5 ms·
Whenever I get onto the subject of how robots are taking jobs away from people, my usual simple argument (when the conversation is only going to be a minute lon
by Waterluvian 10y ago
Whenever I get onto the subject of how robots are taking jobs away from people, my usual simple argument (when the conversation is only going to be a minute long) is that refrigeration took many jobs away, such as ice and milk delivery people.
But I wish I could find a more significant example of some industry that was huge and is now entirely gone due to modernization.
- rwmj 10y agoDock workers (almost entirely replaced by containerization).
- mixedCase 10y agoOps guys (almost entirely replaced by containerization). (I kid, I kid)
- 3pt14159 10y agoWell cloth / clothing manufacturing is probably the largest decrease I can think of. From the cotton pickers, to the spinsters, to the weavers, and tailors. Much of it has been mechanized. The difference with robots though is that they can actually 100% out perform humans in the not to distant future. Once a robot has hands as agile and controllable as ours, and once they have energy requirements that are cheaper than ours, I don't see how humans could compete with them in non-cerebral jobs. And there is a good segment of the population that can only do physical work.
- Waterluvian 10y agoI would intuit that the proportion of labourers to the rest has been decreasing throughout human history. I think what has me most curious is how low can it go. Is it possible to have near 0% labourers?
- lisper 10y agoFarmers. In 1850, >70% of people in the U.S. were farmers. Today <2% are. (Source: http://www.nytimes.com/1988/07/20/us/farm-population-lowest-since-1850-s.html http://www.nytimes.com/1988/07/20/us/farm-population-lowest-...)
- Waterluvian 10y agoWow, yeah that's a pretty compelling example. Thanks.
- ekianjo 10y agoYet we don't have 70% unemployment.
- lisper 10y agoThat's true, but that should not lull us into complacency. Some day we may run out of productive things for unskilled human labor to do, the same way we ran out of things for horses to do (http://www.cgpgrey.com/blog/humans-need-not-apply http://www.cgpgrey.com/blog/humans-need-not-apply). Not everyone can be a software engineer, and even if they could, we probably wouldn't need 7 billion of them.
- ekianjo 10y agoYes, but that also means humans are usually more resourceful than what we can imagine in the first place. Look back also in the early 1900s where all major newspapers were proclaiming the end of world and massive famine if we ever reached 1 billion people on Earth, and look where we are now: virtually no famines anywhere (except in war zones and in the worst dictatorships, which is now a minority) and the population is still growing and poverty is decreasing progressively. This would have been unimaginable 100 years ago. So, let's not fool ourselves with predictions. We are notoriously bad a predicting long term trends. PS: the analogy with horse is wrong in so many ways (because horses are not humans and cannot adapt like humans) but this would be another topic altogether.
- 10y ago
- yoodenvranx 10y agoSome things come to my mind: - wooden barrels / casks for wine beer - coppersmith (not sure about the exact term. i mean people who create pans and pots by hand) - basketmaker - coachbuilder
- taneq 10y agoA lot of old professions are still reflected in surnames. A barrel-maker is a Cooper. Coachbuilder would have been Wainwright.
- Godel_unicode 10y agoWooden barrels for wine are still very much in use, and still largely made by hand. Source: I've been to a lot of wineries and talked with a lot of people who make barrels.
- danellis 10y agoI'm not sure you can blame refrigeration on the absence of milk delivery people. In England, we had milkmen/milkmaids well into the late 1990s, despite refrigeration. Electric milk floats (sometimes carrying orange juice and bread, too) were a common early morning sight and sound.
- bostik 10y agoIt's 2016 - and still do. We live in a region with an operating milkman. The price per pint is roughly 2x what it'd cost in a store, but the milk is fresh, organic, delivered to our door - and very importantly for us - generates very little waste. The empty glass bottles go back with the milkfloat, so we use far less plastic cartons.
- krallja 10y agoYou might also be able to buy glass bottles of milk at the grocery store when you're buying other groceries already, which would save the milkman the extra trip. You'll get your deposit back on the next grocery trip.
- icebraining 10y agoIs it really less wasteful? Cartons seem to be easily recyclable using an hydrapulper, while the milkman distribution requires an extra truck trip, wasting a lot of gas compared to just carrying a couple of milk packages along with the rest of the groceries.