10 ms·
Why Red Means Red in Almost Every Language (2015)
- woliveirajr 10y agoIt would be interesting to see some color map for each of those groups. Also, do parents who moved abroad have kids with different perception? And would have analysis in some genetic factors (as babies seem to indicate) and the cultural influence.
- moron4hire 10y agoIt's not a difference in perception, it's a difference in communication. Imagine a room full of people wearing "pink" shirts, and you want to call out specifically one of those people, but you don't know the word "salmon" in the context of a color of shirt. You absolutely see the difference in the colors of the shirt. Your lack of language does not change your perception. You know the color and you could pick it again when asked. You just have to go through convolutions to communicate the exact nature of the color to others.
- OJFord 10y agoWe absolutely can differ in perception. As long as the boundaries are the same we can perceive something different, call it the same, and never be confused; all the while 'seeing' a completely different colour to one another.
- moron4hire 10y agoMeaningless distinction
- OJFord 10y agoHow so? I'm colour-blind (a bit red-green, a bit other things) - that's a blurring of boundaries; so we absolutely will disagree on what a colour is (though oddly I can literally see colours change in front of me once I 'know'). Why is it so implausible that people may have the same boundaries, but with things swapped such that they experience a different 'colour', say what you see to be 'blue', every time that you say 'red'? They'll still call it 'red'. You'll agree every time you see it.
- SamBam 10y agoThe linguistic relativist's position (Sapir-Whorf hypothesis) is specifically that people with different color words perceive colors differently. It's mostly discredited now, but that's exactly the position being discussed in the article.
- tetromino_ 10y ago> It's mostly discredited now Unjustly so. There is experimental evidence that at least in for some languages and some colors, language affects the ability to distinguish colors. Here is one example: http://www.pnas.org/content/104/19/7780.short http://www.pnas.org/content/104/19/7780.short > English and Russian color terms divide the color spectrum differently. Unlike English, Russian makes an obligatory distinction between lighter blues (“goluboy”) and darker blues (“siniy”). We investigated whether this linguistic difference leads to differences in color discrimination. We tested English and Russian speakers in a speeded color discrimination task using blue stimuli that spanned the siniy/goluboy border. We found that Russian speakers were faster to discriminate two colors when they fell into different linguistic categories in Russian (one siniy and the other goluboy) than when they were from the same linguistic category (both siniy or both goluboy). Moreover, this category advantage was eliminated by a verbal, but not a spatial, dual task. These effects were stronger for difficult discriminations (i.e., when the colors were perceptually close) than for easy discriminations (i.e., when the colors were further apart). English speakers tested on the identical stimuli did not show a category advantage in any of the conditions. These results demonstrate that (i) categories in language affect performance on simple perceptual color tasks and (ii) the effect of language is online (and can be disrupted by verbal interference).
- int_19h 10y agoNot quite. The position being discussed in the article is a more nuanced revival, in that not having a distinct word doesn't prevent one from distinguishing the color, but having the word does affect behavior (speed of distinction, grouping of colors where it's called for, association of colors with other things etc).
- woliveirajr 10y agoBut the article states that even babies, who don't express those knowledge verbally, can have different reaction. In my experience, sample size=1, you don't talk that much with a baby about colors. The article doesn't explain details, and that made me wonder: is this genetic? Cultural? How does it goes when the parents have different cultures? Moving to another city/country changes that? Being in a nursery with caregivers of the same/different culture? Once I read a discussion about teaching your child colors, and how some take longer to differentiate colors from the object, so that color is an attribute and not _the_ object. That's where this caught my attention.
- coldtea 10y ago>* His field had long espoused a theory called linguistic relativity, which held that language shapes perception. Color was the “parade example,” Kay says. His professors and textbooks taught that people could only recognize a color as categorically distinct from others if they had a word for it. (...) The two languages are as unrelated to each other historically as any two languages can be,” Kay says. And yet they seemed to give rise to a common way of seeing and thinking about color. Either he and Berlin had stumbled upon a one-in-a-million coincidence. Or the relativists were wrong.* Or relativism is truer for less tangible things (like how we deal with societal and abstract notions based on our language) than about stuff we experience directly, like color.
- rubber_duck 10y agoSaying that you can only think about abstract things if you have words for them is tautological since abstractions build on language.
- coldtea 10y ago>Saying that you can only think about abstract things if you have words for them is tautological since abstractions build on language. The actual relativist core is not about "only being able to think X if you have words for it" (which is bogus imho), it's about the "language shapes perception" part. Besides, abstractions are not just built on/from language -- else they would be meaningless names. They are based on experiences -- which are not just experiences of actual tangible things but also of circumstances, common feelings, etc. Freedom for example, while an abstract notion, is painfully "tangible" as an experience when its taken away from you, whether you are Japanese or Irish, etc, so one would expect all cultures to form the relevant words to describe it (and that is the case). Thus one could think of freedom even without having access to the word -- just by having in his mind the relevant sensation (as a mental picture, etc). But even more so, a system of language (associated words and notions) also shapes how we approach freedom beyond the basic underlying sentiment.
