4 ms·
While I agree that journalists should have protections, and think Amy Goodman should not be prosecuted, I have some issues with how this article is presented.
by kbenson 10y ago
While I agree that journalists should have protections, and think Amy Goodman should not be prosecuted, I have some issues with how this article is presented.
The scene was full of movement. Overhead, a helicopter hovered, circled, while back on the ground, protesters began to report burning eyes, and dogs—dogs lurching at protesters, dogs straining against their leashes, dogs with mouths open, mouths biting.
Is that what the protesters were reporting, that dogs were straining, dogs had their mouths open, that dogs were biting, or is this a bit or artistic license? If it's the former, it's just sloppy writing, as it's hard to parse. If it's the latter, it appears to be a blatant attempt to influence through emotion. This case is sound based on it's importance and the law, and there's no need to fictionalize an account in an informative piece, so I hope that's not what this was.
Thus far, the North Dakota authorities remain committed to their own embarrassment
It's not embarrassment if they think they should do it. They are committed to their course. Wording such as this implies they know they are wrong but are doing it anyway, as there's no reason to be embarrassed about doing what you perceive to be right.
I understand the author is a friend of Amy Goodman, and wants to help, but I prefer my journalism to at least attempt to preserve the facade of objectivity. Without that, my natural inclination is to recoil (and thus the impetus for this comment is explained). I doubt I'm the only one, and what's more, people naturally inclined to take the other side now have something to point at as an indication that this whole piece is not objective and should be discounted.
Edit: I wouldn't mind an actual reply from someone that disagreed enough to down vote. At least then I would have an idea of why what I said (or at least how it was interpreted) was in any way controversial.
- ZenoArrow 10y ago> "Is that what the protesters were reporting, that dogs were straining, dogs had their mouths open, that dogs were biting, or is this a bit or artistic license?" You don't have to take the protesters word for it, the footage is available on YouTube. I'll dig up a link for you to see it for yourself. EDIT: This video covers the protest, you can see the part where the dogs were used against the protesters: http://youtu.be/VADcWANqBp8 http://youtu.be/VADcWANqBp8
- kbenson 10y agoI'm not calling the protester's words into question, I'm asking whether he's attributing those words to the protesters, or those are his words. That's what I meant by "sloppy", as the wording makes it somewhat ambiguous when going by this article alone. IMO it's either sloppy, or overstepping the bounds of what I consider good journalism. I would prefer it be sloppy rather than the alternative, but as I say, it's hard to tell for me. That link would be appreciated.
- ZenoArrow 10y ago> "That link would be appreciated." Sure, no problem. http://youtu.be/VADcWANqBp8 http://youtu.be/VADcWANqBp8
- kbenson 10y agoThanks for the link. It actually provides a lot of context, and made me reexamine the passage in question. It's clear now that it's an accurate description of the scene in the video. I think I was thrown by what appeared to me to be a shift from a factual, matter-of-fact description of the video shifting to what seemed a more artistic expression of the events when it gets to the actions of the dogs. It's clear now that the portion about the dogs is an accurate, if stylish description of what the video showed. At this point, on reading it again after watching the video, I'm unclear whether my initial response was an odd interpretation on my part, or justified given the information at the time and presentation in the article. In any case, I think it's better to error on the side of caution and giving the benefit of a doubt, so I'll assume the problem was my interpretation, and retract my objection to how it was presented (it may still have been presented sloppily, but I'm not longer qualified to assess that). I do have some observations regarding the video though: 1) It's undoubtedly clear she was attempting to be a journalist based on the video presented. 2) I don't think it's necessarily good journalism, but it is journalism. I would have preferred if she got a statement from the other side regarding the event, or at least attempted it and mentioned whether she was unable to get someone to respond or they responded with no comment. 3) Unless there is evidence she incited people to action in some way, this looks to be a simple first amendment defense, and will be thrown out quickly. It also probably happens a lot with reporters and local governments. She's just a larger name so it gets more press. Doesn't make it any less important that those rights are upheld though.