5 ms·
I'm curious - is your (and maciej's, if he's still following this thread) position that someone should refuse to associate with anyone who supports Trump? Take
by nostrademons 10y ago
I'm curious - is your (and maciej's, if he's still following this thread) position that someone should refuse to associate with anyone who supports Trump? Take Graham and Altman out of the equation - assuming that this is not just a vendetta against YC partners (and the principle of charity compels me to assume that), would you apply this standard to other people you know? Do you have friends and business partners that support Trump, or buy products from Trump-supporting companies?
For me personally - I actually have relatively few people in my life that are Trump supporters. But this is mostly an accident of demographics - I went to an elite liberal arts college in what is literally the most liberal region of the country, I worked at Google, I live in the Bay Area, my mom's from NYC, and my dad's an immigrant. I have friends who have family that are hard-core Trump supporter, as well as family myself.
It would never occur to me to stop associating with them because of their political views, or the political views of their associates. They have their beliefs, I have mine, and we just don't discuss the subjects where we are diametrically opposed. We interact on the common ground that we do have.
According to my principles, the calls for YC to disavow Thiel or stop associating with him are obnoxious for the same reason I believe Trump is unfit to be president. They divide the world into "people like us" and "people against us", and then seek to build a wall between the two groups. If you believe that it should be "us and us" rather than "us vs them", then that includes reaching out to people with whom you disagree and finding the parts that you do agree on.
- tptacek 10y agoI understand why people think Maciej has a "vendetta" against YC, but I definitely do not. We considered joining YC's last summer session, after Altman generously invited us. I've recommended several startups to YC, over the objections of other friends to some of the same startups, and YC has made money as a result. I'm personal friends with both current and former YC partners, and numerous YC founders. I started a VC-funded startup in '99-'00 and worked for another VC-funded startup for 4 years after that, and attempted to raise money in '05: I am painfully aware of how abusive Silicon Valley was to tech founders prior to YC, and of all the work YC has done to remediate those abuses. I often feel like YC gets a bad rap. In fact: I even feel like Paul Graham often gets a bad rap. But Paul Graham and Sam Altman are comprehensively wrong about Thiel, and I would be doing them no favors at all to pretend otherwise. I'm Catholic. I come from an Irish Catholic family. I have at last count 13,492 first cousins. I do not know all the names of my aunts and uncles. But I do know that most of them are... "aggressively" pro-life. Some of them support Trump, because they feel a moral obligation to vote for whomever is going to appoint pro-life judges. I do not hold Trump support against my family. Despite the fact that half of HN seems to think I'm a Republican, I am not. But I have plenty of Republican friends. Most of them have repudiated Trump and think he's a disaster for the party. But some of them believe in good faith that the cause of limited government is better served by Trump than by Hillary Clinton. I think they're gravely mistaken. But I don't hold that against them. I'm fine with doing business with any of these people. However, if you're in the audience at a Trump rally whooping and hollering your approval for Trump's claim that some women are too ugly to have been assaulted by him, I want nothing to do with you, at least until you've repudiated that disgusting notion. If you're the person telling reporters that you're going to perform much-needed "racial profiling" at polling places on election day, to intimidate minorities from voting, I want nothing to do with you, at least until you've repudiated that disgusting notion. If you're a billionaire who has stood on the largest imaginable stage and told the nation on live television that Donald Trump is the only honest candidate, and who donated $1.25MM to the Trump campaign after he threatened to jail his political opponent and started a national tour inciting white voters to distrust the votes of minorities in a rigged election, then you aren't a supporter of the Trump campaign. You are part of the Trump campaign. I want nothing to do with you. Nobody who claims they'll "join the resistance" after Trump wins can coherently argue otherwise. I don't demand that Altman and Graham sever ties in any formal way with Thiel. I don't know what that would entail or what's going on behind the scenes. But I do require them not to support Thiel publicly --- at least, if they're going to claim to be part of the resistance against Trump. You can't oppose Trump but defend the Trump campaign.
- pen2l 10y agoI like your thoughtful reply and agree with you, but want to point out that you are drawing somewhat arbitrary lines here on what is fine and what is not fine in supporting Trump. For example, wouldn't you agree that any of your cousins who support Trump -- the ones you are in good terms with now, if they had Thiel-money, they probably would have donated a million or two to him?
- tptacek 10y agoIf I had a cousin who donated millions to Donald Trump, I assume we would not be on good terms afterwards. You've zeroed in on something implicit in my argument: yes, with escalating power in society comes escalating responsibility not to do harm. Another way to look at it is: any cousin of mine hooting and hollering about black folks and "too-ugly" assault victims is no friend of mine, either.
- pen2l 10y ago> You've zeroed in on something implicit in my argument: yes, with escalating power in society comes escalating responsibility not to do harm. So you're more a consequentialist than a deontologist, okay.
- tptacek 10y agoI'm very much not a consequentialist. Like I said, I'm Catholic. I'm about as deontological as you can get and still be a software developer.
- pen2l 10y agoWell, you're at least somewhat consequentialist because you've just said you'll judge a person differently depending on what means and resources are available to them. You're okay with your cousin supporting Trump (and giving his campaign a paltry $20USD donation?) but you're not okay with them if they were richer and were giving the campaign a $2M donation. Where am I misunderstanding you?
- idlewords 10y agoI appreciate the charitable reading and will try to do likewise. I see a significant difference between private political opinions (including their expression by voting), and a public political act like a convention keynote speech. It's important in a pluralistic society that we live and work with people with very different political views. But Thiel doesn't just have his contrarian opinions, he is actively working to promote the candidacy of someone who is a threat to our basic democratic institutions. To me that's a significant difference, and the reason it calls for a public and forceful response.
- nostrademons 10y agoHmm, interesting. So would it be acceptable if Graham & Altman were more vocal about their support for Clinton? To my mind, they've been pretty vocal already, between their Twitter feeds and published articles about how they sit around Sam Altman's dinner table and discuss ways to defeat Trump. I suspect that Paul Graham may also have donated > $1.25M to Clinton's campaign, based on his recent Tweet about the number of non-profits that could've been funded with the money he's spent defeating Trump. But you're right that this is not covered on the national stage the way Thiel's RNC convention speech or $1.25M donation have. (Much of this may also be because everything that Thiel does that could remotely be spun into the "power-broker behind the scenes, doing evil things" narrative tends to make the press, post-Gawker, which to be fair had much of the same ick-factor as this debate.) To me, the right answer to bad speech is better speech. It's fine to disassociate from people if you dislike them - but there's a big difference between disliking them and disliking one position they hold, or even more tenuously, disliking the people they associate with. Most people associate with a lot of other people, and these networks grow ever bigger as you get older and more powerful. If you start disqualifying people based on the company they keep, the set of people that you actually like will get both ever-smaller and more monocultural. Some people like that - I suspect many Trump supporters wish the world could be divided into black & white-Christians-who-act-like-us - but I think you'd lose a lot in this.
- idlewords 10y agoI wonder if the difference between us is that you view what Thiel did as speech, where I see it as a major political act, that demands some kind of response. I don't want Graham and Altman to be more vocal about Clinton, I want them to say something substantive about Thiel, and why (or whether) they are comfortable continuing to do business with him.
- uola 10y agoRegardless if I agree or not I can understand your opinions about Thiel being free to support Trump politically. What I can't understand is why he should be able to continue his association with YC without even answering questions. YC supposedly uninvited supporters of SOPA from demo day, but when you're actively trying to elect someone to the highest office in the country you don't even have to explain what you mean? I don't really see how you can have a democratic society when people can't even be held accountable for fundamental things.