5 ms·
You'd think banks paid no tax. When banks profit, society gets its share of those profits. Taxes, spending by the organization, spending by employees, their ta
by gaius 17y ago
You'd think banks paid no tax.
When banks profit, society gets its share of those profits. Taxes, spending by the organization, spending by employees, their taxes. The government bailed out Detroit, why's this any different?
- grandalf 17y agoNot sure why you inferred that anyone above supported the auto company bailouts (or the airline bailouts, etc.). Taxes are not paid in exchange for bailouts... at least if they are tell that to all the other companies that have failed over the years and not had the government swoop in to help.
- gaius 17y agoThat's true, but the assertion that that there's no contribution to the economy and society from bank profits is a false one.
- Psyonic 17y agoI don't disagree with that, but simply asserting they pay taxes doesn't prove anything. If they more or less stole the money, paying back 20% is hardly contributing. Not saying they did, the verdict is still out there, but just pointing out that taxes alone don't say much.
- metamemetics 17y agoThere really isn't that big of one. A bank is an entity that uses an unsustainable business plan, fractional reserve banking, and has to rely on a federal subsidy (FDIC insurance) to make it work. They are getting a subsidy to mindlessly arbitrage the yield curve and profit by making riskier loans than they would normally be capable of making. Fractional Reserve lending is NOT necessary for a financial intermediary to function. Look at hedge funds or VC firms. They are investing the amount of money they have received from investors and are not allowed to invest 10X they amount they have without raising that extra amount from somewhere. Banks are not doing anything intelligent that adds significant value, the majority of their profits come from mindlessly arbitraging the yield curve due to a federal subsidy.
- CWuestefeld 17y agoThe broken window strikes again.
- dpapathanasiou 17y agoI do not disagree with your tax argument in theory, and I'm all for capitalism and free enterprise. If i-banks like GS want to pay large salaries and bonuses to their employees, that is fine by me, as long as they also accept the negative consequences of the risks they take. I'm also not a fan of the automobile bailouts; to paraphrase Plato, two bailouts do not make a right.
- stretchwithme 17y agoThe government should have allowed the weakest auto company to fail. Instead it pumped in many times its total worth to prop it up. How does that make sense? Coercing the rest of us to take on debt so they can continue an enterprise that doesn't make economic sense? You're absolutely right when you say there's no difference between subsidizing banks and auto companies. Both actions were wrong.
- hristov 17y ago"The government bailed out Detroit, why's this any different?" Here are some differences: - The bank bailouts are turning out to be at least a 100 times as expensive as the Detroit bailout. Detroit is not even worth mentioning in the same breadth as the banks. - In the detroit bailout, most people that were responsible for the failure did not benefit. CEOs were sacked, all equity holders lost their money, debt holders lost most of their money too. In the bank case most people responsible kept their jobs and many of them are now back to getting multi million dollar bonuses (supported by government loans). Some banks wiped out their equity holders, some banks had only temporary drops in stock price. But pretty much all of the bank debt was guaranteed by the government.
- ericd 17y agoCan you and others please stop implying that people are getting paid bonuses directly out of taxpayer money/loans? It's completely false.
- hristov 17y agoThey are getting bonuses because of the loans. The issue whether they are getting the money directly out of the loans or not is impossible to decide because once the bank gets the money it treats it like any other money. But if the loans did not exist, many of these people would not be getting these bonuses either because their employers would not exist either, or because their employers would not have sufficient capital to generate the profits from which the bonuses come.
- ericd 17y agoNo, it's not impossible, they've paid back the loans, so it's not coming out of that money, period. Goldman in particular: a) didn't want the money, they were forced to take it b) paid it back as soon as they were allowed So yes, they would have gotten those bonuses regardless, and no, you can't say they would have failed without it.
- 17y ago