4 ms·
Not sure who this guy is but he seems to have completely missed the point about what Fiske was saying. Sure the internet has heralded a new paradigm but that do
by threeseed 10y ago
Not sure who this guy is but he seems to have completely missed the point about what Fiske was saying. Sure the internet has heralded a new paradigm but that doesn't mean that we have to just accept the negatives. And the negatives with the internet are just as severe as the positives.
Go spend time on any politics forum for example and it is downright scary. Conspiracies run rampant and are unchecked, experts are personally vilified and viciously attacked and facts come second to feelings and opinions. And all evidence to date suggests that this is not helping society but actually making it more polarised and less cohesive.
And exactly the same thing has happened in other fields e.g. climate change. Legitimate criticism is always useful and welcomed but it needs to be constructive.
- ewr24 10y ago> facts come second to feelings and opinions I think Fiske is arguing exactly for this point. Feelings are more important than data. > this is not helping society but actually making it more polarised and less cohesive. Do you think stuff like "ambivalent sexism theory" is making society more cohesive?
- lifty 10y agoI think Fiske met that constructive criticism with negative hyperbole and vague counter arguments that were not on point. People protect their vested interests and status quo by praying on people's decency and politeness, but ignore the fundamental facts in the criticism brought against them, and that leads to a proportional negative reaction from the other side. This situation reminds me of the Eastern European political systems where failure to recognise and deal with basic problems like fairness, corruption, nepotism, etc leads to a progressive degradation of trust that in turn leads to more violent/drastic changes, with total disregard for decency. So, if you want to be treated decently, than you'd better act decently as well, and not only superficially.
- mafribe 10y agoreminds me of the Eastern European That's interesting, but maybe not so surprising, because the techniques that people like Fiske use stem (at least in parts) from the communist tradition of undermining and taking over institutions (e.g. Trotsky's entryism).
- venomsnake 10y ago(e.g. Trotsky's entryism) - known in modern times as diversity advocates. Let me in your group. Then change your group culture to suit me instead of me blending in.
- _delirium 10y agoTrotsky's entryism was pretty specific, I don't think particularly related to your beefs. His argument was that forming small far-left workers' parties didn't make sense if there already existed large mass workers' parties, and instead communists should work within those, even if they were more moderate than you'd like, rather than forming new parties, which would be ideologically pure but not contain the actual masses of the working class who would have to form the basis of any workers' government. In most Western European countries, the majority of the working class supported various kinds of Labour and Social Democratic parties, so that's what he advocated joining.
- skybrian 10y agoI think the idea isn't to listen to everyone on the Internet but to take seriously the conversations scientists have on their blogs and social media accounts.
- Noseshine 10y agoYour comment seems to me to go off into a completely different direction, one far away from saying anything concrete about actual research and going towards a very fuzzy general direction. This is completely different from the article, which has a lot of very concrete points about a concrete subject. I see a big mismatch between the article you criticize and how you do it. "Strawman" comes to mind too, most of your comment is about things that you yourself introduce into the debate.
- scandox 10y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Gelman https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Gelman He is not some random commentator. Sadly, experts are being vilified because the perception of their accuracy has been damaged and expectations about the certainty of results have been poorly managed. Blind respect got us where we are. Now we have to find a different way.
- bobcostas55 10y agoWhen <50% of results in a particular field can be replicated, should you trust the experts of that field?