completely Chinese design, clearly they have made many design choices which were directly inspired by the Soyuz capsules, from how the solar panels are attached/deployed to the mass fractions allocated to various parts of the system.
I expect that is for the same reason that Boeing's CST looks like a bigger version of Apollo, because Boeing had all of the Apollo data already and it was perhaps easier for them to start from there and tweak rather than take it from the a blank sheet. I find it particularly interesting that SpaceX's Dragon, Blue Origin's New Armstrong, and SNC's Dream Chaser manned capsules are quite a bit different both from each other and previously flown designs.
So what I see is that the US will shortly (as in within 12 - 18 months) have a variety of manned space launch capabilities, some of which will have targeted return to base capability.
The odd duck out here are the Russians as they really don't seem to have a replacement for Soyuz either in the works or anywhere close to being deployed. That surprises me as they certainly have the expertise to build such a system and they will be at a tactical and strategic disadvantage when both the US and China can launch crews with greater on orbit maneuvering options.
- Alupis 10y ago> The odd duck out here are the Russians as they really don't seem to have a replacement for Soyuz either in the works or anywhere close to being deployed Perhaps this is because they don't really see a need for a new vehicle (Soyuz meets mission requirements just fine), let alone the benefit of having partially re-usable rockets? Partially re-usable rockets require special launch/recovery procedures (ie. a "smart" barge parked in the ocean somewhere, or worse, over land someplace risking the population), a whole lot of R&D, a new untested vehicle, and no guaranteed payoffs (SpaceX's cost reduction and re-usability claims are yet to be proven). The Soyuz, as you've pointed out, is fairly inexpensive (given it's mission), and is very well understood. From their perspective, it seems, the Soyuz is the ideal craft for the job, and any new build would largely result in a new craft meeting the same mission goals, ie. a waste of time and resources when they already have a vehicle that fills that need. As of ~2013, Soyuz has about 939 successful launches, 24 failures, for a total of 963 launches[1]. Seems to be a "recipe" one doesn't want to tinker with. [1] http://space.stackexchange.com/questions/2138/how-many-successful-soyuz-launches-have-there-been http://space.stackexchange.com/questions/2138/how-many-succe...
- mikeash 10y agoI don't think the Russians see "over land" as a particularly big obstacle. Right now they just drop their spent first stages on land without much guidance. Before launches from Baikonur, they send out soldiers in helicopters to warn the nomads, and otherwise it's pretty much every man for himself. Salvaging the spent stages is apparently a bit of a cottage industry there. Just a bit of a nitpick, your overall point here is entirely sound.
- PerfectDlite 10y ago> That surprises me as they certainly have the expertise to build such a system This might be questionable. Soyuz (as the name implies) was built in USSR, not Russia. After USSR dissolved some experts were outside Russia. And since several decades passed most people with Soviet knowledge are already retired.
- DominikR 10y agoI don't know about that, at least regarding rocket technology they seem to be ahead and not by a small factor, probably a decade. (they have been upgrading their ICBM's and missile defence systems very aggressively in the last 15 years)