5 ms·
FWIW, I'm glad YC is taking this stance. Firing someone over their personal political views is very icky. You would be up in arms if your boss fired you becau
by nostrademons 10y ago
FWIW, I'm glad YC is taking this stance. Firing someone over their personal political views is very icky. You would be up in arms if your boss fired you because of who you were supporting for president, so why would you wish that upon someone else?
- idlewords 10y agoWe're not talking about firing, or employees, or personal political views. Otherwise your argument stands. At issue is the most public endorsement possible (a keynote speech, and then a 1.25M donation) by a YC partner, and YC's refusal to speak out about it, or distance itself from this extraordinary gesture of support.
- nostrademons 10y agoYC does not (to my knowledge) have a corporate position on the presidential race - I'd welcome any citations where a YC partner, speaking in an official capacity, endorses one of the current presidential candidates. When they have taken corporate political positions, it's usually been narrowly defined, in support of specific legislation that affects the tech industry (eg. anti-SOPA, anti-software-patents, pro-immigration). The vast majority of YC partners' personal positions are strongly pro-Clinton. You can see that just by following sama, paulg, or paultoo on Twitter.
- tptacek 10y agoIt would suffice for me to see any public reluctance on the part of Paul Graham or Sam Altman to continue to associate professionally with Thiel so long as he is playing this role in American politics. I don't demand that Altman and Graham know exactly what to do about this. I don't demand that they "fire" Thiel (they can't, as Thiel isn't an employee). I don't even demand that they strike him from the roster of Partners to the Regional Partner of YC. I understand that this stuff is complicated and that there's more going on behind the scenes of these relationships than we know. Unfortunately, both Altman and Graham are being supportive of Thiel, despite the fact that he donated $1.25MM to Trump's campaign just days ago.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- edanm 10y agoIsn't the fact that they're making it clear that they're against Trump enough? Why do you think they need to also be against Thiel, "just" because of his political activities? Clearly everyone would find it incredibly wrong if someone would withdraw support for someone just because they supported Hillary Clinton, and while most people here think Trump is much worse, he is the head of one of the 2 major parties. You might not like it, but his actions and views do represent a significant portion of the mainstream (which is why this isn't the same as supporting someone from the KKK, which does thankfully lie outside the mainstream). Note: I am in no way endorsing or defending Trump, or Thiel.
- tptacek 10y agoIn a real way, Thiel is Trump. He's a part of Trump's political campaign. He's no mere supporter: he's a surrogate. He was placed on stage at the RNC to suggest to the world that Silicon Valley supported Trump. His recent donation to Trump is still on the front page of CNN. You cannot coherently oppose Trump and support Trump's political campaign. Let me put it this way: According to the logic that Altman and Graham are using, if Donald Trump himself were a "part-time partner" at YC, they would be unable to disassociate themselves from him.
- edanm 10y agoThere's certainly a line where someone stops being "just" a supporter and becomes something more. E.g. a big complaint against Brendan Eich was that he wasn't just anti-gay-rights, he actually contributed money for the Prop 8 fight. The big question is where that line should be drawn. You say Thiel is a Trump surrogate, but I'm not so sure. Then again, he did donate a substantial amount of money in the last few days, so maybe he really is close enough to the campaign to act as a surrogate, especialy since he is being explicitly given as an example of someone from Silicon Valley who is supporting Trump. It's a hard question - I'm not sure, personally. "You cannot coherently oppose Trump and support Trump's political campaign." Well this part I don't really agree with. A big part of democracy is coherently opposing other people's ideas, while not opposing their right to voice those ideas.
- 4wayssnnbb234 10y agoMate, stop it. We all know that the whole thing is just marketing for you, like PC bros from South Park that want to get some "puss". This behaviour breeds support for Trump. People feel they are being attack.
- archagon 10y agoThe issue of firing aside, I think most people could easily imagine a political figure whose supporters they would outright disavow and want nothing to do with. To me and many, many others, Trump is unequivocally past that line. When a candidate stands before violent, cheering crowds and promises to tear up the constitution, the people propping him up need to be held fully and publicly accountable.