7 ms·
Universities have turned over hundreds of patents to patent trolls
- yladiz 10y agoIt makes me sad that my alma mater is listed as one of the top 10. If you're like me and see that, forward this article to the provost of your school or the dean of your college and let them know you're not OK with this as an alumni. Of course there's no "take backsies" but at least we can try to do something to stop the spread of patents to patent trolls.
- URSpider94 10y agoI would like to know more. My experience with university license teams has been that they rarely sell patents to anyone -- for the most part, they provide a license. In the deals I've been involved with, the license specifically requires that the licensee be practicing the patent within some period, or the license is canceled. I'm curious if these represent cases where the universities sold patents to practicing entities, and then they got shuffled over to trolls in liquidation sales or re-orgs?
- devilsavocado 10y agoThe fact that you can just sell patents always seemed a little bit off to me. Does that really further the purpose of a patent? I understand that we can't just ban the selling of patents, but there must be a better way to avoid situations like these where the patent is not used to reward the innovator.
- the_watcher 10y agoThe answer, to me, is to focus on eliminating patent trolls. I haven't thought this one through much, but something like requiring a minimum percentage of revenue to come from non-patent related activity might be a good start.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoI was thinking the patent owner must be building, maintaining, and/or selling a product it covers with at least the amount of labor and updates as average competing product or IT project. Originally the benchmark was vs fastest-developing competitor to incentivize Shenzhen-like innovation with some patent protection for incentives. I thought quality might tank further, though, so leaned toward average.
- compsciphd 10y agoThe problem with this is, I can invent something, describe in detail how to build it, but have no ability to build it myself as a product. For example, imagine I invented a better type of flip-flop circuit. Its only useful to people building microprocessors, but under your logic I shouldn't get any benefit for creating a better way for them to build microprocessors because I don't build them myself.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoI don't any benefit for anything I do personally or commercially outside whatever people paid me initially. Why should you get a monopoly on an idea because you were lucky enough to think of it first? And in a country where monopolies are banned due to negative impact on society in about every other field? So I'm against the monopolies to begin with. Even if we accept patents, then you can be required to partner with a manufacturer within a certain period of time. This kind of thing might already exist if we compare it to the record labels for turning copywritten songs into fortunes for labels and authors. Similar middle-men would show up plus DIY kits, consultants, and advice on doing it yourself. The risks you face wouldn't be much different from the current market where trolls like Intellectual Ventures convince broke patent holders to give it to them for pennies using pressure of their bargaining power then make millions off them in law suits.
- Grishnakh 10y agoIf I were dictator, I'd definitely ban the selling of patents. I'd also ban the assigning of patents to corporations; they would only be owned by the original people who filed them. So corporations could only benefit from those patents as long as the patent-holders were employees (or at least one of the patent-holders if there's multiple), by being allowed to use the patent license-free. >I understand that we can't just ban the selling of patents Why not? We can ban anything we want as long as it's not unconstitutional. The question is if a ban of something has more negative effects than positive. I don't see how it would here.
- pitaj 10y agoJust get rid of patents in general then.
- rpenm 10y ago>The fact that you can just sell patents always seemed a little bit off to me. It is a long way from a patentable idea to a marketable product. So what happens when the patent originator lacks the competencies or capital to produce at scale? If selling a patent was banned, both the innovator and society would be denied any benefit from the innovation.
- chrismcb 10y agoIt absolutely furthers the purpose of the patent. As a small time inventor what us my incentive to invent, if I don't have the resources myself? One thing I could do is sell my patent and go invent something new.
- ron0c 10y agoYou will notice that University of Wisconsin Madison is not on that list. This is because Dr. Harry Steenbock (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harry_Steenbock https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harry_Steenbock) with fantastic vision started the Wisconsin Alumni Research Foundation (WARF http://www.warf.org/about-us/about-us.cmsx http://www.warf.org/about-us/about-us.cmsx) where discoveries made at UW get the help of the team of lawyers to guide through the patent process while the royalties paid then go back to the university. Starting with his discovery on fortifying food with Vitamin D by method of ultraviolet light in 1925. WARF is an enormous success at UW and last year alone contributed over $100 million back to the university.
- jessaustin 10y agoIf one were a cynic, one might suspect that UW is just playing the troll itself. Assuming that it isn't, what controls are in place that help UW avoid registering and then seeking royalties on trivial patents? If administrators decided that WARF should instead contribute $200M yearly, wouldn't the resulting patent inflation carry the whole operation into troll territory?
- wmf 10y agoSo far I can only find one trollish lawsuit from WARF (against Apple) so it's not clear how bad they are.
- shagie 10y agoOne can easily browse the patents and newly submitted inventions that are registered to the WARF: http://www.warf.org/technologies/new-patents.cmsx http://www.warf.org/technologies/new-patents.cmsx - the sidebar organizes them by category. The intention is more of "hey entrepreneurs, we've got this technology developed in academia - if you see a business model based on this, talk to us so you can use it." Of note, if you follow the 'technologies - information technology - software' path, you'll note that none of these are actually patents. They're listed as "technologies" instead. There do appear to be some patents listed... things like low profile, ultra wide band antenna and wideband transceiver for antenna array. All that said, one of the distinctions between the patent troll and the warf is that of "the warf is seeking business partnerships for people to use technologies, inventions, and patents developed at the university of madison" and the troll is "buying patents from one party and suing another party for royalties." The business model for the two is completely different.
