3 ms·
So, I understand what the prosecution is trying to say. And what they are trying to say has merit, but not in a legal sense. Journalism without objectivity is
by kbenson 10y ago
So, I understand what the prosecution is trying to say. And what they are trying to say has merit, but not in a legal sense. Journalism without objectivity is not journalism. Presenting facts in a partial manner is not informative (which is a pillar of journalism), it's influential, which should at most be a byproduct of journalism. Does the person that purposefully leaves out relevant information from a story to influence people in the direction they want deserve the title journalist? I think not. (To be clear, I am speaking generally. I am not saying Amy Goodman falls into this category).
So, what does this have to do with Amy Goodman? Nothing. Except in the most egregious of cases, it's nigh impossible to tell whether a journalist was purposefully shaping the facts to their narrative, and to allow accusations and prosecutions over this may have such a chilling effect on what is a vital aspect of our democracy, that we should all stand against this.
So, in summary, support Amy Goodman in this, protect journalistic rights, but hold them to a high standard, as with those rights should come responsibility, as it should with all rights.
- mratzloff 10y agoThe prosecutor couldn't care less what the definition of journalism is or isn't, except insofar as it applies to winning the case. He is acting as an arm of the state government, trying to protect moneyed interests by using his prosecutorial power to punish Goodman and intimidate other reporters from getting clever ideas about covering the protests. To that end it's not even worth considering the argument he has presented; it's just a thin veneer of legality, a diversion, and not worth the paper it's printed on.
- kbenson 10y agoYes, I agree. I'm also saying that even if that wasn't the case, it's almost impossible correctly identify what is journalism and what isn't from a professed journalist and freedom of the press is protected under the first amendment, so the charges are ludicrous on those grounds alone. But because of that we, as the populace, should hold journalists to a high standard and call out what we see as misconduct, since the legal system is ill suited to do so. That's not to say this is a case of that, I'm just trying to make a general point about journalism, which I was spurred to do by the charges leveled (even if they are baseless in this case).
- logicallee 10y agoI read your comment very very carefully to see if we disagree about anything. You're saying the same thing as me, but I think others in this thread are misinterpreting. So, here is what you and I agree on, I think: we both think that Democracy Now is pushing an extremely strong agenda and is not objective journalism. Where you add "but not in a legal sense" -- we also agree. But the person I quoted was the prosecutor!! He can't say, you know, this woman just strikes me as being politically different, and I'd like to lock her up for it. That's not okay! Since he's the prosecutor, he can't just mix his political opinions willy-nilly in with throwing someone in prison for their writings. That's Stalinism. So while reading carefully, you and I on a personal level actually agree politically, where you lightly add "though not legally" this is actually a really really heavy distinction and you shouldn't be adding it lightly. You should be making a BIG deal about it. People can publish whatever even wrong or even biased crap they want with very few exceptions, and this is absolutely, 100% not one of these exceptions. You don't need a license to be a journalist. The license to write reports is based on "has America been overthrown and there's a Stalinist dictatorship", and if you Google that the answer is nope, hasn't happeened. She might as well be a licensed journalist, and isn't held to any standards because she can write whatever she wants. It's called America. if she committed a crime (which she didn't) it's not practicing journalism without a license or practicing biased journalism - which aren't crimes. That's the point. ------------ EDIT for your reply: this clarifies (thanks) but I don't see why you feel "journalism" is a legally protected status. (I don't know much about this.) What protections do journalists have that I don't if I write wherever I want? What obligations do they have that they can be criminally prosecuted for? (albeit in 'egregious' cases). you seem to imply both.
- kbenson 10y ago> we both think that Democracy Now is pushing an extremely strong agenda and is not objective journalism. Well, I don't specifically think that, as I have far too little information to make that judgement. I have very little exposure to Democracy Now (like a couple minutes of one episode, then the occassional snippet repeated elsewhere over the years) . What little exposure I have had had a feel of being a bit less objective than it could be, but I specifically was not trying to make my point dependent on that, as I think it's important and should stand on its own. It should make sense without Amy Goodman or Democracy Now taken into consideration at all. Journalism needs protection, some people profess to be journalists but aren't by any stretch, it's a slippery slope to go after them since we don't have an objective way to qualify journalism, nor a legal framework that I know of to make it workable without trampling rights. > where you lightly add "though not legally" .. I don't think that was lightly added. That was the point of the comment. Journalists are protected because they provide a vital service, and while it can be confusing and subjective as to whether someone thinks some piece of writing qualifies, the fact that it's so subjective and yet journalism in general is so important means we should not try prosecuting people for it in any except the most egregious cases (such as where the reporter is later on record saying they were purposefully misrepresenting the situation to cause a problem). Anything else is an erosion of our rights as a people, since journalism is for our benefit. I think you may have been looking at my comment as though I was someone agreeing or disagreeing with you specifically, and that may have colored your interpretation slightly. My intent was actually to make use of your pulpit to make what I thought was a related point, and wasn't specifically meant as a direct response to you. I mention this because I'm not entirely sure the point you are trying to convey in the last couple paragraphs, and how it relates.