6 ms·
Soviet scientists tried for decades to network their nation
- patkai 10y agoThe Cybernetics angle is really interesting. I thought the Chilean Cybersyn project -https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2003/sep/08/sciencenews.chile https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2003/sep/08/sciencene... - led by Stafford Beer was an isolated case, but apparently not. An even more distant angle: I just read the autobiography of David Hilbert, and apparently he thought Norbert Wiener was an fraud of some sort. Cybernetics, Systems Science, Complex Systems - these draw a certain type person, and apparently a type of political system, too.
- danielmorozoff 10y agoThis is a fantastic writeup. this quote really struck me and seems very apt to today: 'Glushkov’s story is also a stirring reminder to the investor classes and other agents of technological change that astonishing genius, far-seeing foresight and political acumen are not enough to change the world. Supporting institutions often make all the difference. '
- neolefty 10y agoAnd: "There is an irony to this. The first global computer networks took root in the US thanks to well-regulated state funding and collaborative research environments, while the contemporary (and notably independent) national network efforts in the USSR floundered due to unregulated competition and institutional infighting among Soviet administrators. The first global computer network emerged thanks to capitalists behaving like cooperative socialists, not socialists behaving like competitive capitalists."
- simonh 10y agoYet mobile networks flourished in heavily regulated Europe, largely due to enforced standardization, years before they became ubiquitous in the USA. I worked in the Mobile industry in the late 90s. I remember being on a bus in Madrid airport taking us to our plane. Some young Spaniards were talking loudly on their mobiles while the two American tourists sitting near me gaped at them. One turned to the other and said 'Those things are everywhere. They use them all the time.' It was probably just a brief period of time, but I found it striking.
- berntb 10y agoLook up the OSI standards. They were a horror to implement and use. The telecom companies wanted those to be used instead of the US tcp/ip stack. They would have had much more control and could have been fat cats, taking a large piece of the slice. Be damn happy they failed. :-) A heterogeneous world is an advantage, it gets harder for oligopolies to charge at every gate.
- raattgift 10y agoThere was a substantial overlap between the then Internet Activities Board and the committees associated with ISO/IEC 7498, and it was far from dominated by telecomms companies at the time. Indeed, Lyman Chapin of BBN was in ca. 1992 the chair of both! Other overlappers included Christian Huitema and IIRC Dave Katz. The OSI reference model itself originated with Charles Bachman (Honeywell, then IBM). So far, no telecomms companies to be seen. Telecomms companies and agencies were more interested in EDI in the form of X.400(84) and to some extent X.500 directory services, rather than in the lower layers, and while they were heavily invested in X.25, they were not the biggest pushers for the connection-oriented lower layers -- there were plenty of private X.25 networks operated by government agencies (including many non-PTT ones; bear in mind that the CCITT of the time was national governments represented by their local postal-telegraph-and-telecommunications ministries; the U.S. and Canada were huge outliers in having privately owned commercial telcos). There were also research & education networks with X.25 underneath, including CSNET (largely based in the USA) which was definitely part of the TCP/IP-speaking Internet. OSI's problems weren't in the people involved or in the (admittedly heavy) formalisms that go into ISO/IEC/CCITT/ITU standards, but rather that the idea was to redo TCP/IP "right", and that included supporting difficult to reconcile goals, like supporting both connection-less and connection-oriented protocols in most of the lowest of the 7 layers, and then mechanisms to provide interoperability between CO-only and CL-only talkers. At the time, well before FPGAs and ASICs were accelerating routers, and when megabytes of RAM were expensive (and slow), OSI appeared too heavyweight compared to TCP/IP, and that is one of many reasons TCP/IP won. OSI reference implementations were expensive rather than free as in beer (sort-of); compiling up your OSI elements took considerably longer; an OSI-equipped kernel was fat (too fat if it was only really talking ES-IS and nothing else); and so forth. SMTP/TCP/IP was what members of the OSI subcommittees were using to communicate with one another, in spite of the existence of EAN for X.400 and some native OSI CLNP (AlterNet, UUNET's internetwork, in the very early 1990s carried real CLNP traffic between RAND and several other organizations). Internet protocols did benefit from the OSI development work; good ideas from IDRP found their way into BGP4; IS-IS is still the IGP of choice for some large IP networks; LDAP, SNMP and others absorbed good ideas from X.500 and EFTAM; and of course DSL and OTN systems have a lot of OSI in their DNA. Finally, the U.S. government's GOSIP and similar programmes for mandatory adoption of OSI networking elsewhere probably doomed OSI networking much more than politics (and personality conflicts) among people involved in actually making the standards in the various bodies, both international (and national) and in the IETF and its close relatives. Taking profile "short cuts" to roll out OSI networking rapidly in that way raised the real possibility of fully conforming OSI networks (and stacks) that would nevertheless be mutually incompatible! Unfortunately many of the lessons learned in the failure of OSI networking were not applied in the process of choosing and standardizing a successor protocol for IP, and here we are a couple decades later with IPv6 being a compromise specification designed for speed of roll out... (In fact some of the wrong lessons learned in the very early 1990s of OSI networking are in IPv6 today: the expectation that being CPU constrained, routers must deal with relatively short, fixed-length, fixed-format fields (rather than, say, something self-describing) is front-and-centre in IPv6 addressing and headers generally. Concerns about overheads are also well-reflected in IPv6, and for terrestrial applications, those concerns were obsoleted by the turn of the century.) "A hetereogeneous world is an advantage". Well, try explaining that on the IETF mailing list as a reason to support concurrent development of a successor protocol to IPv6.
