3 ms·
> Why are we trying to move towards more diversity? Why is that inherently a good thing? For the same reason why genetic bottlenecks are a bad thing.
by yellowapple 10y ago
> Why are we trying to move towards more diversity? Why is that inherently a good thing?
For the same reason why genetic bottlenecks are a bad thing.
- jimmywanger 10y ago> For the same reason why genetic bottlenecks are a bad thing. That is a false analogy. They're segregating based on race and gender, not class or socioeconomic status. Does it really matter what color your skin is, if you have a MBA from MIT? How does that improve the cultural bottleneck?
- yellowapple 10y ago"They're segregating based on race and gender, not class or socioeconomic status" Socioeconomic factors are the more ideal consideration on paper, but in practice it doesn't matter, since that status tends to be influenced very heavily by racial/ethnic factors. Hopefully this'll change someday and we'll all live in a Star Trek utopia. Today is by absolutely no means that day. "Does it really matter what color your skin is, if you have a MBA from MIT? How does that improve the cultural bottleneck?" Wait, so just happening to have a degree from a prestigious college suddenly makes someone immune to the effects of racism? What a wonderful thought.
- pitaj 10y agoBut this is forced diversity on the demand end, instead of genuine diversity on the supply end. I agree that diversity is a good thing, but hear me out. What if women are generally genetically predisposed to disliking computer science? I'm not saying they are, but just take it as a given for a moment. Would attempting to increase the diversity in certain places be a good thing to do then? I think it would probably be harmful. It's unfortunate that we may never know why there are so few women in CS and similar fields. When I saw the 31% stat for women in Silicon Valley, I was surprised, as that seems much higher than I though the general rates were. Maybe that includes managers and stuff? Believe me, I'd love to see more diversity, but I think forcing it could be dangerous.
- yellowapple 10y ago"Would attempting to increase the diversity in certain places be a good thing to do then?" If I'm genetically predisposed to not want to eat my vegetables, does that mean I shouldn't be encouraged to eat my vegetables? Does that also mean that a group of people who are genetically predisposed to want to eat their vegetables shouldn't encourage me to try gardening and possibly even join their vegetable cooking club? Should they not themselves be encouraged to invite me to said vegetable cooking club simply because I'm genetically predisposed to having a tendency to decline such a proposition? "Maybe that includes managers and stuff?" More likely customer support, clerical, sales, and other such supporting roles, but yes. That figure is almost certainly not limited strictly or even loosely to technical positions.
- RandomOpinion 10y ago>If I'm genetically predisposed to not want to eat my vegetables, does that mean I shouldn't be encouraged to eat my vegetables? C. S. Lewis said it better than I possibly ever could: "Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive. It would be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron's cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated; but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience." Even as a liberal, I find the "It's for their own good" argument frequently advanced by modern authoritarian liberals to be insufferably arrogant. We're all adults here and we deserve the opportunity to chart our own course in life, whether for good or for ill.
- yellowapple 10y agoI'm by no means trying to imply that such a thing should be forced. On the contrary: it should be encouraged, sure, but the decision to embrace diversity must be a voluntary one. No tyranny wanted or needed here; the benefits of avoiding the stagnation of a monoculture should be apparent enough.
- jimmywanger 10y ago
- throwow3439 10y ago> For the same reason why genetic bottlenecks are a bad thing. What is that "genetic bottleneck" ? it's a pretty racist expression if you ask me , it sounds like it leads to "degeneration" or something like that, it really sounds like nazi rhetoric but reversed, instead of the "purity of the race" that must be preserved, it is now mandatory to diversify "white people's genes" to avoid genetic defects ? You take a Slovenian and an Irish, they are both "white" , does that constitute a "genetic bottleneck" because of a superficial trait ( color of the skin ) ? I mean only racialists speak about genetics when it comes to race. Just because now a specific racial narrative is pushed by the left doesn't make racialism less obnoxious. And white women despite being women are still white , does it also constitute a "genetic bottleneck" too ? people pushing for all that should take a step back and think about what they say, for a second. "Diversity" AKA affirmative action AKA "positive discrimination" isn't inherently good or bad, from a productivity or a financial perspective for businesses that engage into all these diversity policies. If they see value in it, good for them, now let's see if they perform better on the long run just because they replaced a good white candidate with an average non white one. I'm not american, but I'm puzzled by all this which mostly looks like feelgood PR, seen from abroad, especially at a time US finds more and more difficult to hide its racial tensions to the rest of the world.
- yellowapple 10y agoThe point wasn't to take genetics literally. The point was that - much like how a homogeneous genetic population will tend to amplify its defects compared to a heterogeneous one - so will a homogeneous ideological population. The diversity is what brings in new ideas and viewpoints. The very idea of the American "melting pot" is rooted in this philosophy; immigrants both adapt to existing customs and introduce new ones, thus making the America as a whole (lots of us Americans seem to forget this, including at least one of our presidential candidates, but such is life). This can be and has been applied on smaller scales to various organizations with much success. This isn't only about race or only about gender or only about sexual orientation or only about political affiliation or only about socioeconomic class; it's about all of these things influencing an individual's background in a way that is different from the group as a whole.
- BigJeffeRonaldo 10y agoGreat, I'll tell my Peul friend that he's a genetic bottleneck for wanting to marry a Peul girl