- gmfawcett 10y agoAbstractions might benefit deeply from language, but I don't see a tautology here. I suspect that anyone who does a lot of abstract thinking (math, software design, visual arts, etc.) spends time engaging with abstractions that have no names or linguistic references, and which may never manifest in named constructs. It can be a relief to have such a "mental thing" become concrete enough to attract a name -- now we have more tools to manipulate it with, and we can communicate it more effectively -- but that doesn't always happen. And when it does, sometimes you have to discard some of the interesting parts in order to wedge the thing into a nameable compartment: it's not really the same abstraction any more. In software design, sometimes I know that I am working within a certain project-specific "space" in my head that informs the decisions I'm making. It has structure, influenced by the structure of the project and by my problem-solving approach; but there aren't any words in there, and I'd be hard pressed to give it a better name than "a mental model." And yet it's a palpable "thing," it's often unique to the specific project, and it is useful in getting the work done -- I definitely notice when I get distracted and lose track of it, and recognize it when it I find it again. I'm trying hard not to sound all fancy and mystical about this -- it's not magical stuff. It's just tricky to talk about kinds of abstractions that don't lend themselves well to being named. :)
- eukaryote 10y agoI was surprised in this article that "wine-dark" is still being bandied about as a translation for οἶνοψ πόντος. According to a scholar I spoke with many years ago, a more reasonable translation would be gleaming or shimmering. This would fit with another known use of οἶνοψ, referring to the back of an oxen in the sun.
- twoodfin 10y agoIt's hard for me to believe that "gleaming" or "shimmering" would be an objectively better translation. Even putting aside that it's a beautiful turn of phrase, Homer's audience would have been conscious of the simile suggested by the word choice, no?
- eukaryote 10y agoI do agree wine-dark is a beautiful turn of phrase, but from what I gather the literal translation is "wine-faced" or "wine-eyed". Have considerable experience of being "wine-eyed", I can assure you my eyes are generally gleaming. :-)
- DonaldFisk 10y agoLiddell and Scott translates as wine-coloured or wine-dark, when used as an epithet of the sea, or wine-red or deep red, when used to describe oxen. https://archive.org/stream/greekenglishlex00lidduoft#page/1034/mode/1up https://archive.org/stream/greekenglishlex00lidduoft#page/10...
- smogcutter 10y agoI recall "wine-dark" for oinodakruo, but it's been a while since school.
- ysavir 10y agoYeah, I don't know why scholars approach ancient texts as though figurative writing was not available to them, and that their words can be taken at face value, without a need for understanding a variety of applicable contexts.
- Thaxll 10y agoRed in French is "rouge" which is close enough :)
- antarrah 10y agoWhich doesn't necessarily mean the color red in French.
- VeejayRampay 10y agoI'm French and I have no idea what you mean by that.
- antarrah 10y agoIt's often used to refer to cosmetic for coloring the lips. https://www.google.ca/search?q=define+rouge+&oq=define+rouge https://www.google.ca/search?q=define+rouge+&oq=define+rouge http://www.dictionary.com/browse/rouge http://www.dictionary.com/browse/rouge
- VeejayRampay 10y agoNo one calls it "rouge" in France. It's always referred to as "rouge à lèvres" (lit. "red for lips").
- ardacinar 10y agofrench rouge and english red correspond to mostly the same shades of red, though. if you did a detailed study, you might find a slight difference but that's it.
- glup 10y agoIt's funny that the author points to the possibility of a synthesis, when one was just published within the last month by the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences: http://www.pnas.org/content/113/40/11178.abstract http://www.pnas.org/content/113/40/11178.abstract.
- shric 10y agoTo slightly throw a spanner in the works, the word for an egg yolk in Thai is "ไข่แดง" (kai daeng). ไข่ = egg, แดง = red. I've no idea why they use red here. This isn't a color disagreement. The Thai word for red is otherwise identical to the red English speakers know of, and there are other words for the actual colors of yolks (i.e. yellow or orange) and Thai chickens don't produce red yolks :(
- geomark 10y agoI'm not so sure. Thais call things แดง that don't look red to me. The egg yolks you mentioned are one of them. Brown dogs are another. People with dark complexion are another (if really dark they call them เขียง = green).
- Latty 10y agoIt may well be that in the past, there was no separate word for yellow or orange, they were just considered shades of red. So people used 'red'. Then later, people felt enough need to create more nuanced terms. In a similar way, if I remember correctly, Apple used to be the English word for all fruit[1]. We later added specific words for more fruits, and Apple only remains as the name of a single fruit - however, we still have 'Pineapples', which gained the name when apple was a generic fruit moniker. Apparently it's common for blue and green to be clumped together - green (midori) is a surprisingly recent term in Japanese, so lots of green things are referred to as blue (aoi) because of traditional usage - including the green light on traffic lights, apparently.[2] [1]: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/apple#Etymology https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/apple#Etymology [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue%E2%80%93green_distinction_in_language#Japanese https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue%E2%80%93green_distinction...
