3 ms·
An embassy is outside the jurisdiction of the host country, but is subject to the jurisdiction of the guest country. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vienna_C
by Symbiote 10y ago
An embassy is outside the jurisdiction of the host country, but is subject to the jurisdiction of the guest country.
See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vienna_Convention_on_Diplomatic_Relations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vienna_Convention_on_Diplomati...
- Tomte 10y agoBut it is not part of the guest country. So Assange is still residing in England, not in Ecuador.
- monocasa 10y agoBut still outside the UK judicial process.
- tptacek 10y agoThat doesn't really mean anything. If Assange was arrested in the embassy, or, like, by a helicopter when he's out on the balcony, he would very much end up subject to the UK judicial process. The thing protecting Assange right now isn't the judicial process, but rather the inviolability of embassies. The UK police are adhering to the norm that they can't enter the embassy without permission. That norm is routinely violated in other places, but I think everyone involved is comfortable with Assange's self-inflicted house arrest.
- monocasa 10y agoRight, outside of the UK judicial process.
- Symbiote 10y agoAssange cannot be arrested in the Ecuadorian embassy without the permission of the Ecuadorian ambassador. The British police can't enter the embassy without permission. The balcony makes no difference. > That norm is routinely violated in other places No, it isn't. That would severely damage relationships between the two countries. It's more than a "norm", it's a fundamental principle of diplomacy going back millennia.
- tptacek 10y agoIt's a fundamental principle of diplomacy going back 55 years, and if you'd like to put money on my inability to cite you an example of a country not respecting the inviolability of a diplomatic mission on their own soil, I invite you to name a number. At any rate: we agree: it's the Vienna Accords that keep the UK from simply lassoing Assange and hauling him out of the building. It has nothing to do with whether he's on Ecuadorian soil (he is not).
- monocasa 10y agoThe Vienna Convention is only the current basis for international law. The concept of diplomatic immunity is at least as hold as history itself. Yes it gets violated occasionally, like nearly every law and custom we've ever created. That's generally treated as an act of war though. You're the only one in this thread that said anything about Ecuadorian soil.