- badmadrad 10y ago"Socialist-like" policies usually work when they have militaristic end goals. The reason is that the govt is actually incentivized to maintain its power and protect it citizenry. Most even right leaning people would agree that government spending in this case actually makes sense because the government is directly acting in its own interests much like a private company does.
- digi_owl 10y agoAs best i can tell, the soviet system dreamed up by Lenin and cooped into a personality cult by Stalin was pretty much a bastardization of what Marx was envisioning. Not that communism and Socialism was more than far flung ideals even for Marx. For the most part he was appalled by the working conditions of factory workers at his time. That said, ol' Marx was not completely against capitalism. He did see that it had the capacity to rapidly industrialize a nation. What he did point out though was inherent flaws in the system, flaws not just relevant to worker exploitation but also the whole engine of spending money to earning even more money. In that he perhaps noticed a hint of something that even present day mainstream economics has problem noticing, the feedback loops related to the flow of money and goods. Notice that the article mentions in passing equilibria. That is a notion that is persistent within economics, even though it introduced more to make the math easier to work with back when it was done by hand and pencil. these days all but economics have abandoned any notion of equilibrium, instead using computers to model complex systems and their feedbacks. Something that was spearheaded by meteorologists trying to improve weather prediction. To go back to Marx, what he envisioned was more a transition from capitalist owned factories to worker owned factories. Coops essentially. Things like trading would still remain, as they provide vital means of signaling along the supply chains. He did btw have some nasty things to say about finance capital, perhaps forewarning both the great depression and out present situation. His great lament in that regard was that industrial capitalists were more likely to side with finance capital in any three way struggle between them and the workforce, when industrial capitalists would be better off in the long run to side with the workforce against finance.
- alexro 10y agoGlushkov has build a unique PC too https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MIR_(computer) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MIR_(computer)
- walter_bishop 10y ago"The distributed network was originally designed to nudge the US ahead of the Soviets, allowing scientists’ and government leaders’ computers to communicate even in the event of a nuclear attack. " https://aeon.co/essays/how-the-soviets-invented-the-internet-and-why-it-didn-t-work https://aeon.co/essays/how-the-soviets-invented-the-internet... No no no, the Arpanet was never designed to survive a nuclear war, the originators are even quoted as saying so. footnotes 5: http://www.internetsociety.org/internet/what-internet/history-internet/brief-history-internet http://www.internetsociety.org/internet/what-internet/histor...
- arcanus 10y agoA reminder that Soviet science used to rival the West's capabilities, or even surpass them. A pity that Russia has fallen so far behind in this regard.
- maga 10y agoUnfortunately that's something younger generations would find hard to believe watching news coming from the area. Last I checked, they were busy opening a Theology department in their top tech university[1], and blessing their rockets[2]. [1] http://www.asianews.it/news-en/Moscow-scientific-university-announces-chair-in-theology-26141.html http://www.asianews.it/news-en/Moscow-scientific-university-... [2] http://time.com/3759467/rocket-blessing-soyuz/ http://time.com/3759467/rocket-blessing-soyuz/
- zokier 10y agoWhile true in some areas, computers and advanced electronics was not one of those things. I don't think Soviets really ever got very good at producing integrated circuits, and even less at designing them. By mid-70s when stuff like less-than-room-sized computers and internet really began to take form, Soviets were already almost exclusively trying to keep up with western microprocessor tech with straight up clones, with the gap consistently increasing.
- baybal2 10y agothe reason it failed abd the guy got fried was simple if state company records were kept off-site on a computer, it will make quiet ledger rigging and stealing from state companies harder. That would be outrageous for every commie as every commie was stealing cash from the state one way or another.