6 ms·
Why the Vast Majority of Women in India Will Never Own a Smartphone
- andrewvijay 10y agoDon't have a subscription to read it. Would be glad if anyone can summarize the article here.
- mikeash 10y agoThe "web" link worked for me, for what it's worth. The brief summary is that an extremely conservative culture gives men power, and causes husbands and fathers to forbid their wives and daughters from having smartphones.
- sbierwagen 10y agoWeb link didn't work for me
- mikeash 10y agoTry an incognito window. I hear that WSJ is setting cookies once you see their paywall and showing it every time after that regardless of referer.
- ptaipale 10y agoThis is it. Click the "web" link with incognito, the top link (likely) is the Google search result, follow that, then you can see the article. If you don't use incognito and visit WSJ first and hit the paywall, your browser will have cookies that the site will see and block you even if you arrive via the Google link.
- realo 10y agoOne of the sentences at the beginning: ==== “They start talking and the next thing you will have a love marriage or she will run away with a boy,” said Mr. Balbi. ==== Oh the horror! A love marriage? No no no... we cannot have that here... And then the last 2 sentence of the article say it all, really: ==== Lakhan Singh Arya said it was a father’s duty to protect his daughter because someday she would marry into another family. “A daughter is someone else’s asset,” he said. “They must be more cautious, and we have to go an extra mile to protect her honor.” ==== I have trouble imagining a human being as an "asset"... but maybe it's just me.
- Ericson2314 10y agoThe key to understanding many traditional cultures around the world is that men are valued as agents, but not assets, and women are valued as assets, but not agents.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- zubat 10y agoAgent/asset also explains related attitudes including homophobia(blurring lines between agent and asset), culturally accepted abuse(instrumental to asset control), and honor culture(no room for expression outside the agent hierarchy).
- Ericson2314 10y agoYes, I beleive too often abuse is described in the language of violence, which either ubjustly narrows the definition abuse or expands the definition of violence in ways that illicit confusion or resistance.
- hackuser 10y agoInteresting. Is this a well-known theory? I'd be interested in reading more about it.
- Ericson2314 10y agoTo my knowledge it has not been elsewhere summarized as such. This is my personal synthesis of what I've read.
- hackuser 10y agoThanks; very insightful. I understand the other three cases, but how are males not assets? Also, I believe females are often seen as being the liability side of the balance sheet (which is perhaps what you meant). You have to pay another family (pay a dowry) in order for them to take on the woman. (In case there is any doubt, I strongly believe that every woman is a person who should decide for herself who she wants to be.)
- cpncrunch 10y agoJust do a google search for the title, and you should be able to read the full article for free.
- spaceandshit 10y agoWhy does this work?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cb18 10y agoBecause the WSJ wants Google to index their articles, but Google will penalize sites that show different content to a regular user vs a crawler. Or something like that.
- WalterSear 10y agoThe WSJ journal wants to charge people for access, but it doesn't want to lose prominence in google and the traffic that that provides. However, google isn't going to index information that isn't available to searchers, so they have to leave things entirely open.
- ddinh 10y agoNon-paywall link: http://www.business-standard.com/article/beyond-business/why-the-vast-majority-of-women-in-india-will-never-own-a-smartphone-116101401144_1.html http://www.business-standard.com/article/beyond-business/why... (The site will try to prevent you from reading the article if you have an adblocker, but you can bypass it by blocking all scripts.)
- r00fus 10y agoHaving a smartphone is not a right, but the article does highlight a bunch of stuff that we in the Occident take for granted in terms of equality of rights: "In parts of rural India, village councils, which effectively dictate community norms, have issued decrees barring unmarried women from possessing cellphones" "In India, millions use smartphones to find jobs, bank, study, order train tickets, interact with the government and more. Offline options require freedom of movement not available for many women, and extra time and cost in traveling, standing in lines and filling out forms" It would be unthinkable for modern western countries to segregate as described in the article.
- M_Grey 10y agoYeah, we're all about the more subtle behaviors, such as not bothering to study female animal models for a majority of pharmaceuticals over decades, or fighting various aspects of reproductive rights.
- rabboRubble 10y agoWhen a country is missing about 60,000,000 women [0], weird stuff comes about to control the ones that remain. http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/2013/07/201372814110570679.html http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/2013/07/20137281411...
- cbanek 10y agoOn the other hand, look at the dating "markets" in China, which stemmed from the one child policy. It's certainly interesting to see how different countries handle the same problem (more men than women). In China women have gotten a lot more "negotiating power" in that women can be choosier and pick from the men with the most money/car/house.
- rabboRubble 10y agoTrue. One other result is that Chinese men have gone bride shopping throughout Asia, pushing their sex ration imbalance into other countries.
- emodendroket 10y agohttp://www.lrb.co.uk/v38/n10/sheng-yun/little-emperors http://www.lrb.co.uk/v38/n10/sheng-yun/little-emperors This piece, which I found interesting, argued that the One Child Policy actually had a sort of "feminist" effect and was not exactly to blame for the gender imbalance: > Besides, there were benign aspects of the one-child policy, especially for girls. Traditionally females were used as domestic help, birth machines or clan assets to marry off or trade. Women didn’t go to school, and were encouraged to internalise the saying that ‘a woman without talent is virtuous.’ Illiteracy was their proper condition: they were there to clean, farm, and above all to give birth to a male heir. They could not dine with men at the same table. Even today in many rural areas, all the family resources are invested in the male heir. The one-child policy forced people to review many of their assumptions, and at least try to treat girls as they would boys: parents, after all, were not able to choose their child’s sex, and had to come to terms with whichever they got. The policy also ended the nonsense that having a girl put paid to the family line. I have only one male cousin on my father’s side (regarded as the precious ‘trickle’ of the family bloodline), but when he had a girl, our family promptly abandoned their absurd talk about the male line. Cheers. > Western scholars and human rights activists are inclined to blame the one-child policy for forced abortions, female infanticide, the under-reporting of female births and so on. These issues were deadly serious but they resulted less from the policy than from the nature of Chinese patriarchy, which the policy threw into sharp relief. People were willing to break the law, to pay a fine to have a second go at having a boy, even to murder or abandon female babies. Paradoxically the one-child policy undermined the atavism of tradition, even while seeming to encourage it. I grew up in Hefei, about 500 km west of Shanghai, where I remember a striking young girl from the countryside who attended a private violin class; she was the daughter of peasant parents who spoke poor Mandarin. Without the one-child policy, her father would have tried fanatically to conceive a second, third, fourth child, until the family produced a male heir. His daughters would have led miserable lives. Instead, he invested in his only child’s violin lessons.
- Avshalom 10y ago'Never' is fucking long time.
- skybrian 10y agoThat depends on your point of view. Is a human lifetime long or short?
- plorkyeran 10y agoIt may be that in ten years no one owns something called a "smartphone". "Never" here merely requires that technological advancement outpace social.