- mzs 10y agoPolish has two reds - czerwony and rudy - I mean in the sense that even a young Polish child would use the different words for different colors that a young English speaking American child would call both simply red.
- manwithaplan 10y agoI think Hungarian has the same distinction with piros versus vörös: https://www.academia.edu/7375817/The_Hungarian_color_terms_piros_and_vörös_A_corpus_and_cognitive_linguistic_investigation https://www.academia.edu/7375817/The_Hungarian_color_terms_p...
- biztos 10y agoIndeed, Piros and vörös are completely distinct, and nobody who speaks Hungarian would have any doubt what colors they indicate; and it's generally obvious when looking at a reddish color whether you're talking about piros (a brighter red, as in Red Riding Hood) or vörös (a darker red, as in Red Wine). For English speakers, in everyday usage both are just "red." English has more specific words for red but we don't use them much. This is a great example of why context-free machine translation is impossible. If you were to translate "red wine" as piros bor (instead of vörösbor) it would be ridiculous.
- deaddodo 10y agoBecause "crimson", "magenta", "scarlet", "pink", etc are all the same color? Red isn't a color, it's a spectrum. It encompasses a whole range of colors. You use it to describe a similar set of colors when specificity isn't required ("What was that red thing?" vs "I think it would look good in crimson"), like most things in English.
- mjlee 10y agoDid you read the article? The discussion is entirely about colour as a linguistic concept, not as a wavelength of reflected light. Until a few hundred years ago, pink things were simple "light red" things in English (and many other languages) - we didn't have the word pink and so couldn't express the colour without using relative terms.
- chx 10y agoThere's a fascinating book on this topic, that is Guy Deutscher: Through the Language Glass.
- int_19h 10y agoI'll second that. If anything in the article made you curious, absolutely get the book.
- crummy 10y agoRelated, here's a visualization that shows connotations from different cultures for colours: http://www.informationisbeautiful.net/visualizations/colours-in-cultures/ http://www.informationisbeautiful.net/visualizations/colours...
- Waterluvian 10y agoCool! Though I think a flat matrix would be far more readable. Can't really see if there are any trends on first glance.
- jedberg 10y agoThis title isn't a great title and the article doesn't explain the concept very well. What this is trying to say is that human languages all over the world come up with color names in a similar path, but they stop at different points. It's all very fascinating, and interestingly is the argument some use against strong AI -- that is they believe that to truly understand language you must have a human or human-like body that can perceive the world in the same way as a human, because these color words develop based on the physical properties of your eye and brain. For example, many people that are blind from birth have a hard time understanding the concept of color. A few of you mentioned that Russian has two words for red. Russian is actually at the end of the spectrum (pun intended) -- that is they have the maximum number of color words. English is close but we don't have separate words for blue and light blue. You can see this as English speaking children learn words -- they will call "pink" "red" until they learn pink, and will almost always learn "red" before "pink". Some cultures just stop with "warm" and "cold" (which are red orange yellow vs green blue purple). Ah the joys of being a CogSci major -- we had entire weeks of classes devoted to this.
- ryanx435 10y ago>English is close but we don't have separate words for blue and light blue. Azure. Celeste. Cerulean. Cyan. Teal. Turqouise. aqua. Aquamarine. Lapis.
- quicklyfrozen 10y agoNone of those are light blue :-)
- pavel_lishin 10y agoAs long as we're randomly talking about Russian colors, there's a color that I used to hear a fair amount in Russia that I don't know of an equivalent to here in the US: рыжый. Maybe it's not a common color term there, either - the most context I've heard it in was describing a dachshund's hair color[1], and the second most common is describing a redhead's hair. Maybe the English equivalent is "ginger", but I always thought of ginger as being a much lighter color. [1] http://www.allsmalldogbreeds.com/breeds/dachshund-smooth.jpg http://www.allsmalldogbreeds.com/breeds/dachshund-smooth.jpg <-- an example. Это рыжая такса.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- greenshackle2 10y agoAuburn?
- tetromino_ 10y agoI think it's hard to find an exact equivalent because Russian has a number of color words that are used mostly for one category of objects. For example, рыжий for human or animal hair, русый for human hair, карий and болотный for eyes, смуглый for skin, etc. So when translating, you might pick the English equivalent for describing that type of object (рыжие волосы = red hair), but it doesn't feel quite right, because that same English word would be perfectly OK for describing the color of all sorts of unrelated things (and might imply a different shade when applied to those unrelated things!), and the original Russian word wouldn't be.