3 ms·
I guess the thing may be that movies have the luxury of make-believe; that is, they have absolute freedom with these interfaces because as someone else pointed
by cookiecaper 17y ago
I guess the thing may be that movies have the luxury of make-believe; that is, they have absolute freedom with these interfaces because as someone else pointed out, they don't actually have to function. Sure, their dialogs and warning messages are great to convey a single important message, but what about someone who needs to do something on the computer that reports the "lockdown" status of an area? And do you really want it displayed with a huge green bar every time you get into something that was previously protected? Aren't there some situations where discretion is preferable?
In the milder example of the email flying off the screen, who wants to sit around and wait for a few seconds watching these animations in everyday use? Sure, they're a neat one-off or demo, but when you have a stack of emails to pop off, nobody wants to sit around and wait for that cute little animation to finish. You can probably toggle it, but after the first few times, who would leave it on? It seems like something that would just make grandma's computer usage even slower.
I do think that we could probably look at movies more and try to cherry-pick some cool ideas for dialogs or animations, but in general movie widgets, like everything else in the movies, are larger-than-life. They wouldn't work if you tried to deploy them as a real usable UI.
- danhon 17y ago"And do you really want it displayed with a huge green bar every time you get into something that was previously protected? Aren't there some situations where discretion is preferable?" Well - we won't know without trying. But it's clear that in the Read/Write Web Facebook case, a bunch of people had thought that they had logged in to Facebook when in fact they hadn't. And that they didn't even know where they were. You may not want it every time. But at the moment, we don't even have it at all. That's restrictive in the kind of messages we can send out. For emails flying off the screen: the execution is in the detail. A few seconds may be too long. For some people, it may not even be long enough. But the animation isn't necessarily just showing that an email is being sent: it can convey a lot of other information in a clear, yet subtle way. It's interesting that there's no visual cue when an email is sent that distinguishes between sending to a single individual or a group of people, or an even larger group of people.
- stcredzero 17y agoIt's interesting that there's no visual cue when an email is sent that distinguishes between sending to a single individual or a group of people, or an even larger group of people. Pure gold!
- Qz 17y ago...and try to cherry-pick some cool ideas for dialogs... See, I think that's part of the problem. Dialogs pretend that the computer is something that can engage in conversation. But computers don't understand human and (many) humans don't understand computer. So the illusion that computers can engage in these 'dialogs' only exacerbates the problem by perpetuating miscommunications. I think what interfaces need to strive for is a different model of how the user is expected to interact with the computer. It used to be that most people worked with creating and editing files, but I think modern use has shifted towards navigating between places -- unfortunately the old UI paradigm of file management is still dominant among a significant portion of modern software.
- cookiecaper 17y agoWell, I meant dialog like "dialog boxes", not like a discourse. I think the shift represents a change in the primary use of a computer. Early on it was just a thing to let you save and read files written with word processors etc. Now, with the internet, people mostly use it scoot around a global network of files, most of which they have never saved or touched themselves. It would be interesting to see some truly unique concepts of computer usage. KDE wanted to shake it up with KDE 4 and change the whole paradigm, but they ended up essentially just adding widgets and leaving everything else the same. I don't know if there's just no other logical representation for the way we use our computers (doubtful) or if perhaps nobody can seem to think of it because we're too acclimated to the traditional window-based model.
- Qz 17y agoI know you meant dialog boxes, but dialog boxes have that name for a reason. They usually tell the user something and then ask for a response. The problem is that the computer doesn't really understand what it's asking about, it's just a pre-recorded message. Dialog boxes on a computer are the equivalent of the automated phone menus and just as frustrating (although those are getting better with speech recognition). I have some ideas that I think are pretty good but I'm not an expert coder so progress is slow. I think windows is mostly the right idea, but the current implementations are crammed with wastefulness of all types such as application windows that take up unnecessary screen space with menus and buttons that are rarely used (this is getting better, but in my opinion the idea of 'applications' is part of the problem). Another thing is window resizing -- full user control over this is pointless, and a lot of time is wasted resizing windows so you can see things the way you want. Various X Windows versions try to fix this with smart tiling and so on, but I've yet to find one that's really satisfactory. Another sad thing is that even simple drag and drop, which has been around for ages, is poorly implemented in the majority of programs, if at all.