2 ms·
Is Fiskes article related to the replication crisis? Remember that whole cultural appropriation thing last year? Or the safe space movements on campus? There a
by wodenokoto 10y ago
Is Fiskes article related to the replication crisis?
Remember that whole cultural appropriation thing last year? Or the safe space movements on campus? There are plenty of movements that abuse political correctness to bully anyone around. On the opposite side there are plenty of 4chan types who love to shamelessly bully anyone who dare come out with a feministic message.
I imagine academics in related fields are ripe for being targeted by Internet bullies and trolls.
Isn't it this kind of abuse that Fiske is referring to?
- leephillips 10y agoI don't think she's talking about personal abuse. Some people just get upset when mistakes are pointed out in public. There is a crisis in social psychology: its status as a science is crumbling. Naturally, feelings are raw; many careers are precarious.
- caseysoftware 10y agoIt seems they're "precarious" because massive amounts of research is "fraudulent" or at minimum plagued with errors. If my code was in a similar state, I would consider my career "precarious" or "at risk" too.
- leephillips 10y agoIndeed. It seems likely that there are prominent people in these fields, with decades of research and publishing behind them, almost all of it based on bad statistical methods. Naturally, there is a certain amount of panic.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- conistonwater 10y agoThis is literally nothing to do with any of the things that you mention. Why do you think it is? Indeed, it has been discussed many times in different contexts on Gelman's blog and here on HN too, so you can just read this and the previous discussions to see that it's specifically about research and statistics methodology in psychology. The blog post itself contains plenty of links itself that you can read to find out what it's about.
- wodenokoto 10y agoIf you read Fiskes article that the link is a reply to, it also has absolutely nothing to do with p-hacking or the replication crisis.