8 ms·
I think Wikileaks is definitely anti-Clinton but it's a stretch to say they're pro-Trump.
by gaius 10y ago
I think Wikileaks is definitely anti-Clinton but it's a stretch to say they're pro-Trump.
- tptacek 10y agoPeople keep saying that. It is the single most common rebuttal given to this argument. But I can't understand how it makes any sense at all. It's a two-person race. It's zero-sum. To materially oppose one candidate is to materially support the other. That is, i assume, why Trump's campaign keeps claiming they coordinate directly with Assange through an intermediary. Can someone (calmly) explain why anyone should take seriously the idea that Assange can singlehandedly run virtually the entire opposition research campaign against Hillary Clinton and not be supporting Trump?
- zzleeper 10y agoI think Assange doesn't care that much who is elected, as long as it's not Hillary (because of the things she did against him and the things she promised to do). In this case his only choice is Trump, but it could have been others.
- tptacek 10y agoTo believe that Assange is motivated by a vendetta against HRC, you not only have to conjure up a plausible motive for that vendetta despite Clinton's marginal role in any of the US's dealings with Wikileaks, but also rationalize his efforts to put into power someone who has promised to put Edward Snowden to death. No, not buying it.
- matthewrobertso 10y agoDoes HRC wanting to drone strike Assange qualify as something he might be concerned about? https://www.rt.com/usa/361459-secretary-clinton-drone-assange/ https://www.rt.com/usa/361459-secretary-clinton-drone-assang...
- JamesBarney 10y agoNo real evidence for this. http://www.snopes.com/julian-assange-drone-strike/ http://www.snopes.com/julian-assange-drone-strike/
- DominikR 10y agoThe person who wrote this article is obviously engaging in high level mental gymnastics. She explicitly asked to have Assange assassinated -> people laughed -> until they realised she was serious because she offers arguments why it would be better to kill him. My 2 cents: Assange is anti establishment and that's why he helps Trump.
- tptacek 10y agoIt doesn't take gymnastics to reach the conclusion that the Secretary of State of the United States of America is not seriously advocating for a military strike on the Ecuadorian embassy in the largest city of our closest ally. The notion that Clinton wants to "drone" Assange is about as credible as the notion that she and Podesta discussed murdering Antonin Scalia in a "Wetworks" operation.
- luminiferous 10y agoWasn't this supposed drone quote said before Assange entered the Ecuadorian embassy? The quote was in 2010, but Assange wasn't at the embassy until 2012. Not to say I believe that Clinton was seriously considering assassinating Assange, but I don't think that not wanting a drone strike in the middle of London is a valid argument against it.
- ikeboy 10y agoThe obvious theory for Trump support would be: He thinks Trump will severely harm America, and he really hates America.
- tptacek 10y agoI assume that's what he's doing. Think about that, though: to fuck over America, he'll help elect someone who has promised to kill Edward Snowden.
- kyledrake 10y agoThis is a really good point. HRC isn't necessarily good for Wikileaks, but Trump would conceivably be a lot, lot worse. Perhaps the idea is that they might get off easier if Trump feels Wikileaks gave him an election present, but I find that to be a high risk gamble, especially at this point. That said, the argument could perhaps just as easily be made if they leaked a bunch of Trump stuff too. I don't think anyone can really determine motives at this point with the current base of information.
- tptacek 10y agoWe're not required to unspool Assange's weird motives to acknowledge that he is essentially functioning as an arm of the Trump campaign, and must know that he's doing so.
- dragonwriter 10y agoI don't see any evidence that he is providing any electoral even fit to Trump; I think he is more, in effect, serving as an arm of the Russian regime acting to undermine trust in the US leadership and government regardless of the election results than he is acting to improve Trump's electoral prospects.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- existencebox 10y agoLet me take on that question, as someone who would willingly attack Hillary while simultaneously refusing to support Trump. If I want to be internally consistent as a supporter of truth/justice/liberty/all those tasty things, I MUST NOT hesitate to release damaging information along those lines for the sake of a "lesser of two evils" justification. Your statement of zero-sum two person race is also a principle I believe one must sacrifice a "lesser of two evils" discussion to rally against, I believe that accepting we are in a two person race is part and parcel with the level of polarization/group-think we're seeing nowadays. The first steps to a better world in my eyes are to question EVERYTHING and become as vehemently anti-tribal as possible, and that means not withholding things that my moral code would demand I act on, even if it might harm the horse I'm rooting for. (quite to the opposite actually, if I saw that my main candidate had flaws and wasn't getting called out on them, I would see it as my obligation to do so even MORE so, since to whitewash in that direction to my eyes weakens what would otherwise be a valid stance. e.g., all things have negatives, even perhaps a positive choice, but to ignore them is duplicitous.) tl;dr, my goals in this are not "this election" or "this candidate"; it's "getting people to question more"; "getting people to realize it doesn't NEED to be a zero-sum game". One may say this is idealistic/drop in the ocean etc; but I cannot reconcile with my personal philosophy giving up, because if I did, then there is no justification for ANYONE ELSE to push for these "impossible" goals, and thus the status quo/tragedy of the commons continues.
- tptacek 10y agoTo believe that's what Assange is trying to do, you'd have to explain away the drip-drip scheduling of the releases and the (often false) editorializing he does with decontextualized snippets from the email leaks. It's not simply that Assange is exclusively leaking stolen emails from Democrats, but the manner in which he's doing it.
- existencebox 10y agoThat's a fair point, I can't say I'm as tuned into the drama as tightly as I should (or shouldn't, for my mental sanity?) be. I was more addressing the general case of your question; can his local actions of seeming uniformly opposing one party occur out of any incentive other than being in the pocket of that party, and additionally your statement re: zero-sum-game given that being an argument I find frustrating. Taking into account broader context should adjust your prior, for sure.
- gaius 10y agoAs a non-American, I don't really care about US domestic politics, but I do care a very great deal about there not being a shooting war with Russia. Hillary wants to force the Russians out of Syria. So it's perfectly possible to simultaneously believe that Trump will be a terrible President, but that that's better for everyone outside the US than Hillary. We all wanted Bernie, but he sold out :-(
- aaroninsf 10y agoI beg to differ. In a two horse race, throwing stones in front of one horse has an obvious and calculated effect. There was a time when I believed in Wikileaks. But collusion, orchestrated or not, with Putin and Trump crosses a clear line. When you sell your services or align your actions with fascists, you are not longer serving the public interest, merely your own. Let's not equivocate. Trump is an opportunistic fascist, apparently with aspirations to become America's analog to Putin the authoritarian fascist thug. The cynic in me wonders what Putin has on Assange.