3 ms·
When the state takes such invasive action, it needs to pass a very high bar. Even with the best intentions, state institutions rarely treat people under their c
by barrkel 10y ago
When the state takes such invasive action, it needs to pass a very high bar. Even with the best intentions, state institutions rarely treat people under their care better than relatives and close friends.
You can see the other side of this, of course: each decision derives from laws and judgements that were made or justified on the basis of wrongdoings.
It follows the same pattern as anti-drug legislation. Drugs do damage, so let's outlaw the drug. But the state's attempt to outlaw the drug means using its monopoly on violence, and that causes more total harm than the original problem. Laws against abusive situations in families or preventing vulnerable people being scammed out of their money need to take into account the possibility that the state will make things worse.