10 ms·
If builds were reproducible (i.e. binaries would be identical if recompiled with the same toolchain on a different machine), then all it would take is N indepen
by frutiger 10y ago
If builds were reproducible (i.e. binaries would be identical if recompiled with the same toolchain on a different machine), then all it would take is N independent builders to verify the app store binary matches their locally built binary to greatly decrease the likelihood of tampering.
So, while being open source is not the complete answer, it certainly doesn't hurt.
- ChoHag 10y agoOr we could have build systems that weren't even more convoluted and fragile than they were 50 years ago and just release software in the form it's supposed to be in.
- tptacek 10y agoI don't think it hurts! All else being equal, I'd rather have source than not have it. What I don't accept is our supposed helplessness in detecting backdoors in secure messaging software.
- tedunangst 10y agoHow do you guarantee the App Store doesn't serve limited edition binaries to selected recipients?
- nmgsd 10y agoThe App Store run by a central authority with complete control over what can even be available and the ability to modify the delivery at their own whim is certainly a big issue in terms of trusting the integrity of the apps running on a device.
- Canada 10y agoForget the aop store. How do we know Google, Apple, Microsoft, Ubuntu, etc doesn't give us a malicious kernel update? I don't think we have good solutions for the problem of malicious updates in general. The only one I can think of is a trusted hypervisor that hashes memory in the guest and reports on it. And even then, how do we trust that?
- angry_octet 10y agoForget the software, the firmware running on the baseband processor can read system memory and send it over the network without you knowing. But that takes lots of effort to target a specific person. So what do you do? It comes back to making sure that 'they' can only hack some of the people all the time, and all of the people some of the time. It's preventing them hacking all the people all the time I worry about.
- verbify 10y agoIf you suspect yourself to be a selected recipient (e.g. you're Edward Snowden) I reckon you should compile your own binaries. Or read 'Reflections on Trusting Trust'.
- conradev 10y agoFun fact: The App Store already serves limited edition binaries to everyone because it encrypts them per-account :)