3 ms·
To be fair, even leveling charges against her and arresting her has a chilling effect on the Press.
by noobermin 10y ago
To be fair, even leveling charges against her and arresting her has a chilling effect on the Press.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI'm not quite sure about that, I dated a journalism major at USC and she told me about a seminar the law school did for journalism majors called "what to do when you are arrested." I will grant you that it was primarily focused on being in a foreign country (lots of stuff about what the embassy can do, what the consulate can do, and what sort of agreements countries have with the US regarding journalists) but there was a section on being arrested in the US as well.
- forgottenpass 10y agoI dated a journalism major at USC And I've read the wiki article "Chilling effect" so we're probably equally qualified. Just because jurnos are taught how to resist a chilling effect, does not mean it does not exist.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI don't disagree with that. I absolutely agree that arresting and shooting and villifying people has a chilling effect on their actions. At the same time, while I am not a journalist I've talked to many of them. What has been true in all of the journalists I've met has been both a passion about their mission and a recognition about the risks to themselves about that mission. There reports that over 150 journalists have been killed covering the Iraq war[1] and issues in the middle east. One could argue that dying is the ultimate threat and the most "chilling" of any effect. And yet journalists, even now, are reporting on the heroic efforts of the "White Helmets", the human cost of the sieges and bombing, and the various factions engaged mortal combat there. Journalists, by their own volition, go to centers of conflict. They do that to understand the conflict and to tell the story behind it. They may be idealistic or they may be pragmatic, but they know the risks. And one of the lesser risks is one that you will get arrested and put in jail. It is a "lesser" risk because "getting arrested" already pre-supposes that there is a civil system that is operating well enough to have a notion of "arrest", "trials", and "sentencing". Covering the Contras in Nicaragua you didn't get arrested you got "disappeared."[2] It is so common that the USC School of Journalism nominally assumed that if you were a journalist covering a story in a trouble spot you would get arrested. So anyone who has studied to be a journalist should expect that they might be arrested from time to time and prepared for it. Their parent organization should have legal resources on call, and when arrested the journalist should have a checklist of things to do and not do. Which is what the USC seminar was teaching. As a result, having one of the expected outcomes come to pass, should not be a surprise to someone who was already expecting that could happen. And while having it actually happen might cause them to re-think their career choice, it has been my experience that people willing to go out there and get the story, it is not a disincentive that someone might arrest them. So for the journalist, getting arrested was great thing. It gives her a headline "US Authorities Jailing Journalists!" that grabs at a very closely held American value, freedom of the press. But as a very closely held value it has been litigated extensively and the only time journalists do any jail time at all is when they are held in contempt for not turning over sources. There is a ton of case law here, and if she was just there covering the story, she won't have any issues. And look here 48 hours later, on the 17th the Judge dismisses the case (and her arrest)[3] because guess what, she's protected by the first amendment. Her getting arrested was a non-story. [1] https://cpj.org/blog/2013/03/iraq-war-and-news-media-a-look-inside-the-death-to.php https://cpj.org/blog/2013/03/iraq-war-and-news-media-a-look-... [2] http://catholicherald.com/stories/We-were-disappeared,13011 http://catholicherald.com/stories/We-were-disappeared,13011 [3] http://www.democracynow.org/2016/10/17/watch_amy_goodman_speaks_after_nd http://www.democracynow.org/2016/10/17/watch_amy_goodman_spe...