3 ms·
You think the arrest will stand up to existing federal scrutiny? I sure don't. I wouldn't be real surprised if a ND state court tosses the charges.
by maxerickson 10y ago
You think the arrest will stand up to existing federal scrutiny? I sure don't.
I wouldn't be real surprised if a ND state court tosses the charges.
- seiferteric 10y agoBut will there be any consequences for those who made up these bogus charges against here?
- webmaven 10y agoTo some extent, it doesn't have to stand up, that isn't the point of the arrest and prosecution (or in a civil context, suing). The point is making news orgs spend scarce resources on legal defense, or more precisely for them to FEAR such expenses, and thereby self-censor (so, you rarely have to demonstrate your willingness to do so in order to cause a widespread chilling effect). Not to mention that while she's arrested or in court she conveniently can't cover the confrontation. The civil lawsuit version of this is called a Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation, or SLAPP. It is quite effective, especially in states that don't have anti-SLAPP legislation (and North Dakota doesn't). In any case, the criminal version is usually called malicious prosecution, and the bar is set rather high (you have to prove that the prosecution wasn't just unjustified by the evidence, but caused actual damages beyond the ordinary costs of the defense such as lost wages, and reputational damage doesn't count), not to mention that prosecutors (and judges) are usually specifically immune to lawsuits alleging malicious prosecution in the first place.
- maxerickson 10y agoThe media can write stories about the spurious prosecutions (to wit). It's going to be hard to gin up charges to suppress those stories. So I think the media is well positioned to deal with the problem, and I think the prospect of breaking a story is a lot more top of mind for reporters than the financial resources needed to fight potential prosecution.
- webmaven 10y ago> The media can write stories about the spurious prosecutions (to wit). They can, but generally don't. To wit: http://fair.org/home/charges-dropped-against-amy-goodman-no-thanks-to-corporate-media/ http://fair.org/home/charges-dropped-against-amy-goodman-no-... > I think the prospect of breaking a story is a lot more top of mind for reporters than the financial resources needed to fight potential prosecution. True as far as it goes, but publishers (and indirectly, editors etc.) have the opposite incentives except when the story is so sensational that if they don't cover it, some other news org will. And believe me, reporters definitely get the message through such means as assignments, promotions, raises, etc.
- maxerickson 10y agoThat didn't take long. A North Dakota judge today refused to authorize riot charges against award-winning journalist Amy Goodman for her reporting on an attack against Native American-led anti-pipeline protesters. http://www.democracynow.org/2016/10/17/breaking_riot_charges_against_amy_goodman http://www.democracynow.org/2016/10/17/breaking_riot_charges...