- Panino 10y agoRelated: publicly funded research that leads to privately held patents results in a form of double taxation. The consumer pays taxes to create the product, then turns around and pays patent-level pricing to buy/use it.
- mathattack 10y agoAnd we have to pay to get access to the research in private journals. (And pay faculty salaries to do peer reviews for the journal) It's at least Triple taxation. Quadruple taxation for the underpaid grad students working on the research to get their degree?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mathattack 10y agoTax dollars at work!
- jxramos 10y agoDing dang UC's letting us down! I really enjoy reading articles that are data driven. I feel like the frequency of such things is on the increase and something just feels good about that showing up in journalism with data I assume can be openly verified with. Someone just posted some interesting data driven analysis of OkCupid data that was pretty intriguing.
- diogenescynic 10y agoThe UCs really aren't what they used to be. The Chancellor at UC Davis had her own students pepper sprayed for a peaceful protest and had a paid board seat at Devry. The UCs are run by crooks and they continue to rip off their students. I regret giving my money to the UC system and if I have kids, will guarantee to send them somewhere else.
- abpavel 10y agoThe primary motivation of a student is to attain a systemic improvement in a body of knowledge, but also to open ones eyes to the realities of the world around us, including socializing and being pepper sprayed. UC is great at all of those. That's why there are so many Nobel prize winners there.
- bogomipz 10y agoCan I ask what does it cost for a resident that is not a dependent?
- andyh2 10y agoI'm a UC Davis student. Agreed, our previous chancellor was not a model public servant. We need a chancellor who can solicit tons of money and has a decent character. If you're a California resident, UC is a deal compared to private and out-of-state public options. UC guarantees free tuition (grant, not loan) for in-state students with family income under $80,000. On the other hand, out of state and international students pay full ticket and subsidize the rest of the students. The real rip-off for UC students is in the large class sizes and inexperienced lecturers and grad students at the podium. Large research institutions are having a lot of trouble ensuring quality of education as enrollments increase and student bodies diversify.
- the_watcher 10y agoSmall clarification: I see that UT is listed as the system, but that's not used for University of California. Is it just Cal? Or the whole system?
- Amorymeltzer 10y agoIt's the whole system. The UC schools are under direct administration of the UC Office of the President, whereas my understanding of Texas is that the University of Texas System schools are independently-run.
- the_watcher 10y agoHow did IV get its hands on a patent filed by Linus Torvalds?
- B1FF_PSUVM 10y agoTransmeta? Linus worked for that company a few years.
- the_watcher 10y agoOf course. Momentary blank where I forgot that people get patents while in the employ of companies.
- vmarsy 10y agoHow can we guarantee those patents went from the schools directly into IV ? What if the school first sold it to a non-patent-troll 3rd party, and then that 3rd party transferred it to IV? Is there a way to follow the history of a particular patent?
- agjacobson 10y agoIt's really outrageous. University research publications behind paywalls, but paid for by us. Now patents, the development paid for by us, in the hands of trolls. And public universities involved. This privatization is outrageous.
- rayiner 10y agoJust because university research is paid for by the public does not mean that all the results should be in the public domain. It would be absurd, for example, for a VC to demand 100% of a company's equity in return for providing the funding necessary to keep the lights on while a product is developed. There is a long history of innovation happening from universities spinning-off patented technology into private companies. E.g. what John Hennessy did with MIPS. It's a great model. If you get rid of it, you'd turn universities into ivory-tower ghettos where researchers would only go if they had no desire to make money.
- CamperBob2 10y agoIt would be absurd, for example, for a VC to demand 100% of a company's equity It's a school, not a business. The idea that there's supposed to be any equity is novel, to put it mildly. Your analogy would make more sense if it described a hypothetical VC who puts in 100% of the money in exchange for no equity at all, because the company is holding a gun to his head.
- Grishnakh 10y agoVCs aren't spending my money. Universities are, because they're subsidized by taxes. If they want to make money which says in private hands, they can do it with their own money, not taxpayer funds. Universities were never meant to be profit-generating entities, but institutions of learning. The people in universities should be happy to have a cushy, tenured academic job; people who have a serious "desire to make money" (beyond that of a professor's salary, which is both good and very stable) don't belong at universities at all, they should be working in the private sector.
- 10y ago
- bogomipz 10y agoI have a question, aren't some of these public universities in some part subsidized by tax payer money at the state level? If this is true, should these patents be exclusive domain of these school's to profit from exclusively? It seems to me that selling patents to these litigious entities impedes progress that might otherwise benefit the same tax paying public that helped underwrite at least some of the research. Am I looking at this wrong? Maybe there are lots of other nuances that my oversimplification doesn't account for. I would be curious to hear what those are if so.
- tzs 10y agoThe author seems to be implicitly assuming that Intellectual Ventures is just a patent troll. IV's business is much more than that. Besides buying outside commercially developed patents (similar to what a troll does), they also employ scientists and engineers directly to develop new things that IV can patent, and they fund outside researchers in exchange for patent rights. At least some of the university patents IV has acquired were through such deals, where IV provides funding for the academic research that leads to the patent, and then IV gets commercialization rights to the patent, with the university getting a cut of any licensing fees IV gets from those patents.
- gravypod 10y agoThe patent that Linus was on for anyone interested: http://www.google.com/patents/US20100169613 http://www.google.com/patents/US20100169613
- gravypod 10y agoThe patent that Linus was on for anyone interested: http://www.google.ch/patents/US20100169613 http://www.google.ch/patents/US20100169613