3 ms·
$50M is peanuts for this scale of a project and the engineering that will need to be done. Seems like this is likely only enough to get to a small scale POC. I
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
$50M is peanuts for this scale of a project and the engineering that will need to be done. Seems like this is likely only enough to get to a small scale POC.
I think it's a great start, but it's still super early to know if this can even work.
- netule 10y agoHonestly, I'm just glad that the project isn't dead after the recent kerfuffle. Hiring decent people may be a good way to get back on track and attract more investors.
- danbruc 10y ago50 million Dollars will buy you at least 200 man-year of clever people thinking about it, that should be more than enough to realize that this is not an (economically) viable endeavor and render building a prototype mood.
- zootam 10y agobut it will also buy at least 50 'man-year' of clever people thinking about marketing it and how to continue to profit off of it regardless if it is feasible or not
- nihonde 10y agoI'm all for chasing ambitious goals, but America should probably demonstrate some modest capabilities in building and running high speed passenger trains before it disrupts that game. While Americans (and Dubai) chase this hyperloop boondoggle, Japan is rolling out 300kph+ trains from stern (Kyushu) to tip (Hokkaido) in the most inhospitable and earthquake-prone region in the world, with insane population densities in some places, across relatively vast waterways, and with almost zero delays in operating timetables.
- pitaj 10y agoShould America also have upgraded the mail system before telegraph lines were deployed? Should America have also made faster trains before building the interstate system? Innovation and disruption are better than just incremental improvements to make some existing technology fit your bill.
- babyrainbow 10y ago>Should America also have upgraded the mail system before telegraph lines were deployed? It is a bit different, you know. Investing in proven tech vs investing in vapourware..
- nihonde 10y agoAre you really arguing that 300km per hour trains that run on time and safely are equivalent to "telegraphs" while American passenger trains routinely fail to follow any schedule at all and have a bad habit of killing people? Not to mention that they don't serve large swaths of the country, including areas that need them most.