3 ms·
For your edit: > I don't see why you feel "journalism" is a legally protected status. Because the first amendment both stipulated freedom of speech and specif
by kbenson 10y ago
For your edit:
> I don't see why you feel "journalism" is a legally protected status.
Because the first amendment both stipulated freedom of speech and specifically the rights of the press. It's core to how our democracy functions. Without an informed populace, there can be no democracy.
> What protections do journalists have that I don't if I write wherever I want?
That question belies an assumption (or uses it for effect) that you aren't a journalist if you write what you want. This is a controversial assumption that is getting more attention as the hurdles to publishing have been lowered with the internet. Everyone has the capability to be a journalist now, even if it's only for a moment. What you specifically get as a journalist (meaning you are partaking in journalism) is specific protection in some cases[1], and general protection from your general actions being legislated against through the first amendment.
> What obligations do they have that they can be criminally prosecuted for? (albeit in 'egregious' cases).
They cannot break the law. That said, they are protected automatically from laws that target journalism through the first amendment. In this case, a law about being part of(?) a riot has been leveled against her, but she has clear constitutional rights to protect any actions that were for the benefit of the populace by reporting on the incident. Just being present is not enough.
On the other hand, if she were found to have been suggesting that people take action at the location, rather than just reporting on what they were doing, I think that is something they could legally and constitutionally attempt to prosecute, as she was not just reporting the situation, she was causing the situation (presumably not through informing the people present of the facts). Not that I've seen any evidence to suggest this is the case, beyond the charge itself. I am not a lawyer though, so take what I say as opinion and as I understand it.
1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shield_laws_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shield_laws_in_the_United_Stat...
- logicallee 10y agoThank you.