4 ms·
I'm strongly opposed. The electoral college is designed to protect the country from manifestly unqualified presidents. Furthermore, the electoral college is a
by macintux 10y ago
I'm strongly opposed.
The electoral college is designed to protect the country from manifestly unqualified presidents.
Furthermore, the electoral college is all that stands between us and Florida 2000 on a national scale. Recounting one state was painful enough. Recounting all 50? Nightmare.
- lisper 10y agoIt's arguable whether the electoral college works as intended. But it would still exist under NPV, so whatever protections it provides us now, it would continue to provide, so this is not reasonable grounds for opposing the NPV proposal.
- tunesmith 10y agoA nationwide recount (or multiple statewide recounts) is bigger and more complicated than a single statewide recount. How is that not reasonable grounds for opposing NPV? It is worth considering that if the size of the House had been permitted to grow as originally intended, then the difference between the NPV and the EC basically disappears. For instance, I believe that Gore would have won in 2000 had the House been double or triple in size (I forget exactly where, but somewhere around there). So that's a point in favor of the popular vote.
- mikeash 10y agoGrowing the House might have solved 2000 but it doesn't solve the overall problem, which is that a few states are hugely elevated in importance because they're the only ones that might realistically go either way. Swinging 5% of voters in Ohio is vastly more valuable than swinging 5% of voters in California, even though California has 3x more people. A larger House wouldn't change that.
- lisper 10y agoIt's actually a theorem that it is not possible to devise an apportionment scheme that does not have perverse outcomes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apportionment_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apportionment_paradox http://study.com/academy/lesson/balanski-youngs-impossibility-theorem-political-apportionment.html http://study.com/academy/lesson/balanski-youngs-impossibilit...
- mikeash 10y agoOther countries, even large ones, manage to do OK with recounts. I will note that the Florida recount wouldn't have had to happen at all in 2000 with NPV, since the national vote was clear, only Florida's was iffy. And how does it protect the country from unqualified presidents? It may have been meant to do that, but at this point it's just a weird way to tally votes. There's no realistic chance these days that the outcome could be changed by electors voting differently from how they're supposed to. All it accomplishes now is give a handful of states hugely exaggerated importance in the election relative to the rest by making it so that they effectively determine the outcome regardless of the popular vote total.
- GunboatDiplomat 10y ago>The electoral college is designed to protect the country from manifestly unqualified presidents. Well, it doesn't do that in practice. The electoral college which goes against the will of the voters will quickly become the last electoral college. As it's politically untenable for the electoral college to do anything but heed the will of the voters, it's vestigial. All it does is get in the way of a democratic election.
- v64 10y ago> All it does is get in the way of a democratic election. The Electoral College system enables smaller states to have a fairer influence on the election. If the election were a straight popular vote, the candidates would consolidate their campaigning to only major population centers, leaving a large portion of the country behind.
- lisper 10y agoThey might leave a large portion of the geography of the country behind, but they wouldn't leave a large portion of the people behind, which is what happens now. I live in California, and presidential candidates hardly ever campaign here despite the fact that we are one of the largest states in both size and population.
- _kst_ 10y agoDepends on what you mean by "goes against the will of the voters". There have been close elections where one candidate won the popular vote and the other won the electoral vote. That hasn't led to the electoral college being abolished. If you're talking about faithless electors, they have so far never affected the outcome of an election. If they did, I'm sure the calls for reform would become even louder than they are now. If the electors were intended to be able to exercise their own judgement, it hasn't really worked that way in practice. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faithless_elector https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faithless_elector
- macintux 10y agoI found a discussion of the topic in the Federalist papers this year because it seemed it might be relevant. Don't have the citation handy but they were absolutely intended to exercise their own judgment in the event of a patently unqualified candidate.
- macintux 10y agoThe other problem with a national vote: you think the money in politics is bad now, wait until the presidential candidates have to blanket the airwaves in every state.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]