5 ms·
No, it's what happens when large numbers of people decide they care about safety and security more than they care about freedom. That doesn't necessarily make
by lisper 10y ago
No, it's what happens when large numbers of people decide they care about safety and security more than they care about freedom. That doesn't necessarily make it any better, but to attribute this outcome to mindlessness is to badly miss the point. The first step to solving a problem is to understand what the problem actually is.
- M_Grey 10y agoThe problem is that we're not exchanging freedom for security, we're exchanging freedom for the empty promise of security and the reality of a police state. I'm still calling "mindless".
- trendia 10y agoTo give another example: If the US were to outlaw all forms of encryption, we would have less privacy AND less security: Less Privacy: all communication is now readable by a third party in the middle Less Security: all banking information is now transmitted in plaintext
- tedunangst 10y agoA locked phone is a lot less interesting to a burglar. If the convenience of touch ID means more people lock their phones, that's not an empty promise.
- M_Grey 10y agoHow many people lock their phones against burglary?
- tedunangst 10y agoOne. Me.
- M_Grey 10y agoHuh... why? I mean, burglars and hackers are usually very different people, and the former usually doesn't care about what's on your phone, just your phone. I grant however, that you could have a particular situation perhaps relating to your work which might alter that.
- KJP191 10y agoYou think a thief won't go through an unlocked phone they stole? Even if they don't, the person they fence it to will.
- M_Grey 10y agoI think whatever is on your phone would be of little or no interest to either party.
- dagss 10y agoThieves sell the phone on to people who know how to exploit what is on your phone to try to get access to your accounts and money.
- M_Grey 10y agoHow would your phone give them access to any of that? All of that kind of thing is inevitably protected by more security layers they won't be able to break, and meanwhile, the phone itself is worth something once wiped. Worse, the longer they fiddle with your phone, unwiped, the longer they risk someone tracking that phone. They're burglars, not masterminds.
- dagss 10y agoWhat I heard is phones are often sold off by burglars to organized crime who do know how to exploit the phone to its full potential (and not get tracked, and properly wipe it and resell it after properly copying off the data/login credentials which is sold to another party, which then package the data with other data and sell that, and so on). Wish I had some better sources. All I could find from a quick google search is that the market rate for full personal info is $20 -- that is certainly something you can get with email inbox access (which is enough to get Amazon login which would have your full address etc etc) Keep in mind most services only needs your email address and browser cookies for full access, only banking services etc are 2FA.
- Johnny555 10y agohow many people lock their phones for any other reason? I only lock my phone in case it's lost or stolen, I don't lock it to keep the government out of it, since pretty much everything on my phone is available in Google's Cloud services (except for my password protected password manager), which the feds can gain access to with a valid search warrant.
- ZoeZoeBee 10y ago? Who are the large numbers of people you speak of, who decided perceived "safety and security" are more desirable than freedom? Far as I can tell the general public had no say in the legislation, and the legislatures who pushed through the Patriot Act reassured their constituents that the abuses we're witnessing were not under the realm of possibility. Meanwhile the Feds techniques of warrant-less intervention and forced entry of suspects phone have yet to yield measurable results. The general public is mindless to the extent of surveillance and the aggregation of that data, the vast majority are certainly unaware of the possible unintended consequences of wanton disregard for the 3rd, 4th and 5th amendments. Only a third of Americans can even name all three branches of government, to believe they're informed on matters they don't understand on a technical or philosophical level is badly overestimating the American Public.
- eternalban 10y agoLet's put this in its political context. We are citizens of a constitutional republic. A republic, as far as I understand it, implies that a (thoughtful, responsible, .., elected) minority is afforded the delegated power to legislate, judge, and administer. The 'actual problem' seems to be in the selection/delegation process. The minority that is currently in charge has framed the question as that of "safety and security" vs liberties ("freedoms"). The corporate media (aka "journalists" and "free press") is more than happy to support this thesis. The "people", lets be frank here, were never expected to be a nation of Jeffersons. And it is unreasonable to expect them to be astute techno-political scientists carefully weighing various implications of technology and policy. Other unelected minorities -- corporations such as Apple, Google, Facebook, ... -- could by fiat choose to only offer goods that preserve our liberties. They chose not to do so and arguably they are not under an obligation to do so. (Note arguably.) Other unelected minorities -- technologists that work for the above -- have also elected to lend their talents to produce these systems, platforms, and devices that erode our liberties. Again, arguably they don't really have much choice in the matter, as we all must pay the proverbial rent. So, imho, beyond the cliche that 'a people deserve their government' (which is a congenital defect of a political body), there remains the framework that was intended to select the best and brightest minority that would be entrusted with carefully considering various options. It is this framework that is currently broken. I accuse our so called "free press" for a playing a substantial role in the dysfunction of our political system. There are other responsible parties for sure, but the press and media play a critical role in knowingly confusing and frightening the majority -- a role known as agitprop in the USSR. [edit: noop cleanup]
- lambertsimnel 10y agoThe current voting system doesn't help. A national popular vote for president under IRV and proportional representation for Congress are necessary parts of the solution.
- dmoy 10y agoirv would be nice, but I feel like campaign finance reform would help more.